Live data from Hacker News

20Y study finds little evidence religiosity leads to greater life satisfaction

psypost.org

21–30 of 113 posts

Re: 20Y study finds little evidence religiosity leads to greater life satisfaction

#21
post #7
post #4

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Survivorship bias. Especially for high-demand religions, answering "no" means admitting the church you make so many sacrifices for does absolutely nothing. This leaves those who are either too afraid to confront the cognitive dissonance or who were already happy in the first place.

Where do you get the premise of religion being a happier life?

I never said it was, I'm not sure why you think I did.

Re: 20Y study finds little evidence religiosity leads to greater life satisfaction

#22
post #15
post #2

Interesting. I wonder how you square that with results from "are you happy?" surveys comparing the religious and irreligious.

Believing you are happy and actually being happy are different things. Religious people believe that they're happier than other people, but they're not.

link? is that in the study?

Re: 20Y study finds little evidence religiosity leads to greater life satisfaction

#23
post #7
post #4

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Survivorship bias. Especially for high-demand religions, answering "no" means admitting the church you make so many sacrifices for does absolutely nothing. This leaves those who are either too afraid to confront the cognitive dissonance or who were already happy in the first place.

Where do you get the premise of religion being a happier life?

For most faithful, the answer would be 'experience'. People happy in their faith tend to stay. Those who aren't tend to leave eventually.

Re: 20Y study finds little evidence religiosity leads to greater life satisfaction

#24
post #4
post #2

Interesting. I wonder how you square that with results from "are you happy?" surveys comparing the religious and irreligious.

Survivorship bias. Especially for high-demand religions, answering "no" means admitting the church you make so many sacrifices for does absolutely nothing. This leaves those who are either too afraid to confront the cognitive dissonance or who were already happy in the first place.

> Especially for high-demand religions, answering "no" means admitting the church you make so many sacrifices for does absolutely nothing.

I think there's a chasm or 10 between declining a responsibility and denouncing your faith.

Re: 20Y study finds little evidence religiosity leads to greater life satisfaction

#26
post #7
post #4

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Survivorship bias. Especially for high-demand religions, answering "no" means admitting the church you make so many sacrifices for does absolutely nothing. This leaves those who are either too afraid to confront the cognitive dissonance or who were already happy in the first place.

Where do you get the premise of religion being a happier life?

[deleted]

Re: 20Y study finds little evidence religiosity leads to greater life satisfaction

#28
post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Where do you get the premise of religion being a happier life?

I never said it was, I'm not sure why you think I did.

Your answer of "survivorship bias" hints that you are assuming the parent's "are you happy" is a yes.

Assuming for argument's sake, that is.

Re: 20Y study finds little evidence religiosity leads to greater life satisfaction

#29
post #15
post #2

Interesting. I wonder how you square that with results from "are you happy?" surveys comparing the religious and irreligious.

Believing you are happy and actually being happy are different things. Religious people believe that they're happier than other people, but they're not.

>Believing you are happy and actually being happy are different things

Even if that were true, the two likely wouldn't be distinguishable in any meaningful way.

Re: 20Y study finds little evidence religiosity leads to greater life satisfaction

#30
post #15

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Believing you are happy and actually being happy are different things. Religious people believe that they're happier than other people, but they're not.

>Believing you are happy and actually being happy are different things Even if that were true, the two likely wouldn't be distinguishable in any meaningful way.

Yes they would. If you ask people if they're happy they'll say yes. If you actually measure it by observing what people do they'll exhibit behavior that shows they're not actually happy.

Self-delusion is a well researched topic. There are many studies.

Post reply on HN