Live data from Hacker News

German state planning to switch 25,000 PCs to LibreOffice

blog.documentfoundation.org

351–360 of 368 posts

Re: German state planning to switch 25,000 PCs to LibreOffice

#351
post #326

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think the truth between what you say and the other person accusing you of being biased is somewhere in the middle. They basically went too mach ahead of the time. Mind you, the project started 18 years ago! The computing landscape was very different back then. I know what you mean as I was forced by my employer to use Linux on the desktop at that time and it was mediocre - but many things changed in the meantime. P…

the hardware thing was not a problem for us as we could dictate which computers were bought. so computers were bought which would be compatible. our problem was: none of the tools we needed were available in the quality and richness as they exist today. automatic deployment to hundred of PCs at the same time with extensive automatic configuration? session and configuration management per user? departments want to use…

I'm sorry, but I disagree about the two last points. Around 2001/2002 I was doing this kind of work of purchasing new desktops and deployments on hundreds of machines using a combination of PXE and Kickstart (I believe Kickstart appeared in 1998). It was not ideal, but it worked, and each department had their own settings. The only complaint I heard from my colleagues was that they cannot install "little sheep" (one of these gimmicks that would sit on your desktop and distract you). Actually some of them were upset they cannot install games, but they preferred not to voice this concern aloud.

As to your first problem, the lack of software, yes, it was a huge problem then. What we had to use at that time was substandard. I personally suffered (even though I love Linux on the server). Also KDE was unstable and a memory hog, Gnome wasn't much better, and you couldn't just buy more RAM. I'm very happy these days are over.

Re: German state planning to switch 25,000 PCs to LibreOffice

#352

MS Office was so much more functional and nicer to use than libreoffice when I last checked.

The thing that costs 7$/user/month(home version)+119$ for Windows 10 Home is better than the thing that is free, Gee, I wonder why is that? Everyone should use the thing that costs a lot of money for it to just make sense.

Over 15 years you would be paying 1260$(paid 7 per month) for the office. 119$ for windows.

Re: German state planning to switch 25,000 PCs to LibreOffice

#353

This is an opportunity to rant about what makes MS Office so hard to be compatible with. It's a mess of ancient and modern features, that mostly, but not always, work as you'd expect them to, but the overall complexity is mind boggling. This is used by normal humans. Who don't want to spend a lifetime getting good at all this complexity, so they muddle around until stuff gets done. And then you end up with a table in…

The "hard to be compatible" is a feature by design. If it was easy MS would have lost its biggest advantage by now.

Re: German state planning to switch 25,000 PCs to LibreOffice

#354
post #143

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This is the standard reaction I’ve heard so often from experienced Linux users, but you tend to forget all the trouble you’re able to solve because you know what you’re doing. Consider proprietary graphics drivers - ordinary people won’t even know why that is an issue, where to look if the display flickers, or what even drivers are. And that’s just the start of it… I’ve never had a Linux box that didn’t require me to…

None of that matters in this case, since the users don't purchase or administer their computers. The IT department selects appropriate configurations that support the software they need. My university has no problem supporting a Linux laptop and desktop, and Germany's administration would be doing something similar.

I'm not arguing that, but I was specifically responding to parent which referred to their own, personal Linux setup.

Re: German state planning to switch 25,000 PCs to LibreOffice

#355
post #180
post #177

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What "enterprise software" is needed at a public administration? Almost all of it is custom ordered, so Linux compatibility can be a part of the requirements. Outlook is a dumpster fire, and there are perfectly fine alternatives. Very few people actually need the full might of Excel, and you can always RemoteApp it to them, and have the rest use Libre Office. Or heck, provide them with actual tooling better fit for t…

> Very few people actually need the full might of Excel How's the groupware situation on Linux? Mail, calendars, adding shared meeting rooms, etc.

I used Evolution for years, and it worked really well.

Anymore I just keep Outlook web open in a web browser though. Not because Evolution is lacking, I just didn't really see the point in setting it up anymore.

Re: German state planning to switch 25,000 PCs to LibreOffice

#357
post #246

Earlier quoted context omitted.

LOL, damned if you do, damned if you don't > That doesn’t mean you’re free of bias. If anything it means the opposite. Maybe, but at least i know what i talk about. You observe from the outside and talk about "meme-level bad"? do you believe anything BILD and AZ writes? > “Limux worked” and “we solved a whole ton of problems and had to implement printing dialogs, QT interfaces and more” feel like statements somewhat…

> Linux can do something, which windows cannot || : eh, wo cares Exactly. We who have used Linux for a while have had fun a couple of times before asking if Windows is ready for our desktops and the answer was most often a resounding no. Lately I've made do with just Windows and WSL and to be honest, it still isn't ready for my desktop. Recently my laptop had overheated in the bag a number of times. Knowing I would p…

Ads on the logon screen? Or the start menu?

I don't get those on my personal 'home' installs, 'pro' installs, or the enterprise laptop from my employer.

Did your machine get hacked?

Re: German state planning to switch 25,000 PCs to LibreOffice

#358
post #135

Earlier quoted context omitted.

>>LibreOffice lacks no features I would remotely consider using. Yup. I use it all the time just fine, and set the default format to .XLS and .DOC (not the X versions which are bogus MS bastardizations of XML anyway) and I've had no interchange problems. Over the last decade or so, I occasionally see some Excel feature that might be switch-over-worthy, but then the whole MS setup is so much of a hassle I don't bother…

> set the default format to .XLS and .DOC (not the X versions which are bogus MS bastardizations of XML anyway) I don't like the proprietary nature of OOXML formats either, but why are the older formats like .xls and .doc better than them? At least I can unzip a .docx file to extract the media and get the text and formatting in a machine-readable structure, all without the help of an office suite at all.

I mostly find the XLS/DOC formats more compact and they seem a bit more compatible with transferring to Excel vs the X version, but that is just a rough impression, not the result of any explicit testing. I'll give it another look - thx for the tip!

Re: German state planning to switch 25,000 PCs to LibreOffice

#359

I have used LibreOffice, and it makes me cringe. Has it vastly improved the UI in the last three years? That was the last time I installed it, tried using it for three weeks, then uninstalled it. It was like a bad acid trip version of the 1990s.

Have you tried one of the other included UI variants, or did you stick to the default one?

Re: German state planning to switch 25,000 PCs to LibreOffice

#360

This is an opportunity to rant about what makes MS Office so hard to be compatible with. It's a mess of ancient and modern features, that mostly, but not always, work as you'd expect them to, but the overall complexity is mind boggling. This is used by normal humans. Who don't want to spend a lifetime getting good at all this complexity, so they muddle around until stuff gets done. And then you end up with a table in…

I find Impress (LO's Powerpoint equivalent) to be good enough, but definitely don't try presenting the final file with Powerpoint.
Post reply on HN