Live data from Hacker News

Long Beach has temporarily suspended container stacking limitations

twitter.com

341–350 of 514 posts

Re: Long Beach has temporarily suspended container stacking limitations

#341

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> This is a system which assigns outgoing trucks an easily accessible container to deliver, rather than a specific container that has to be retrieved. This is such an obvious thing. Do they really have people so incompetent they didn't think of that? Wow

my understanding is that not all containers pay the same (since they are different weights, have different destinations, etc.) and so this mostly screws over the driver who loses the ability to select the best offer.

Not only do containers not pay the same, but containers to the same location often don't pay the same. So many variables and often the driver is the one that ends up getting screwed in the process. I completely understand why so many simply refuse certain loads. And getting assigned a load you know nothing about before it's on your truck is a no go for most drivers.

Re: Long Beach has temporarily suspended container stacking limitations

#342
post #285

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> This is a system which assigns outgoing trucks an easily accessible container to deliver, rather than a specific container that has to be retrieved. This is such an obvious thing. Do they really have people so incompetent they didn't think of that? Wow

There are truck driver shortages too. It’s a crappy deal for a truck driver to take a load which they don’t know it’s risks/payout or how long of a drive they will be taking, what they’ll do at destination, or if they’ll have a return trip. Odds are you could offer truckers a special premium flat rate to clear the blockage - but it wouldn’t be sustainable.

This is literally the same argument for why Uber/Lyft/Doordash drivers need to know the details of a fare before accepting, but a couple of orders-of-magnitude higher.

Re: Long Beach has temporarily suspended container stacking limitations

#343

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If that is true the rates for empty containers should increase making it worthwhile for ships to bring them back again?

Elsewhere someone mentioned it’s cheaper to build a new container in China than to ship and empty one over from the US. Even if you are already sending the boat. This sort of implies that it’s incredibly cheap to make the container, and/or it’s expensive to add that weight to the ship, and/or our ports are incredibly slow at loading empty containers onto ships.

Is it possible China is subsidizing creating the new containers exacerbating this problem?

Re: Long Beach has temporarily suspended container stacking limitations

#344
Is this related somehow to China refusing to take USA's recycling material?

IIRC shipping recycled material was super cheap. So many empty containers. Might as well fill them with something.

Why aren't empty containers shipped back to China? Boat has to go back anyway, right?

Did the empty containers pile up because no one was willing to pay to ship them back?

Re: Long Beach has temporarily suspended container stacking limitations

#345

A little off topic, but these ports don’t usually store so many empty crates, so why do we have them now? Are we not exporting at the same rate? Is that even what empty crates are used for? I’m assuming they aren’t sent back to (mostly?) China empty. I read something about the prices to ship out of the US being very high, but isn’t the price coming in also similarly proportionally high, yet we still have a backlog of…

This is very bad for the rest of the world, and also for the US, since all the empty containers are stacking up there, then there aren't any empty containers available in China or anywhere else for exporters, so even getting your hands on an empty container can be very difficult or almost impossible, or they cost 2-3x more than usually.

Our container price went from $1,500 to $10,000.

Re: Long Beach has temporarily suspended container stacking limitations

#347

I am a member of ILWU 13. A couple thoughts after reading the comments: The zoning change is for TEU storage outside the port. The port itself was not subject to that rule. The Port of Los Angeles is a landlord and is not directly involved in operations. Private companies, such as APM, EverPort, and others, rent piers/berths and are responsible for the actual operations and logistics. Some speculation: recently I’ve…

Is someone paying for ships to do this or are they doing their own calculations and realizing it’s cheaper for them to leave fast?

And what is the delay time if the ships decide to wait to load containers for the return?

Re: Long Beach has temporarily suspended container stacking limitations

#348

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I work at Flexport, Ryan is the real deal.

At my last employer, we lost a ton of engineering candidates to Flexport - it was frustrating because we'd try to articulate the scope of the opportunity, but some combination of what Flexport is doing and the recruiting process meant you guys would win every time.

I wouldn’t want to compete with Flexport on “scope of opportunity”. It’s like AWS 10 years ago.

Happy hunting!

Re: Long Beach has temporarily suspended container stacking limitations

#349

Earlier quoted context omitted.

My mental model is that regulations are decided on through a political process, and then no one looks at them until it becomes a political issue again.

zoning is very easy for local busybodies to capture, since normal people don't have time to give a crap (work to do, errands to run, kids to take care of, etc.). and those busybodies with the most time (older, wealthier) want very restrictive zoning. (see also: HOA regulations). the particular issue here is defined by local zoning. Japan managed to arrest housing prices by moving zoning definition to national rather…

What does any of this have to do with zoning?

Re: Long Beach has temporarily suspended container stacking limitations

#350
post #85

Truckers are leaving containers all over Los Angeles.[1] Allowing stacking over 2 high is only useful if you have the equipment to stack over 2 high. A place that just stacks empty containers 2 high probably only has large forklifts. The special equipment for high stacking is far more expensive, and only bought if you need it.[2] A more useful proposal is a "peel pile".[3] This is a system which assigns outgoing truc…

Sidenote... I think this might be the first time I've personally heard "There's an app for that" to essentially indicate "this is a solved problem" - even if in this case it does kind of mean "software exists to solve this problem" in a literal sense. We're only a decade or so out from when "there's an app for that" represented this cool new novel idea that you could install an app on your fancy new smartphone to do…

I wrote "there's an app for that" because IMC does have an app for that.[1] Also a web site.[2] Drivers need to be able to talk to the container dispatching system.

That's a side issue, though. As the number of containers in temporary storage increases, system throughput drops. So, once you get into overload, you're stuck there until you somehow reduce traffic or get more capacity. That seems to be the current situation.

It's not just at the US end. Shipify reports about 200 ships stuck waiting to get into Chinese ports.[3] (That article has a good overview of the situation.) At the China end, there's an empty shipping container shortage.

Back in July, US farmers were also complaining about an empty shipping container shortage.[4] Ship lines wanted to load up and get out, because the China->US rate is currently much, much higher than the US->China rate. So loading up containers at the US end apparently cost time and profits. The way empties are handled is driven by a system of economic incentives to not hold onto empties, and apparently that's not working well enough to get containers back to someplace useful. Someone has to pay to ship the containers back.

[1] https://apps.apple.com/us/app/imcs-mydriver/id1299727364

[2] https://www.imcsmartstacks.com/

[3] https://www.shiplilly.com/blog/container-ships-now-piling-up...

[4] https://www.farmprogress.com/trade/shipping-container-shorta...

Post reply on HN