Live data from Hacker News

“The NFT Bay” Shares Multi-Terabyte Archive of ‘Pirated’ NFTs

torrentfreak.com

1–10 of 184 posts

Re: “The NFT Bay” Shares Multi-Terabyte Archive of ‘Pirated’ NFTs

#3
I think the biggest problem the art project will face is that nobody actually wants 19.5TB of not-terribly-good art.

If there wasn't a fun speculative element, then most of the artists would have trouble getting anyone to download their stuff even for free (just like most game devs struggle to get anyone to play their games - even when they're pretty good).

So really, if this art project does succeed it could be an interesting new distribution channel!

Re: “The NFT Bay” Shares Multi-Terabyte Archive of ‘Pirated’ NFTs

#5
Ah yess, when you put something publicly available then claim piracy and copyright infringement when people actually use those "public bits".

Gotta love this logic.So if i don't right-click your precious NFT I don't pirate it, how about if i get it from my browser's image cache?Am i pirating it then or not?(I'm not going into copying and selling, which is more nuanced, but even then one could argue in the same manner).

To me these questions are extremely rhetorical, especially if one believes in the concept of property. If you don't want to freely give people copies of your precious hard work,don't put it on the internet, period, not even under a protected information system. I would further argue on this principle about computer security aswell, but that actually requires understanding how computers work, which the vast majority doesn't know.

By putting your work publicly available you already explicitly give permission on people to copy your bits into their computers(a.k.a viewing).I guess people think machines are like humans and automatically "forget" what they see, thus enforcing the value of copyright.

Re: “The NFT Bay” Shares Multi-Terabyte Archive of ‘Pirated’ NFTs

#7

Soooo the obvious question... when does the NFT of the “The Billion Dollar Torrent” drop?

It already has https://twitter.com/GeoffreyHuntley/status/14618723766819512... and now it's into inception territory. The person who did https://www.thenftbay.org (me) got NFT'ed by VVD (passed in at $17,645.42 USD) and now I've NFT'ed his auction result with the proceeds being diverted to Outreachy internships.

Re: “The NFT Bay” Shares Multi-Terabyte Archive of ‘Pirated’ NFTs

#8
Isn’t the point of NFTs that it verifies ownership, not “you’re the only one that can access the content” (although there are indeed NFTs that can only allow the owner to decrypt the content)? It’s like video game cosmetics - many people can have the same skin, but people you want to impress or show off to can see that you own x, y, and z.

Re: “The NFT Bay” Shares Multi-Terabyte Archive of ‘Pirated’ NFTs

#9

Isn’t the point of NFTs that it verifies ownership, not “you’re the only one that can access the content” (although there are indeed NFTs that can only allow the owner to decrypt the content)? It’s like video game cosmetics - many people can have the same skin, but people you want to impress or show off to can see that you own x, y, and z.

> It’s like video game cosmetics

Video game cosmetics derive their appeal from people using them while they actually play the game, not from showing off the database flag that activates it for the account. With NFTs, the whole game part of the game cosmetics analogy is missing.

Post reply on HN