Live data from Hacker News

Two conspiracy theories about cola

dynomight.net

1–10 of 146 posts

Re: Two conspiracy theories about cola

#2
Maybe Emetrol is placebo, but it has worked for me in the past on a couple of occasions. This included 8 hours of vomiting no mater how hard I willed it to stop or other remedies I tried, and it didn't work on the first dose. It didn't seem like placebo to me, but I am grateful it worked either way.

One thing to note that isn't in the article, is that concentration can matter, so comparing one can to a 30ml dose of medication might not be a great comparison (although this still supports for the author's position that phosphoric acid is not added to cola to prevent vomiting).

Is the placebo effect applicable in infants? I would think that infants would not be capable of the understanding that something will make them better, and thus placebo wouldn't apply to them. Unfortunately this paper is pay-walled so we dont have details about the methods used, but the summary seems relevant.

https://www.jpeds.com/article/S0022-3476(51)80084-2/pdf

Re: Two conspiracy theories about cola

#4
Kind of tangential to the article but regarding phosphoric acid and its use as anti-nausea, is this why bubbly white sodas are a household cure for upset stomachs? This was a go-to for my family in the US as a kid when I had a stomach flu (saltines and 7-up), and i guess it was pretty common

Re: Two conspiracy theories about cola

#6
Ginger is also anti-nausea, but I eat it with sushi just because it tastes good.

From their study link:

>And, the reason most people say that they prefer Mexican Coke is that it contains real cane sugar instead of corn syrup. But according to this Time article, a study done by Obesity journal found that Mexican Coke did not contain sucrose

What does this mean? Last I looked many years ago, Mexican coke has two formulations you can notice *just by looking at the ingredients*: sugar or corn syrup. Did they not look? Did they not trust it?

The taste difference is noticable, because less-refined cane sugar is very tasty.

Re: Two conspiracy theories about cola

#8
post #2

Maybe Emetrol is placebo, but it has worked for me in the past on a couple of occasions. This included 8 hours of vomiting no mater how hard I willed it to stop or other remedies I tried, and it didn't work on the first dose. It didn't seem like placebo to me, but I am grateful it worked either way. One thing to note that isn't in the article, is that concentration can matter, so comparing one can to a 30ml dose of m…

Apparently placebo works even with dogs: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/19912522/ Given that I would not find surprising if it worked for infants too

Re: Two conspiracy theories about cola

#9
post #2

Maybe Emetrol is placebo, but it has worked for me in the past on a couple of occasions. This included 8 hours of vomiting no mater how hard I willed it to stop or other remedies I tried, and it didn't work on the first dose. It didn't seem like placebo to me, but I am grateful it worked either way. One thing to note that isn't in the article, is that concentration can matter, so comparing one can to a 30ml dose of m…

> Unfortunately this paper is pay-walled

not when you use sci-hub

https://sci.bban.top/pdf/10.1016/s0022-3476%252851%252980084...

Re: Two conspiracy theories about cola

#10
post #2

Maybe Emetrol is placebo, but it has worked for me in the past on a couple of occasions. This included 8 hours of vomiting no mater how hard I willed it to stop or other remedies I tried, and it didn't work on the first dose. It didn't seem like placebo to me, but I am grateful it worked either way. One thing to note that isn't in the article, is that concentration can matter, so comparing one can to a 30ml dose of m…

This included 8 hours of vomiting no mater how hard I willed it to stop or other remedies I tried, and it didn't work on the first dose

It seems very plausible that after 8 hours vomiting would stop without intervention.

Post reply on HN