Live data from Hacker News

What caused all the supply chain bottlenecks?

twitter.com

311–320 of 690 posts

Re: What caused all the supply chain bottlenecks?

#311

For an alternate take, see https://www.nationalreview.com/2021/10/the-real-culprit-in-o... ... These posts raise some interesting points I hadn't thought about (I don't see any problem with Next-in accounting). But it seems that lack of inventory isn't the only problem, throughput at ports is also an issue, and the ports themselves are limited at what changes they can make to fix these issues, partly due to profits (…

[deleted]

Re: What caused all the supply chain bottlenecks?

#312
post #258
post #250

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Genuine question: 2020 feels like the biggest shock to the economy in a while yet it was one of the best years for most big businesses. If Jeff Bezos didn't feel the shock from 2020 then when will he feel the shock?

>2020 feels like the biggest shock to the economy in a while yet it was one of the best years for most big businesses. by what metric?

Stock market valuations

Re: What caused all the supply chain bottlenecks?

#313

Long story short: Big spike in demand in a very short period of time.

How big of a spike and a spike in what? Consider the size of the import market in its entirety and how much of a spike would be needed to disrupt it. Don't think more PPE is clogging up ports.

Re: What caused all the supply chain bottlenecks?

#314
All of this talk about supply chain issues are totally missing the point in my opinion. So many articles (and tweet chains I guess) have been written about supply chain issues, yet every one of them seems to ignore the elephant in the room which is demand for goods vs services. Over the course of the pandemic there was a staggering re-balancing of consumer spending [0] from services to goods, to which supply chains have not caught up.

If the spending doesn't re-balance again as restrictions are lifted this is not a temporary supply chain issue caused by just-in-time methodology, it's just the new normal.

[0] https://apps.bea.gov/iTable/iTable.cfm?ReqID=19&step=2#reqid...

EDIT: That link is broken, should have been this https://apps.bea.gov/iTable/iTable.cfm?reqid=19&step=3&isuri...

Re: What caused all the supply chain bottlenecks?

#315

He's right to point out that the obsession with RoE is a big part of the problem. He's wrong to suggest that the billionaire class and founders will solve the problem if we only trust them and let them keep their money. Founders have just as much incentive to optimize the excess out of the system, they just call it "disruptive innovation" by which they mean tweaking how the system works so that they can squeeze out p…

Yep, the capital owning class just doesn't care if their businesses go into shock because they already have their cash in hand. They'll never go back to pre-ROE days because they'd have to live with less money and worse less control. While they still have personal reserves in the billions they can decide the fate of their ventures but if say 20% of their current cash was on the balance sheets of corporations with boa…

R&D in 20 small companies is less effective than in 3 big ones due to less diverse teams and more inefficient double spending, e.g. twenty $5M microscopes utilized at 15% versus three at 90%.

Re: What caused all the supply chain bottlenecks?

#316
post #298

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> People are saying "why didn't we buffer up more" ? Well, there we go. Play Factorio. You'll see just how bad buffers are in a simulated factory. A shortage in real life causes critical issues for real people. A shortage in Factorio does not.

Do you have an actual refutation though? Why does buffering perform better in real-world factories than the simulated ones in Factorio?

The cost of some shortages is measured in lives. With such shortages, preventing the shortage is better than mitigating the shortage. Mitigating the shortage is in turn better than not mitigating the shortage.

A buffer gives us time. That time can be used to save lives.

A buffer absorbs a short term disruption in a supplier which prevents the shortage. A buffer gives time to look for another supplier in a long term disruption. A buffer delays a shortage when no other supplier is feasible.

Re: What caused all the supply chain bottlenecks?

#317

He's right to point out that the obsession with RoE is a big part of the problem. He's wrong to suggest that the billionaire class and founders will solve the problem if we only trust them and let them keep their money. Founders have just as much incentive to optimize the excess out of the system, they just call it "disruptive innovation" by which they mean tweaking how the system works so that they can squeeze out p…

why blame the players rather than the game? It's the government's job to prioritize long term health of the nation

Plenty of people warned about the hazards of allowing these companies to outsource everything, government did nothing. Mostly because they are bought off by lobbyists. This could have pretty easily been prevented by putting tariffs on key industries to keep manufacturing here or at least in North America

Re: What caused all the supply chain bottlenecks?

#318
post #256

This is like a Rorschach test. There is truly something for everyone. What caused all the supply chains bottlenecks? Hard Left: "It's the fault of *capitalism*!" Hard Right: "It's the fault of *unions*!" Soft Left: "Truckers don't have a living wage!" Soft Right: "We stopped producing because of lockdowns!" Greens: "It's *climate change* disrupting the economy!" Libertarians: "*Government mismanagement of ports!*" YI…

Staying at home and collecting unemployment.

Re: What caused all the supply chain bottlenecks?

#319
post #269

Earlier quoted context omitted.

None of this is the point, though. The point is that Amazon wouldn't have achieved what it has if Bezos was forced to slowly divest control of his company over the last two decades. Bezos does not have his cash in hand, for the most part. To the extent that he does have cash in hand, he has already paid taxes on that cash. To the extent that he has not paid taxes on his wealth, he is fully incentivized by the share p…

> Bezos does not have his cash in hand, for the most part. To the extent that he does have cash in hand, he has already paid taxes on that cash. What a lot of high wealthy individuals are doing is using their portfolios as collateral against lines of credit. The LOCs give them cash to fund their lifestyle, and they don't have to liquidate their portfolios and take the capital gains charges (at least in the short-term…

Don't they have to payback the loans at some point? And at that point do they not liquidate some assets to do so and pay taxes on that? (Serious question.)

Re: What caused all the supply chain bottlenecks?

#320
post #99
post #82

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> The US has now outsourced most of the production of goods to places in other countries. I think that is the point (or one of the points): it's not just logistics and spare capacity - it's a much more complex set of issues. This isn't something accounting practices or "less greed" would solve, as seems to be implied in the Twitter thread. Would you have voted for a party that spent $1b annually on mask manufacturing…

> This isn't something accounting practices or "less greed" would solve Are you seriously trying to say that production being moved to China, et al. is not because of greed generally, and ROE specifically?

It might have something to do with drastically lower labor prices and environmental laws.

There is only so much discrepancy in prices that global markets will allow before buyers start rewarding the lower priced sellers for taking advantage of the arbitrage.

Post reply on HN