Live data from Hacker News

The Deep Sea

neal.fun

11–20 of 48 posts

Re: The Deep Sea

#11

OK now I need to go down the rabbit hole of why other mammals don't get the bends. Here goes my evening.

Quick summary, they can but their lungs are structured to partially collapse to limit nitrogen exchange while continuing to exchange oxygen and carbon-dioxide. Sonar is suspected to cause whales to die of the bends.

https://www.whoi.edu/press-room/news-release/how-do-marine-m...

Re: The Deep Sea

#13

OK now I need to go down the rabbit hole of why other mammals don't get the bends. Here goes my evening.

Isn’t a key component of the bends breathing mixed gases while underwater?

Similar to free-diving humans, other mammals are much less susceptible to the bends than human scuba divers. Possibly their innate behavior minimizes the risks further — like slowing their ascent as they get close to the surface?

Re: The Deep Sea

#16

OK now I need to go down the rabbit hole of why other mammals don't get the bends. Here goes my evening.

Not that the other replies are wrong, but it's quite predictable from an evolutionary perspective that the physiology adapts for a range of different environments. Many animals can withstand a large range of temperature, so why not a range of pressure too, as long as it can benefit the animal?

To me, it's more fascinating that land animals like humans can survive at all at ~50x the highest pressure on land. Another fascinating remnant of our oceanic ancestry is the mammalian diving reflex[1].

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diving_reflex

Re: The Deep Sea

#20
The scrolling mechanic was great for communicating scale!

The coolest thought this gave me, that I'd never really considered before:

How little life must have changed in the past 3000 years in the deep ocean? Have we even been adjusting the atmosphere for long enough for the circulation currents to take pH changes that deep?

We've essentially remade the surface of the planet, the lower atmosphere, and the top of the ocean. But in the depths... little of this actually impacts them.

From time to time, a single ship dropping down and coming to rest on the bottom. But those are a drop in the bucket compared to the ocean surface area.

Other than that, life is probably very similar to what it was 5,000, 10,000, 100,000, 1,000,000, 10,000,000 years ago. Before modern humans existed, and certainly before industrial civilization. And probably before our species even existed. Mind bogglingly constant.

Post reply on HN