Live data from Hacker News

Chromium: Permit blocking of view-source: with URLBlocklist

chromium-review.googlesource.com

11–20 of 136 posts

Re: Chromium: Permit blocking of view-source: with URLBlocklist

#11

What are the implications of this? Can’t you just curl/wget the html?

Chrome uses a `view-source` scheme to trigger showing the source of a web page. This change allows Chrome Enterprise administrators to add `view-source:*` to their blocklist so Chrome instances governed by an enterprise policy with that enabled (like at a school or company) wouldn't be able to visit those pages and so wouldn't be able to view source in the browser.

Re: Chromium: Permit blocking of view-source: with URLBlocklist

#12
post #3

Some more context at https://bugs.chromium.org/p/chromium/issues/detail?id=895462 : > With Schools using Google Forms as a testing platform, students are able to use this shortcut to search through the source of the page, and determine the correct answers.

Sounds like these students are learning more in the process of cheating than they'd learn from the multiple-choice quiz.

Re: Chromium: Permit blocking of view-source: with URLBlocklist

#13

  > With Schools using Google Forms as a testing platform, students are able to use this shortcut to search through the source of the page, and determine the correct answers.
So they're serving the answers with the questions, and get annoyed when the students figure this out. What a lark. How about using a system which doesn't do that?

Re: Chromium: Permit blocking of view-source: with URLBlocklist

#15
For context, this is is not allowing websites to prevent View Source for all users. Rather it is a setting that administrators can set on Google Chrome installations within their company/school/etc.

That said, I highly doubt that Google would take this feature request seriously if this were not associated with another Google property. For example, I can't imagine that if Typeform users opened a similar bug ticket that it would see any traction. To me this highlights a danger I had not considered before around the monopoly power of Google - inane requests that would benefit properties within the Google ecosystem get undue consideration despite it harming the broader ecosystem.

Re: Chromium: Permit blocking of view-source: with URLBlocklist

#17
post #3

Some more context at https://bugs.chromium.org/p/chromium/issues/detail?id=895462 : > With Schools using Google Forms as a testing platform, students are able to use this shortcut to search through the source of the page, and determine the correct answers.

That feels like some hardcore X Y problem.

Re: Chromium: Permit blocking of view-source: with URLBlocklist

#18

This is for the chromeos devices/managed chrome browsers [1]. From the bug [2] it looks like this was relevant in a school setting, where this is common. So the school hands out some chromebooks and wants to use that managed environment to prevent kids cheating on quizzes by looking at source code. DRM and related technologies are an effort to wrest control of devices away from their owners, and give control the manu…

Why would viewing HTML+JS source-code reveal correct answers to a school quiz? It certainly doesn’t have to.

Re: Chromium: Permit blocking of view-source: with URLBlocklist

#19
post #15

For context, this is is not allowing websites to prevent View Source for all users. Rather it is a setting that administrators can set on Google Chrome installations within their company/school/etc. That said, I highly doubt that Google would take this feature request seriously if this were not associated with another Google property. For example, I can't imagine that if Typeform users opened a similar bug ticket tha…

I don't think your theory fits the facts...

The bug is from 2018, and was fixed three years later. So it doesn't seem like there was any kind of special prioritization going on here. It was also fixed by a person working at Microsoft, not by somebody at Google.

Re: Chromium: Permit blocking of view-source: with URLBlocklist

#20
post #3

Some more context at https://bugs.chromium.org/p/chromium/issues/detail?id=895462 : > With Schools using Google Forms as a testing platform, students are able to use this shortcut to search through the source of the page, and determine the correct answers.

That feels like some hardcore X Y problem.

Dear StackOverflow, students keep cheating by looking at the page source and finding the multiple choice option with the id "correct-answer".

How do I add a new feature to Chromium, submit a pull request to Google, get it past their various layers of checks and policies, and mandate that all schools use this new option?

Post reply on HN