Live data from Hacker News

Reasons to switch from Windows to Linux

lpi.org

81–90 of 346 posts

Re: Reasons to switch from Windows to Linux

#81

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Well he is right. Linux is not for everyone. It's for people who can learn how to double click an icon that looks different from the one in Windows. That excludes probably 50% of Windows users right there.

This kind of attitude from linux users is significantly responsible for its lack of wider adoption. Who wants to learn something new when the people you need help from are going to treat you like a moron? We both know its more involved than clicking a different icon.

No, he's right. It's like maths. A vast majority of people like to not like / learn it.

I've spent a lot of time with average users of all kinds. They couldn't care less. To them it's a thing that has less value than a coffee cup.

I could, and would sit down and explain to them everything that is cool, cute about every layers of a computer, with simple language and pragmatic use, with history context, and bits of benefits for their lives. They just don't want to hear it.

Some will say it's geek stuff. Some will say "I'm too scared". Some will try and forget 13 seconds later.

The insane side of this is that these people will spend grands on a new machine that will tickle their sense of free improvement (which will not happen). Again every 3-5 years.. forced by ecosystemic pressure to push old stuff out.

ps: I agree that GP was a bit smug, but even then, the population is what it is.

pps: even at work, if I offer to explain something, or write a script, or a macro to help, most people will react negatively for various reasons (very often its petty emotions, like jealousy, or disdain).

Re: Reasons to switch from Windows to Linux

#82

As someone with RSI who uses speech recognition to control most software on my desktop, X11 -> Wayland has been a massive roadblock. Ad-infested Windows isn’t great, but at least it doesn’t feel like I’m fighting any devs just to be able to use my computer in an accessible manner.

How is OS X for that sort of accessibility? It seems to be the best for accessibility in general.

Apple products are very good for accessibility.

Re: Reasons to switch from Windows to Linux

#83
post #55

Earlier quoted context omitted.

>Ad-infested Windows I don't see any ads from windows. Not sure what you're talking about.

Perhaps you disabled them all after you installed it?

I don't see any either, maybe because its the Enterprise / Pro SKU?

Re: Reasons to switch from Windows to Linux

#84
This "list" is awful. I think we're heading into another Vista/8 cycle. Feels like MS really fucked up with Win11, but the writing has been on the wall for Windows for a while. Unless someone splashes them with cold water and they wake up, I'm staying with Windows 10 until they (artificially) force it. Meanwhile I'll be setting myself up a new future on another drive with a decent Linux distro.

Re: Reasons to switch from Windows to Linux

#85
So we all know that the Linux desktop is lacking in a few ways, and we all know there are a few reasons for that, but I really do think the experience is getting better.

Having more people use it and more development has been great. Valve, System76, and a few others have been pouring resources into making the experience better, and it's working.

As much as people aren't going to like me saying this, Electron has been good for the Linux desktop. I'm with everyone that Electron applications can be pretty bloated, but I'd imagine that I'd get late and/or sub-par access to plenty of programs if they weren't written in Electron. The fact that discord is 95% as good as Windows on Linux, despite having a tiny fraction of users is great. If it was written in GTK, I'd imagine that would be a good bit lower.

The fact we have multiple DEs that are of relatively similar popularity is great for choice, but affects development. MacOS and Windows have the advantage of the complete control over GUIs, while Linux has quite a few layers with different options at each layer. Not saying it's bad, but it explains slower development (as well as being FOSS without MS or Apple level of cash behind them).

Linux isn't for everyone, but god damn is the Linux desktop getting better. I won't indulge on the year of the Linux desktop meme, because it might be a while, but I'm happy at the current momentum.

Re: Reasons to switch from Windows to Linux

#86
post #21
post #2

The real reasons I use Linux are mostly out of convenience. For example, updating all my software and OS using one command rather than clicking on 50 updaters.

Linux has its conveniences but I think I definitely spend more times on updates. Some break things and some like Nvidia's drivers can take me ages to actually apply (though with that one the usual trick seems to be to remove --purge nvidia-* first).

Which distro?

You might want to look into something less unstable.

I've had arch running unattended upgrades in a Cron for years.

Worst case I have to find my USB stick and do some debugging, not that an update has ever broken anything.

There is some minor maintenance I run maybe once every 6-12 months to clear caches or fix up any configs that need updating but I've never run into anything that prevents booting.

Re: Reasons to switch from Windows to Linux

#87
post #51

My main reason for running Linux is the Terminal. I'm 35. Began with computers ~10. Spent my first 10 years using Windows, followed by 10 years of the Mac. I'm (hopefully) in my 10-year Linux run?!

Doesn't Windows have a decent terminal nowadays?

Probably does. I'm also guilty of not having given Windows a chance recently.

Re: Reasons to switch from Windows to Linux

#88

I don't disagree with switching to linux, but this isn't a great list. Points 1 & 2 are the same (don't buy a new PC), and quite a few of the rest are fixed as you can run all Linux software in the Linux subsystem for Windows.

I always wonder who these people are who pick the OS first and applications second? If you need to run GarageBand, Visual Studio, or Returnal, Linux is not an option.

Re: Reasons to switch from Windows to Linux

#90

You will learn a lot about kernel when your wifi, graphic card and hibernation does not work!

Why would I want to optimize for working on planes, trains and in meetings? That's not a good work environment.

I run desktop computers and since I don't need to play video games on them, I just use the CPU graphics.

However, even when I did use a discrete GPU - every Linux distro I've used just prompts me to install the drivers and things just work.

Post reply on HN