Live data from Hacker News

Get started making music

learningmusic.ableton.com

71–80 of 152 posts

Re: Get started making music

#71
post #33

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That's a pretty common beginner's trap, to have your motivation be to release music rather than in creating music itself. For basically any beginner you need many years to get to the point where that should be a consideration. Your main motivation should be fun and enjoyment of making the music. Ironically this is what actually differentiates the greats from those that struggle: the former make music primarily for th…

> Your main motivation should be fun and enjoyment of making the music. It's much like brain surgery. People assume you should start out treating people's illnesses and curing them, but the successful brain surgeons know that you should spend your early years just having fun and enjoy playing around inside people's skulls. It's such a rush the first time you probe someone's central gyrus and see their arms twich. Don…

I don't think my music is bad enough that it will make people braindead

Re: Get started making music

#72

Ableton was one of my Lockdown amusements last year. A few weeks playing around with it resulted in this https://youtu.be/I3XrZOw8ZJA

really awesome sounding!

yesterday i’ve had some fun replicating Nightcall by Ravinsky, really recommend that if you’re looking for something (easy) to reproduce next, it also helps, that originals stems are made available by author

i’d also suggest using side-chain compression, which basically gives the synths the ducking effect (https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=fOlOAqgBNM0)

Re: Get started making music

#73
post #70

I feel like this crowd would be more interested in Pure Data: https://puredata.info/ It's an open source visual programming language for music (with some plug ins for visualizations, too). Years ago, I had fun with it, taking Rock Band guitars and turning them into synths, or "scratching" wav files with a DJ Hero controller.

[deleted]

Re: Get started making music

#74

A small anecdote: Back when I was still a little kid I had an awful music teacher in school. He would throw all the theory on the whiteboard but never explained how it actually relates to the music itself. I would've loved to know so I asked how this strange mathematical stuff of 4/4ths makes music and he told me to learn it or I'd fail but nothing actually relating to my question. So I always had a bit of antipathy…

What you needed was something more like this:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ygn7ORgPbEE

(some snippets of composer/conductor/pianist Leonard Berstein explaining some musical concepts to young people using examples from pop/rock music).

Re: Get started making music

#75
post #60

I always liked listening to edm and when I first got to know that you just need a laptop and DAW to make tracks the idea of becoming an edm artist sounded exciting and glamorous to me. (like alan walker, martin grx) I installed FL Studio and tried my hand on making some beats ( https://youtube.com/channel/UClKt2vzomuegCDA45SU6FbA/videos ). Before I spent too much time on it I released it's actually less about making…

> you just need a laptop and DAW to make tracks You just need pen and paper to unify gravity and quantum mechanics. You just need a laptop to write the next TikTok. > less about making catchy beats and more about the marketing That's a common complaint from unsuccessful artists. Michael Jackson spent a ton of money on marketing his last album and it was a total flop.

In a market oversaturated with good talent, marketing has to be the differentiator.

Re: Get started making music

#76

I always liked listening to edm and when I first got to know that you just need a laptop and DAW to make tracks the idea of becoming an edm artist sounded exciting and glamorous to me. (like alan walker, martin grx) I installed FL Studio and tried my hand on making some beats ( https://youtube.com/channel/UClKt2vzomuegCDA45SU6FbA/videos ). Before I spent too much time on it I released it's actually less about making…

I don't think what you said is all that different from people who want to be a successful writer but don't really want to write.

Re: Get started making music

#77
post #70

I feel like this crowd would be more interested in Pure Data: https://puredata.info/ It's an open source visual programming language for music (with some plug ins for visualizations, too). Years ago, I had fun with it, taking Rock Band guitars and turning them into synths, or "scratching" wav files with a DJ Hero controller.

It is an interesting language, but it is very low-level and it lacks many functions that you have to implement from scratch. For example, as I remember, there is no filter with custom response curve. Or there is a low-pass filter but you cannot choose its type, rolloff slope or modulate it with an oscillator. There is no spectrum viewer.

So you will have to reimplement functions that are built-in into modern DAWs. And it is not an easy task, for example, to implement filters you'll have to deal with equations with complex numbers.

Re: Get started making music

#78
post #70

I feel like this crowd would be more interested in Pure Data: https://puredata.info/ It's an open source visual programming language for music (with some plug ins for visualizations, too). Years ago, I had fun with it, taking Rock Band guitars and turning them into synths, or "scratching" wav files with a DJ Hero controller.

I’ll also plug VCV Rack[1], an open source emulator for modular synthesizers. It takes the cost of exploring modular synthesis down from “prohibitive” (thousands of dollars easily) to “zero”. Really cool project that’s come a long way in the last few years.

[1] https://vcvrack.com/

Re: Get started making music

#79
post #31

A small anecdote: Back when I was still a little kid I had an awful music teacher in school. He would throw all the theory on the whiteboard but never explained how it actually relates to the music itself. I would've loved to know so I asked how this strange mathematical stuff of 4/4ths makes music and he told me to learn it or I'd fail but nothing actually relating to my question. So I always had a bit of antipathy…

Sometimes teachers have a negative net value huh? Brings up the point that if the education system can't properly teach a subject, maybe we're all better better off with it just not teaching the subject.

[deleted]

Re: Get started making music

#80
This is a nitpick.

For clarity: the company/vendor is Ableton, their flagship product is Live. Ableton Live is its full name. Ableton Live. Compare Apple Logic Pro, Steinberg Cubase, Image Line FL Studio, and so on.

Respectfully, please try not to refer to the product as Ableton, e.g. "I made […] in Ableton". It was done in Ableton Live, or just Live in a pinch.

(This used to really wind me up back in the old days, but I've calmed down about it. I can't begin to imagine how the Ableton marketing/branding teams feel about the mismatch. Maybe it's just me, this isn't a hill to die on.)

Post reply on HN