Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: I’d like to hire a personal/executive assistant – any tips or advice?

news.ycombinator.com

211–220 of 244 posts

Re: Ask HN: I’d like to hire a personal/executive assistant – any tips or advice?

#211
post #208

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Sure. It's actually a little sad, heh, but more on that in a second. I followed the route that many composers take: working for other composers. First as kind of a general assistant, then doing the boring tasks required to make the process happen, then managing the rigs, then doing production work but not writing, then orchestrating and/or "filling in the gaps" in some cues, then finally writing. I've kind of done it…

> doing things like automating certain workflows where possible, building some custom tools, etc. The goal is to slowly transition to working as a programmer at Steinberg or Ableton or something like that, and then start my own company. I presume you’ve contacted tantacrul[1] who is now working[2] redesigning Audacity, with a hilarious video on the hellscape of a UI that is Sibelius[3]. I am guessing becoming a UI de…

I haven't contacted him but I love his work!!

Re: Ask HN: I’d like to hire a personal/executive assistant – any tips or advice?

#212

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Nope, because if you are a heavy calendar user there are tons of things that could be trivially shuffled. A calendly link is “I will fit you in only if it’s extremely convenient for me”.

“Here’s the link to my calendly. If you don’t see anything that works in the next week or so, just send me over a few times that would work for you & I can reshuffle things to make one of them work.”

Exactly. From my experience Calendly works 99% of time, and remaining 1% is where it is better to handle it personally than through PA.

Re: Ask HN: I’d like to hire a personal/executive assistant – any tips or advice?

#213

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Calendly is a much cheaper option. Managing my calendar would be the last thing I delegate to PA.

I find calendly depersonalizing and extremely insulting. I.e. the shift of power when someone says "Hey, let's find a time to chat" and the answer is "Here is my calendly link, good luck". I usually break off the conversation there.

If someone says "Hey, let's find a time to chat", would you refer this person to your PA to schedule a call? I hope not, and just like normal people you would look at your calendar and find time slot right away. This is not a use case for Calendly. It is good for asynchronous conversations.

Breaking the conversation at the point, where you are being offered to pick a convenient time looks like a good question for AITA on Reddit.

Re: Ask HN: I’d like to hire a personal/executive assistant – any tips or advice?

#215
post #167
post #138

Throughout my 20s (in my 30s now) I worked as a film composer in Hollywood, land of personal assistants. One thing I took to heart was that the best personal assistants weren't looking to use the opportunity get elsewhere. What you want is someone who wants to stay in that role, because as a lot of other comments here point out, it takes a lot of time for the person to learn enough about you to become truly useful ra…

Ah, based on my experiences with assistants, that is exactly the problem. You either get someone who is under-qualified and does not fulfill expectations, or someone who is great, but wants to pursue a career. It is extremely difficult to find a "stable" assistant.

Did you still have the same problem when you offered the latter enough money to dissuade them from pursuing something else?

Re: Ask HN: I’d like to hire a personal/executive assistant – any tips or advice?

#216
post #208

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I would love to hear a story of your film composing career. Yes, HN is about hackers and tech and stuff like that, but I think that being generally curious about other things, such as film composing, is only adding to the experience here. Anyway... Just wanted to let you know that you made me really curious :)

Sure. It's actually a little sad, heh, but more on that in a second. I followed the route that many composers take: working for other composers. First as kind of a general assistant, then doing the boring tasks required to make the process happen, then managing the rigs, then doing production work but not writing, then orchestrating and/or "filling in the gaps" in some cues, then finally writing. I've kind of done it…

That's an interesting story. Thanks for sharing. Good luck in your future endeavors.

Re: Ask HN: I’d like to hire a personal/executive assistant – any tips or advice?

#217
post #208

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Sure. It's actually a little sad, heh, but more on that in a second. I followed the route that many composers take: working for other composers. First as kind of a general assistant, then doing the boring tasks required to make the process happen, then managing the rigs, then doing production work but not writing, then orchestrating and/or "filling in the gaps" in some cues, then finally writing. I've kind of done it…

That's an interesting story. Thanks for sharing. Good luck in your future endeavors.

Thank you!

Re: Ask HN: I’d like to hire a personal/executive assistant – any tips or advice?

#218

Consider an office manager instead. It better describes the requirements that extend into your organization, and it’s one of the best early hires a growing org can make. If they shine, consider letting them take on HR tasks if you don’t already have an internal HR resource.

Please don’t hire people for business roles where part of their responsibilities are to you individually.

This is absurd.

Re: Ask HN: I’d like to hire a personal/executive assistant – any tips or advice?

#219

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You've made two posts negging this idea without providing any actual rationale whatsoever.

Oh, I thought it was obvious I consider it unethical… administrative/HR roles in particular shouldn’t be [potentially] biased by split responsibilities to a specific individual.

Go be a working exec for a few years in a medium sized business and then advise other execs on HR, how to hire, and on business ethics.

Re: Ask HN: I’d like to hire a personal/executive assistant – any tips or advice?

#220

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Oh, I thought it was obvious I consider it unethical… administrative/HR roles in particular shouldn’t be [potentially] biased by split responsibilities to a specific individual.

Go be a working exec for a few years in a medium sized business and then advise other execs on HR, how to hire, and on business ethics.

Go tell someone else what to do before forming an opinion. Or better, don’t do that either.
Post reply on HN