Live data from Hacker News

Why QR Codes Are Here To Stay

mashable.com

71–74 of 74 posts

Re: Why QR Codes Are Here To Stay

#71
post #28

Here I'll give you a "real world hyperlink": print the damn URL in English so that I can remember it if I don't have my phone handy. If you're running a print ad you can afford a short snappy URL. Bonus, I can even use it on my laptop that doesn't have a QR code app! Or any other browser for that matter! The main problem I have with QR codes is that humans can't read them . Therefore, they will be relegated forever t…

> Here I'll give you a "real world hyperlink": print the damn URL in English so that I can remember it if I don't have my phone handy. Provide both then, because typing a URL is a pain on most mobiles, especially urls more than 5 characters. > If you're running a print ad you can afford a short snappy URL. What sense would it make? You have an existing brand and an existing site, why have to create a new brand and a…

> Provide both then, because typing a URL is a pain on most mobiles, especially urls more than 5 characters.

If people are already running up against 5000 SMS/month limits on their phones, I'd wager that they can spend 20 keypresses typing in a URL for something interesting. Frankly, it's probably the same cognitive load as finding the QR decoder app, lining up a good shot, waiting for the white balance and focus to settle, hitting the shutter button, ...

> What sense would it make? You have an existing brand and an existing site, why have to create a new brand and a new site just to link to that?

Don't understand your point. I'm talking about making a short URL redirecting to whatever the QR code points at, maybe even off the company's existing domain. E.g., http://acme.com/foo

I can't speak to QR code usage in Japan or Korea, I just remember seeing them used in CS course material at my college and none of my fellow students ever used them. Those were real geeks, and they weren't even interested enough to try.

> Wait that has no relevance whatsoever to the previous half of the paragraph, you said "normal people" would always ignore QRCodes, but anyone can recognize a barcode and knows (at least roughly) what it's about.

There's a distinction between recognition, and being able to use them. As far as recognition goes very few non-techy people know what a QR code even does, because there is no obvious indication that it contains a URL. My point was that barcodes usually have the numbers below them and that (IMO) facilitated both consumers and cashiers understanding that it just contains a product number, as opposed to being the Evil Mark of Satan that the red beam reads. It is a more transparent system. I know it seems weird, but for non-geeks, being able to see what is going on is an important step in not demonizing new technology.

> Google Goggles can attempt to do that with all the power of Google behind it.

I could be wrong, but I'm pretty sure all the OCR is done client-side. And what's your point? A QR code containing a URL requires a device with a network connection to provide anything of immediate value.

Re: Why QR Codes Are Here To Stay

#72
post #48
post #31

Earlier quoted context omitted.

>Bonus, I can even use it on my laptop that doesn't have a QR code app! Or any other browser for that matter! hmmm, hmmm, well .. you actually can use QR codes from your laptop - and - any other browser (that supports flash, as the HTML5 webcam API is not yet ready) - i know this, as i created it myself - it's called http://miniqr.com/reader.php (with some paid help from http://www.peterelst.com/ ) does it make sense…

Am I missing something? I don't see how that helps a user to parse a QR they come across in meatspace. Say, on a movie poster or fast food cup. If I'm on a website with a QR code... should that publisher not just use a plain old URL?

One useful way to use QR codes on Web sites is for downloading mobile apps. Instead of copying the URL to your device, or searching through the Market/App Store, you can just scan the QR code from off the screen, and you're right at the app you need to download.

Re: Why QR Codes Are Here To Stay

#73
post #45
post #2

... says the CEO of a QR code startup. I've been anti-QR code for a while—partly just because I like playing devil's advocate—but mainly because I see little benefit and a lot of friction to use "in the real world" Now, please, someone on HN who isn't a QR-preneur tell me a story of how a QR code in the wild made your life better ...

Riding the tram, there was an ad of sth. interesting sticked to the door. The URL and a QR code were printed at the bottom. Instead of opening the browser and typing in the URL on the shaky train I fired up the Goggles app (home screen), pointed it to the code and about 2 seconds and one button later the page was loading in my browser. Given an URL and a QR code above I would always choose to use the QR code just bec…

I agree completely. And if the Barcode Scanner app came standard (or, better yet, if the normal camera app could read QRs on its own), it would be even easier. Just press the "Camera" button on the side and get the code in the viewfinder, then bam - done.

Re: Why QR Codes Are Here To Stay

#74
post #65

I think one of the factors working against the QR code is it does not have a recognizable uniform function. The code can contain an text or data in any number of formats which isn't apparent to the naked eye. The text might be a URL, or it might be a poem, or it could be a vCard. This causes consumer confusion. It's almost like we need standard contextual decorations around the QR codes to hint at the contents. Like…

Assuming you could design icons that appear mostly black to the reader, you could replace the four black pixels in one of the position patterns with an icon (globe for hyperlink, business card for contact info...)
Post reply on HN