Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Why are Kyle Rittenhouse articles flagged on HN?

news.ycombinator.com

1–10 of 16 posts

Ask HN: Why are Kyle Rittenhouse articles flagged on HN?

#1
I love HN. It was disturbing to see no debate on one of the biggest trials this decade - your own politics aside. I did some research and found the posts "flagged" or flat out empty. Very concerning.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29283803

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29282469

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29285071

Re: Ask HN: Why are Kyle Rittenhouse articles flagged on HN?

#3
post #2

because the chicoms that control moderation on this site HATE AMERICA FUCK SAN FRANCISCO! FUCK SAN FRANCISCO! FUCK SAN FRANCISCO!

^ Perfect example. You are trying to even get the question flagged. So weird. What happened to actual debate?

Re: Ask HN: Why are Kyle Rittenhouse articles flagged on HN?

#4
They get flagged for a variety of reasons:

- They are considered "off-topic" as outlined by the HN guidelines (Off-Topic: Most stories about politics, or crime, or sports, unless they're evidence of some interesting new phenomenon. Videos of pratfalls or disasters, or cute animal pictures. If they'd cover it on TV news, it's probably off-topic.)

- They are unlikely to result in "good faith" debates about the case given how politically charged the subject matter is

- The comments very quickly devolve into flamewars and/or trolling

I honestly don't think anyone is trying to "squash" debate about the case due to some personal agenda. It's just unlikely that the comment sections on those articles are going to be productive and/or result in anything new or interesting.

Re: Ask HN: Why are Kyle Rittenhouse articles flagged on HN?

#5
there was some discussions, especially of the "pinch to zoom" stories; but there's guildelines against "current news" and it's still a totally flame bait topic.

I'm not sure where non-partisan discussion of the trail might be welcomed. The facts are still very much at issue in the media so its hard to even have a basis for discussion.

Re: Ask HN: Why are Kyle Rittenhouse articles flagged on HN?

#8
It is because it is not the result they wanted. Here is another example:

Truth Social recently open sourced their mastodon fork [0] and that was immediately flagged and not covered by the news even though when they were found to have violated the license, that was heavily voted top of this website. With that, not only HN is already breaking their own guidelines, the bias could not be more clearer.

On another note, just notice how The Verge / Vox had heavily covered the trial and now after the verdict was out, they seemed to have become real quiet about it. It is simply because it is not the result they wanted.

Typical self defence isn't shocking to report is it?

[0] https://truthsocial.com/open-source

Re: Ask HN: Why are Kyle Rittenhouse articles flagged on HN?

#10
post #8

It is because it is not the result they wanted. Here is another example: Truth Social recently open sourced their mastodon fork [0] and that was immediately flagged and not covered by the news even though when they were found to have violated the license, that was heavily voted top of this website. With that, not only HN is already breaking their own guidelines, the bias could not be more clearer. On another note, ju…

> had heavily covered the trial and now after the verdict was out, they seemed to have become real quiet about it

Imagine you're a news agency covering a trial. Once that trial ends, would you expect the number of articles you publish about it (a) go up, (b) go down, or (c) stay about the same?

Post reply on HN