Live data from Hacker News

Overloaded: Is there simply too much culture?

theguardian.com

61–70 of 110 posts

Re: Overloaded: Is there simply too much culture?

#61

For me culture means Michelangelo, Umberto Eco and Shakespeare, not House of Cards, Girls, Squid Game.

This definition seems myopic - yes to old/dead white men but excludes women and asians.

> white men

But hold on, I thought race was just a social construct? I can't keep up these days.

Re: Overloaded: Is there simply too much culture?

#62

I'm not overloaded by popular culture, I just ignore most of it. I know what I like, and the rest of it I just pay no attention to. Most popular culture I like is stuff from the last few decades of last century (showing my age I suppose), although occasionally something new comes along that appeals to me, but most new things I just ignore. If someone makes a reference to something I don't get, I'll Google the referen…

I've passively ignored most of what is popular culture since high school. Which is to say I'm not hiding under a rock, but I'm not feeling left out if I don't have my finger on the pulse.

I _always_ miss some film, tv and music when it's current, but I easily catch up on it years later. Theater is the only cultural genre where you 'use it or lose it', and I accept that bargain.

I have learned that expounding on what you don't know makes you sound like an idiot and/or a snob. Boy, it can be very tempting though when people are talking about reality TV empires.

Re: Overloaded: Is there simply too much culture?

#63
> Maintaining my fluency was getting harder and harder: I was a media studies professor who was able to devote hours of my ostensible working day to the task of consuming media. I was still falling far behind, and more so every day. In discussing my struggle to metabolise what felt like a never-ending meal, I’m focusing on television. But television was just part of the larger, overwhelming feast. Around the time television­ options began to expand, so too did the supply­ (and our access) to so many other forms of culture­, from YouTube to digital mixtapes.

In another time and place these would be the insane ramblings of a mad person.

Re: Overloaded: Is there simply too much culture?

#64
"Too many books" was apparently a problem already 2000 years ago; here's Seneca advising his friend against it, in his letter-2:

[quote]

Be careful, though, about your reading in many authors and every type of book. It may be that there is something wayward and unstable in it. You must stay with a limited number of writers and be fed by them if you mean to derive anything that will dwell reliably with you. One who is everywhere is nowhere. Those who travel all the time find that they have many places to stay, but no friendships. The same thing necessarily happens to those who do not become intimate with any one author, but let everything rush right through them. [...]

'But I want to read different books at different times,' you say. The person of delicate digestion nibbles at this and that; when the diet is too varied, though, food does not nourish but only upsets the stomach. So read always from authors of proven worth; and if ever you are inclined to turn aside to others, return afterward to the previous ones. Obtain each day some aid against poverty, something against death, and likewise against other calamities. And when you have moved rapidly through many topics, select one to ponder that day and digest. This is what I do as well [...]

[/quote]

Re: Overloaded: Is there simply too much culture?

#65

The Guardian aims at a particular kind of person who essentially spends their entire life in artistic theory and not the real world. They derive their worth from being able to quote at each other. For those people I'm sure it does feel like an enormous struggle. If you watch for enjoyment rather than as an attempt at gaining social cachet then it's fine.

Maybe you are right, I want to be able to talk and discuss topics with friends and peers. I feel that is hard sometimes to know what others are watching and how it matches my taste. I enjoy as much watching and reading media as I enjoy sharing that experience with others.

If you do not enjoy sharing experiences with others, whatever you see is good if you like it.

> rather than as an attempt at gaining social cachet then it's fine.

At least for me, I do not think that watching iZombie, Dune or Cowboy Bebop makes me look better, but it allows to share good moments with friends. To explain the complete plot of a movie or several episodes from a TV show just for a pun or a quick observations is not what we like.

I am ok with you watching just for yourself, but it seems that you do not approve that I or others like to share opinions and talk about media. Why is that?

Re: Overloaded: Is there simply too much culture?

#66

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This does feel like my opinion on NFTs / Cryptocoins.

Extend the idea of NFTs to actual registered ownership of a thing you care about, like the title of your house, or your rental agreement, rather than a fucking pixelated jpg a child would be ashamed of, and it might look like something a bit more representative of a worthwhile future.

but why? I already have the title to my house

Re: Overloaded: Is there simply too much culture?

#67

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This does feel like my opinion on NFTs / Cryptocoins.

Extend the idea of NFTs to actual registered ownership of a thing you care about, like the title of your house, or your rental agreement, rather than a fucking pixelated jpg a child would be ashamed of, and it might look like something a bit more representative of a worthwhile future.

If you lose your wallet key do you have to move out?

Re: Overloaded: Is there simply too much culture?

#68

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Extend the idea of NFTs to actual registered ownership of a thing you care about, like the title of your house, or your rental agreement, rather than a fucking pixelated jpg a child would be ashamed of, and it might look like something a bit more representative of a worthwhile future.

but why? I already have the title to my house

All other examples of things being done electronically that were done physically go here.

Re: Overloaded: Is there simply too much culture?

#70

"Too many books" was apparently a problem already 2000 years ago; here's Seneca advising his friend against it, in his letter-2: [quote] Be careful, though, about your reading in many authors and every type of book. It may be that there is something wayward and unstable in it. You must stay with a limited number of writers and be fed by them if you mean to derive anything that will dwell reliably with you. One who is…

I can't even keep up with Kim Stanley Robinson. He writes 'em faster than I can read 'em.
Post reply on HN