Live data from Hacker News

Harmonic Coloring: A method for assigning colors to musical pitches

musanim.com

11–20 of 31 posts

Re: Harmonic Coloring: A method for assigning colors to musical pitches

#11
I've often wondered if people with Chromesthesia (who associate sounds with colours and/or colours with sounds) fall into sets of people with similar colour/sound mappings.

"..studies to date have reported that synesthetes and non-synesthetes alike associate high pitched sounds with lighter or brighter colors and low pitched sounds with darker colors, indicating that a common mechanism may underlie those associations in normal adult brains"

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chromesthesia

Re: Harmonic Coloring: A method for assigning colors to musical pitches

#12
I was hoping this would be about using different colours in musical notation, as I think that black-and-white sheet music doesn't use all the visual tools available to modern designers.

It might be hard for musicians to decide what note to play just by looking at an associated colour (especially if they are colour-blind), but there shouldn't be any downside to doing something like "syntax highlighting" for musical notation, where the existing symbols are used, but are coloured based on what type of information they are conveying, e.g. tempo, dynamics, style.

Re: Harmonic Coloring: A method for assigning colors to musical pitches

#13

I was hoping this would be about using different colours in musical notation, as I think that black-and-white sheet music doesn't use all the visual tools available to modern designers. It might be hard for musicians to decide what note to play just by looking at an associated colour (especially if they are colour-blind), but there shouldn't be any downside to doing something like "syntax highlighting" for musical no…

I'd put "syntax highlighing" on the accidentals (maybe red and blue depending on whether it's flat and sharp relative to the scale), and leave everything else alone.

Re: Harmonic Coloring: A method for assigning colors to musical pitches

#15
post #8

Is this something similar to what the site https://144notes.org/ tries to do? Color the pitches?

Not really. 2 crucial differences: first, it’s the degree of the scale (I, ii, III…) that’s given a colour rather than the note name (C, D, E…), meaning the colouring is independent of the key (or octave) it is written in or transposed into. Secondly, the colours used are designed to be similar where their harmonic ‘meaning’ is similar (according to traditional Western music) and vice versa.

Re: Harmonic Coloring: A method for assigning colors to musical pitches

#16

I was hoping this would be about using different colours in musical notation, as I think that black-and-white sheet music doesn't use all the visual tools available to modern designers. It might be hard for musicians to decide what note to play just by looking at an associated colour (especially if they are colour-blind), but there shouldn't be any downside to doing something like "syntax highlighting" for musical no…

You certainly find this kind of thing in numerous beginner books, but I’m skeptical that it’d be of much use for complex scores, or for someone with mastery of sight-reading. We don’t tend to do the same for text, after all. That said, it is easy enough to miss a dynamic marking and plough through a section at the wrong volume. That one might be worthwhile!

Re: Harmonic Coloring: A method for assigning colors to musical pitches

#17

I've often wondered if people with Chromesthesia (who associate sounds with colours and/or colours with sounds) fall into sets of people with similar colour/sound mappings. "..studies to date have reported that synesthetes and non-synesthetes alike associate high pitched sounds with lighter or brighter colors and low pitched sounds with darker colors, indicating that a common mechanism may underlie those associations…

[deleted]

Re: Harmonic Coloring: A method for assigning colors to musical pitches

#18

I've often wondered if people with Chromesthesia (who associate sounds with colours and/or colours with sounds) fall into sets of people with similar colour/sound mappings. "..studies to date have reported that synesthetes and non-synesthetes alike associate high pitched sounds with lighter or brighter colors and low pitched sounds with darker colors, indicating that a common mechanism may underlie those associations…

From what ive gathered (doing interactive light/sound stuff and chatting with folks at CymaSpace) the issue is that its subjective. Synaesthetes are often frustrated with color to pitch mapping that claims it is "inherent" because the root color (this author picked blue because "it seemed settled") is the creators personal synaesthetic correlation. The issue gets complex when you consider what training set makes each synaesthete build the correlations between colors, moods, sounds, etc.

The article its-self is rad in that the circle of fifths is very much a "relative" thing to begin with so we are actually seeing some pretty "flavorful" results- but the search for the "true color of sound" is tough when light is 430-730 trillion hz and audio is 20-20 thousand hz. The factor that you then are dividing or transposing by is arbitrary.

Re: Harmonic Coloring: A method for assigning colors to musical pitches

#19

I've always been curious why the visible light spectrum appears to "wrap around". Why does the color wheel appear continuous? Is it related to the fact that the frequency range is about an octave?

The L-cones that detect red color also are sensitive to violet light. You can see some of that in some of the curves here: https://biology.stackexchange.com/questions/51870/can-red-co...

Re: Harmonic Coloring: A method for assigning colors to musical pitches

#20
Musical intervals map mathematical ratios to emotional perception (i.e. all minor thirds: feel similar, are { lower, (6/5)*lower } frequency pairs). For a long time I've wondered if there's anything analogous in the world of color (since both are waves), but have been unsatisfied with the non-answers I've found.
Post reply on HN