Live data from Hacker News

Firefox 94 advertises VPN in new private browsing tabs

bugzilla.mozilla.org

21–30 of 56 posts

Re: Firefox 94 advertises VPN in new private browsing tabs

#21

Why isn't there a FOSS browser? Why is building FOSS OSes more popular than FOSS browsers? Edit: Ok, I'll see if I can compile the source. (Firefox is foss)

Aren't both Firefox and Chromium open-source? I'd say the answer to why aren't there more like there used to be is because it's too large an undertaking to actually keep up.

Re: Firefox 94 advertises VPN in new private browsing tabs

#22
post #14

Do you want Mozilla to rely on Google's money, or make their own money, pick one.

Please take my goddamn money. Let me pay for the actual browser, with that money going to browser development. I'll do it. Many others will do it. But this ad and "partner" shit is frustrating and wrong.

Re: Firefox 94 advertises VPN in new private browsing tabs

#23

> So let me be really clear: STOP PUTTING ADS IN THE GOD DAMNED WEB BROWSER! I DON'T WANT YOUR VPN! I WILL NEVER WANT YOUR VPN! YES. How can Mozilla be so out of touch? Do they not understand the fact people use their browser because it supports uBlock Origin? We need to repeat this loud and clear until they get it.

I use Firefox. I don't use an ad blocker, but I do use Firefox's tracking protection, and first party isolation.

If Mozilla doesn't track with this ad, I'm _okay_ with it.

Re: Firefox 94 advertises VPN in new private browsing tabs

#25

> My new tab window should have no advertisements in it, because you are a nonprofit. Basically, I can't agree with that. As a user who is unable to contribute to the development of Firefox. I'd love to see my favorite product have a stable, independent cash flow that comes from a product that doesn't conflict with the company's culture (i.e., protecting privacy). Anyway, at least, this is much better than the crypto…

I would prefer a 10$ a year subscription with no telemetry, keeping plugin support

Re: Firefox 94 advertises VPN in new private browsing tabs

#26
post #10
post #3

It was decent up until the last half. The all caps nature of your post was unnecessary and childish, and while it makes sense to be upset at Mozilla's mismanagement and ads in your browser, you cite needlessly off-topic examples where Mozilla should actually be doing something (aside from the color scheme part).

Does Mozilla really need a VR research team?

Browsers are at the forefront of interfacing with the web.

If VR is coming to the web, Mozilla need to at least be ready for this, if not leading it.

Re: Firefox 94 advertises VPN in new private browsing tabs

#27

> So let me be really clear: STOP PUTTING ADS IN THE GOD DAMNED WEB BROWSER! I DON'T WANT YOUR VPN! I WILL NEVER WANT YOUR VPN! YES. How can Mozilla be so out of touch? Do they not understand the fact people use their browser because it supports uBlock Origin? We need to repeat this loud and clear until they get it.

I use Firefox. I don't use an ad blocker, but I do use Firefox's tracking protection, and first party isolation. If Mozilla doesn't track with this ad, I'm _okay_ with it.

ads can be used to track you (profile you), and even as malware vector.

Re: Firefox 94 advertises VPN in new private browsing tabs

#28
I have not seen the ad and hence speak somewhat uninformed. I will just present and alternate view.

I think a lot of people will be unaware about the fact that in terms of sharing information with your ISP and others, you are no more secure by using "private browsing".

If Mozilla can help educate some of these people, then I cannot fault them for that. But as I started by saying I have not seen the actual ad, just trying to present an alternate view.

Re: Firefox 94 advertises VPN in new private browsing tabs

#29
On macOS, I started using testing Orion [0] when the last discovery of ad-injection into Firefox was posted. While it isn’t perfect, and it’s a closed beta, it actually works quite well.

But ostensibly the best feature is that the browser will have a “pro” tier with extra features that can be paid for, and a major selling point of Orion is that it has literally zero telemetry, by design. I didn’t imagine a decade ago that I’d be begging to pay for a browser, but here I am. I would love to pay Mozilla for Firefox if it meant that I knew I wasn’t going to be advertised VPN software.

Sure, I could pay for a Firefox VPN, but would that make the ads go away? I’m not sure. I would rather pay for Firefox, the browser, and have no ads or studies, but I can’t.

[0]: https://browser.kagi.com/

Re: Firefox 94 advertises VPN in new private browsing tabs

#30
post #10
post #3

It was decent up until the last half. The all caps nature of your post was unnecessary and childish, and while it makes sense to be upset at Mozilla's mismanagement and ads in your browser, you cite needlessly off-topic examples where Mozilla should actually be doing something (aside from the color scheme part).

Does Mozilla really need a VR research team?

There are precedents from the previous wave of attempts at VR: "MICROSOFT AND NETSCAPE TEAM UP ON VRML STANDARD" (1997) [1]

[1] https://techmonitor.ai/technology/microsoft_and_netscape_tea...

Post reply on HN