Live data from Hacker News

Kazakhstan to restrict crypto miners amid power shortages

eurasianet.org

341–350 of 361 posts

Re: Kazakhstan to restrict crypto miners amid power shortages

#341

Earlier quoted context omitted.

So you think I'm a multi-level marketer? Is it even possible to prove otherwise? I just happen to believe in that project and like to talk about it. Am I supposed to not talk about this stuff? I don't particularly care that energy is being spent on cryptocurrency. What I hate is the fact that energy is being spent on bitcoin in particular. The energy is not supposed to be wasted, it's supposed to buy us something . N…

> So you think I'm a multi-level marketer? Is it even possible to prove otherwise? I just happen to believe in that project and like to talk about it. And do you own any Monero?

I own zero XMR right now.

Re: Kazakhstan to restrict crypto miners amid power shortages

#342

Earlier quoted context omitted.

So you think I'm a multi-level marketer? Is it even possible to prove otherwise? I just happen to believe in that project and like to talk about it. Am I supposed to not talk about this stuff? I don't particularly care that energy is being spent on cryptocurrency. What I hate is the fact that energy is being spent on bitcoin in particular. The energy is not supposed to be wasted, it's supposed to buy us something . N…

> Namely, a decentralized, private, anonymous, uncensorable, unsanctionable digital cash network. In other words, the perfect ability to money launder, evade taxes and purchase contraband. Great. But what would a law-abiding person do with this?

Whatever a law-abiding person does. We should not be subjected to total government surveillance because someone somewhere might evade taxes or launder money. We fight hard to maintain our privacy in all fronts, there's no reason for finances to be any different.

Re: Kazakhstan to restrict crypto miners amid power shortages

#343

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I wonder how much coal China burned to fabricate all the computers necessary for you to post this and for everyone else to read it.

It's cliche at this point, but: https://thenib.com/mister-gotcha/ I'm guessing since there are no hypocrites in crypto you are all using non-fiat "coins" to pay your bills and buy groceries, right?

[flagged]

Re: Kazakhstan to restrict crypto miners amid power shortages

#344

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Seems fine to me. I already have nuclear irradiated genes, I'm sterile, and I prefer nature for company over human beings. (If you were sarcastically implying that no one would volunteer, you are mistaken. I encourage making your point more clearly and with less sarcasm, since a worthwhile discussion is possible if you do so.)

I was a bit sarcastic, but the effects on real estate values alone prevent many from wanting to live near a plant. The sarcasm came from the crypto part. The idea that swaths of US land would be devalued for the latest crypto pump and dump project makes me laugh and die inside. I mean Solana is actually pretty cool. But all other crypto projects of which I am aware do not add value to our species as a whole. So addin…

Wait, so you mean we’re solving housing prices too?!! :-)

Re: Kazakhstan to restrict crypto miners amid power shortages

#345

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Seems fine to me. I already have nuclear irradiated genes, I'm sterile, and I prefer nature for company over human beings. (If you were sarcastically implying that no one would volunteer, you are mistaken. I encourage making your point more clearly and with less sarcasm, since a worthwhile discussion is possible if you do so.)

I was a bit sarcastic, but the effects on real estate values alone prevent many from wanting to live near a plant. The sarcasm came from the crypto part. The idea that swaths of US land would be devalued for the latest crypto pump and dump project makes me laugh and die inside. I mean Solana is actually pretty cool. But all other crypto projects of which I am aware do not add value to our species as a whole. So addin…

> but the effects on real estate values alone prevent many from wanting to live near a plant.

So what you're really saying between the lines, is that nuclear power will lead to affordable housing?

Re: Kazakhstan to restrict crypto miners amid power shortages

#346

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Ironically, ETH switching to PoS is the reason I am holding the currency. In the future I expect all PoW cryptocurrencies to be banned, or severely hobbled, because of their electricity usage and e-waste. I have a long bet on ETH specifically because of its eventual move to PoS. Bitcoin doesn't even have a plan, and when the legal landscape changes it will be in the worst position to pivot. We'll just have to see wha…

Nah, I don't think it can be banned. At least not in the non-authoritarian parts of the world. Even if it is, they would need to break my fingers to prevent me running a Bitcoin node. And I will get the blocks via Satellite. If there was a credible threat, we would go somewhere it is not. If your economic thesis is based on hoping the government bans something, why are you even playing with state-resistant decentrali…

"If your economic thesis is based on hoping the government bans something, why are you even playing with state-resistant decentralized monetary systems? "

Because I want to make money? I don't see why that matters.

Re: Kazakhstan to restrict crypto miners amid power shortages

#347

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Ironically, ETH switching to PoS is the reason I am holding the currency. In the future I expect all PoW cryptocurrencies to be banned, or severely hobbled, because of their electricity usage and e-waste. I have a long bet on ETH specifically because of its eventual move to PoS. Bitcoin doesn't even have a plan, and when the legal landscape changes it will be in the worst position to pivot. We'll just have to see wha…

Nah, I don't think it can be banned. At least not in the non-authoritarian parts of the world. Even if it is, they would need to break my fingers to prevent me running a Bitcoin node. And I will get the blocks via Satellite. If there was a credible threat, we would go somewhere it is not. If your economic thesis is based on hoping the government bans something, why are you even playing with state-resistant decentrali…

I don't need or want the technology to be banned. I want mining operations to be illegal in the US, and I want it to be illegal to convert to/from USD.

If you still want to use it then, enjoy.

Re: Kazakhstan to restrict crypto miners amid power shortages

#348
post #70

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Computers also generate heat. Wish I could use cryptocurrency miners for my heating needs. Why burn fuel or pass current through resistances for that? Realistically? Cost. If your goal is to heat a space, it's much cheaper and more reliable to NOT use thousands of dollars of silicon. Doing calculations based on the site below, you might be able to heat a smallish bedroom with a very beefy PC. I can get a space heat…

I already have an rtx gpu. It nets about 8$ of eth a day. Uses 250w. So that's around 1$ of power a day. And enough wattage to heat my office. So I can get paid to keep my room at a nice temperature. This is why I mine now

Using adsorption chillers [0] you can use the heat to also cool down your office.

[0] https://www.technologyreview.com/2011/03/30/196054/using-hea...

Re: Kazakhstan to restrict crypto miners amid power shortages

#350
post #162

Earlier quoted context omitted.

A factory provides jobs to locals. A factory stimulates the economy by creating local economic activity (suppliers, logistics, construction, restaurants). A crypto operation might provide a small fraction of everything above while also producing nothing of tangible value to society.

Doesn't matter how "tangible" the value is if foreigners are paying for it.

Dutch disease is a thing even when the economic value isn’t being frequent dismissed as a Ponzi-adjacent scam, precisely because of foreigners paying for stuff in one sector disproportionately to all the others.

I’m not an economist, so I doubt my understanding is either deep or broad enough to make a proper critique in Kazakhstan’s case.

Post reply on HN