Live data from Hacker News

An underwater mystery on Canada's coast

bbc.com

41–50 of 69 posts

Re: An underwater mystery on Canada's coast

#41

BBCs headlines leave much to be desired. They dont want to summarise the article in the headline, they merely want to pique the readers interest.

If anything, headlines like these make me avoid clicking. My attention is a scarce resource. I'm not going to read through a longform (unless it's from damninteresting.com - but I purposefully go there for longform trivia) if I have no idea of the longforms' relevance to my current interests.

Re: An underwater mystery on Canada's coast

#42

What’s the line of sticks down the middle with no fencing on it for?

Probably to direct more fish into the trap, which otherwise would've swam to the other side totally oblivious of the trap. Efficiency is increased by that middle fence.

Edited to add excerpt from the original paper.

>A leader set in a linear direction more or less perpendicular to the shore so that fish approaching the leader turn and are guided toward deeper water and the trap; a leader that bisects the trap’s entrance to allow fish to enter the enclosure from either side of the fence (i.e., on a rising or a falling tide); a pair of bilaterally-positioned wings that form a V-shaped funnel entry to concentrate and redirect fish toward the trap enclosure’s entrance; and an entrance which incorporates species specific design characteristics (i.e., the width of the entrance and non-return devices) to only allow certain types of schooling fish to easily enter the enclosure and, once inside, prevent their escape.

Re: An underwater mystery on Canada's coast

#43
post #36

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Source? If a major respected journalism outfit was using AI to generate stories I think that would be news itself, and I haven't heard it, outside of the corner-case of within-seconds earthquake reporting.

- https://wan-ifra.org/2021/06/how-bbc-news-labs-uses-ai-power... - https://artificialintelligence-news.com/2017/10/19/bbc-ai-im... - https://techhq.com/2019/12/machines-wrote-the-bbcs-uk-electi...

None of this of course even remotely addresses the false (and, to any tech incined person who reads the BBC and has seen the state of AI-generated content) patently absurd claim you made that BBC News articles are "now mostly written by AI".

Re: An underwater mystery on Canada's coast

#44
post #41

BBCs headlines leave much to be desired. They dont want to summarise the article in the headline, they merely want to pique the readers interest.

If anything, headlines like these make me avoid clicking. My attention is a scarce resource. I'm not going to read through a longform (unless it's from damninteresting.com - but I purposefully go there for longform trivia) if I have no idea of the longforms' relevance to my current interests.

I usually try to avoid clicking them out of spite. I'm sure that they've found that it overall increases viewership, otherwise they wouldn't do it, but I hate that this is what news is now.

Re: An underwater mystery on Canada's coast

#45

Local reporting with much better pictures, diagrams and even a locally-produced podcast. https://www.hakaimagazine.com/features/the-ingenious-ancient...

Great article. It strikes me that this system of fishing is far more efficient and environmentally sustainable than the ocean-going ships we use these days. After all, here the fish just come to you!

Re: An underwater mystery on Canada's coast

#46
post #36

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Source? If a major respected journalism outfit was using AI to generate stories I think that would be news itself, and I haven't heard it, outside of the corner-case of within-seconds earthquake reporting.

https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/ap-expands-relation... > The Associated Press has selected Data Skrive as its preferred platform for automated sports and gambling content. The increased breadth of content provides AP customers more inventory of local-focused sports and gambling news. The AP expects the expansion of content to help both small and large publishers attract new subscribers and grow audience. htt…

From what I’ve seen of the tech, “assist” is the operant word here. It’s more like those article summary bots or a template fill-in-the-blank rather than something like GPT-2 that’s generating entirely novel phrases. A human still has to go in and make the text flow, correct things that don’t make sense, add good hooks, and (of course) an enticing title. The text isn’t “mostly written” by a bot - it’s still text that a human wrote, although it may have been summarized or had details populated by a bot.

Re: An underwater mystery on Canada's coast

#47
post #46

Earlier quoted context omitted.

https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/ap-expands-relation... > The Associated Press has selected Data Skrive as its preferred platform for automated sports and gambling content. The increased breadth of content provides AP customers more inventory of local-focused sports and gambling news. The AP expects the expansion of content to help both small and large publishers attract new subscribers and grow audience. htt…

From what I’ve seen of the tech, “assist” is the operant word here. It’s more like those article summary bots or a template fill-in-the-blank rather than something like GPT-2 that’s generating entirely novel phrases. A human still has to go in and make the text flow, correct things that don’t make sense, add good hooks, and (of course) an enticing title. The text isn’t “mostly written” by a bot - it’s still text that…

Depends on the category. Here's an automated high school sports article that likely never had a human touch it.

https://www.washingtonpost.com/allmetsports/2017-fall/games/...

Re: An underwater mystery on Canada's coast

#48
post #46

Earlier quoted context omitted.

From what I’ve seen of the tech, “assist” is the operant word here. It’s more like those article summary bots or a template fill-in-the-blank rather than something like GPT-2 that’s generating entirely novel phrases. A human still has to go in and make the text flow, correct things that don’t make sense, add good hooks, and (of course) an enticing title. The text isn’t “mostly written” by a bot - it’s still text that…

Depends on the category. Here's an automated high school sports article that likely never had a human touch it. https://www.washingtonpost.com/allmetsports/2017-fall/games/...

That’s the sort of fill-in-the-blank thing I’m talking about. It does data ingest from a very structured source (sports scores, financial reports, weather) and populates a pre-written template. But… the article is dull as dirt (so you’d only use it as a starting point, or for relatively low-value content), and it only works for things with very structured data. This almost certainly isn’t the case with the OP article, or most reporting you read on a day-to-day basis.

Re: An underwater mystery on Canada's coast

#49

Local reporting with much better pictures, diagrams and even a locally-produced podcast. https://www.hakaimagazine.com/features/the-ingenious-ancient...

And for a really deep dive the 2015 paper: https://www.academia.edu/23327812/The_Comox_Harbour_Fish_Tra...
Post reply on HN