Live data from Hacker News

Wall of Sound

en.wikipedia.org

1–10 of 53 posts

Re: Wall of Sound

#2
If you are a Beatles Fun it's fun to listen to the records "Let it Be" and "Let it Be Naked" back to back.

Let it be was produced by Phil Spector, and has a lot of the wall of sound trappings such as heavy use of effects, and heavily overdubbed string/chorus/etc parts.

Let it be naked is a remixed version of the album Paul McCartney was involved in to remove much of the Spector wall of sound parts.

For example listen to these back to back:

  * (spector) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fR4HjTH_fTM
  * (naked)   https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lfVAJNqWw84

  * (spector) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=90M60PzmxEE
  * (naked)   https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NLddD6Xf-8g

Re: Wall of Sound

#5
Phil Spector records have this heavy, dreamy sound that is, oddly, _exhausting_.

Your brain can't pick out the instruments being played (beyond the vocals and some of the lead instruments) so it all folds into each other. You stand there, awash in sound.

A key aspect of this sound was the monaural setup: everything was forced through one speaker and there was no stereo separation to separate the incoming instruments. Mono doesn't work very well on headphones though imo.

Re: Wall of Sound

#7
post #3

Heh I was expecting https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wall_of_Sound_(Grateful_Dead)

Huh! I was expecting some reference to post-rock like Mogwai and Mono, and/or dreampop/shoegaze like My Bloody Valentine.

I was expecting a reference to Phil Spector's wall of sound arranging technique, and was pleasantly surprised!

Re: Wall of Sound

#8
Two of the examples of later applications of the wall of sound in the article are Jesus and Mary Chain's "Just Like Honey," and Spiritualized's "Let it Come Down," which are both fantastic albums if you are into that. The latter doesn't use the same kind of reverb, but that technique of creating a giant wash of sound was huge across the entire subgenre of shoegazer (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shoegaze), and arguably extends into the current era with the whole modular synth drone scene, which comprises a varied spectrum of diminishingly listenable microtonal soundscapes.

I think I understand why Spectre was less about the song itself than the overall effect of the production. The early Raveonettes albums took the best parts of most of what he produced and made more perfect versions from a lofi pop perspective, imo. Songs like "Lust" "Great Love Sound" and their cover of "I wanna be adored," are probably the most comprehensive examples the style Spectre pioneered, and I'd say they improved it with interpretation. I would probably even recommend "Lust," and "Dead Sound" as examples that representative of Spectre's sound more than any of the actual songs he produced. Nothing can compete with hearing JMC for the first time in the 80s/90s, but the Raveonettes are pretty close. They're to that era what Interpol was to Joy Division - interpreted, and almost better. That wall of sound technique over pop is a big influence on my own stuff still.

Re: Wall of Sound

#9

If you are a Beatles Fun it's fun to listen to the records "Let it Be" and "Let it Be Naked" back to back. Let it be was produced by Phil Spector, and has a lot of the wall of sound trappings such as heavy use of effects, and heavily overdubbed string/chorus/etc parts. Let it be naked is a remixed version of the album Paul McCartney was involved in to remove much of the Spector wall of sound parts. For example listen…

Wow, I might actually prefer the Naked version of Long and Winding Road. The stripped down background makes the vocals convey more emotion. For Across the Universe, I still like the more psychedelic sound of the original - but thanks for the links! Despite being a Beatles fan I never listened to the Naked album.

Re: Wall of Sound

#10

If you are a Beatles Fun it's fun to listen to the records "Let it Be" and "Let it Be Naked" back to back. Let it be was produced by Phil Spector, and has a lot of the wall of sound trappings such as heavy use of effects, and heavily overdubbed string/chorus/etc parts. Let it be naked is a remixed version of the album Paul McCartney was involved in to remove much of the Spector wall of sound parts. For example listen…

fascinating. Spectors approach at times seems to share a lot in common with the Indian tradition of over-driven vocals in music.

https://www.reddit.com/r/explainlikeimfive/comments/2vs20j/e...

Post reply on HN