Live data from Hacker News

Get started making music

learningmusic.ableton.com

51–60 of 152 posts

Re: Get started making music

#51
post #38

If you’re into this sort of thing — a few years back, a little-known artist named Grimes posted a really great tutorial on using Ableton to make music. https://web.archive.org/web/20150831081620/http://actuallygr...

Yeah, I remember that tutorial. For those who do not know: she's married to Elon Musk now.

Edit: Apparently broken up by now.

Re: Get started making music

#54

All you need to make music is an iPhone and some ideas. I make music like this on my phone after the kids has gone to bed. I simply use Garageband and a couple of plugins. Sometimes I connect to a physical keyboard. https://youtu.be/iS-gRUzPrKI

Ableton seems to have the in-the-know buzz though. Just looked at the UI for Ableton for the first time today; know how it's preferred by some over Garage Band?

There are quite some videos out there from famous producers showing their craft, and many use Ableton (Deadmau5, Timbaland) or Logic Pro (Armin van Buuren). It helps develop the buzz.

Re: Get started making music

#55
post #38

If you’re into this sort of thing — a few years back, a little-known artist named Grimes posted a really great tutorial on using Ableton to make music. https://web.archive.org/web/20150831081620/http://actuallygr...

Yeah, I remember that tutorial. For those who do not know: she's married to Elon Musk now. Edit: Apparently broken up by now.

They broke up recently.

Re: Get started making music

#56

All you need to make music is an iPhone and some ideas. I make music like this on my phone after the kids has gone to bed. I simply use Garageband and a couple of plugins. Sometimes I connect to a physical keyboard. https://youtu.be/iS-gRUzPrKI

Ableton seems to have the in-the-know buzz though. Just looked at the UI for Ableton for the first time today; know how it's preferred by some over Garage Band?

They're not competing with each-other... Ableton's a pro tool. Garageband for iOS is a fun app aimed at beginners, which allows one to experiment, record, have fun and maybe even produce some tracks. It's surprisingly capable, although it's focused on loops and presets.

Re: Get started making music

#58
post #19

Pretty cool. If you like Ableton but would prefer to use a more obscure underdog for some reason, there's Bitwig.

Obscure, and yet technically superior in all ways... Bitwig == Ableton++, after Ableton management vetoed engineering's desire to do a major and much needed architectural rewrite. As I understand it, they didn't see how tearing down all the legacy code and building something more stable and modular would help them sell more licenses the next year. Hence, we have Bitwig. I like it as one of the rare examples of engine…

Bitwig was founded in 2009 (from Wikipedia). Seems like it’s worked out fine for both Bitwig and Ableton.

Re: Get started making music

#59

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> I installed FL Studio and tried my hand on making some beats ( https://youtube.com/channel/UClKt2vzomuegCDA45SU6FbA/videos ). Before I spent too much time on it I released From 1990 to 2007, I owned a (vinyl) record store (B&M then ecomm) that catered to DJs. I got to listen to quite a bit of "dance music". The early, mid, and even late 90s was jammed packed with creativity and innovative sounds. Eventually things…

Dance music seems awful simple but if it's being played live there's a very simple quality test which is, are people dancing to the music? If you're just on your computer in your room, making beats and perhaps not even moving to them because to you it seems trivial and all about the marketing, you might be glossing over a fundamental part of the music. Seeing what moves an actual dance floor full of real people is im…

True. But there is a difference between minimal (e.g., Detroit legend Robert Hood) and something that is half-baked (e.g., too many examples to list).

Dancing or not, the music is still music and it has to stand on its own, at least in the context of its peers.

When something is cheap and easy to produce and release, there is an overabundance. That glut clogs up the environment (read: the haystack buries the golden needles). Plastic seemed like a great idea at first but then we've (kinda) come to realize cheap and easy ain't such a good thing ;)

Re: Get started making music

#60

I always liked listening to edm and when I first got to know that you just need a laptop and DAW to make tracks the idea of becoming an edm artist sounded exciting and glamorous to me. (like alan walker, martin grx) I installed FL Studio and tried my hand on making some beats ( https://youtube.com/channel/UClKt2vzomuegCDA45SU6FbA/videos ). Before I spent too much time on it I released it's actually less about making…

> you just need a laptop and DAW to make tracks

You just need pen and paper to unify gravity and quantum mechanics.

You just need a laptop to write the next TikTok.

> less about making catchy beats and more about the marketing

That's a common complaint from unsuccessful artists. Michael Jackson spent a ton of money on marketing his last album and it was a total flop.

Post reply on HN