Live data from Hacker News

MarketBrief (YC S11) Makes Obtuse SEC Documents Human-Friendly

techcrunch.com

11–20 of 55 posts

Re: MarketBrief (YC S11) Makes Obtuse SEC Documents Human-Friendly

#11
post #5

So who is the target audience? Finance pros can already read SEC filings. SEO is the only obvious source of traffic and money I can think of.

Their pro package is cheap for an analyst data service.

Doesn't answer the question. Any hedge fund or large trading desk will have prop tools that are probably 100X better as they have unlimited $ to go after more data. Is the hobbyist going to be subscribing... doubtful. Cool idea, but small market imo.

Re: MarketBrief (YC S11) Makes Obtuse SEC Documents Human-Friendly

#12
An API for the raw data that underlies this system would be extremely useful to academics. Databases like compustat and execucomp are expensive and lack some of the most interesting details in SEC documents. I have worked on trying to extract deep information in footnotes in financial statements (e.g. foreign cash holdings and option exercise tax shields) and found even Turk/Crowdflower couldn't handle the complexity. If they can figure out an algorithm to pull out such data, they will have both a great academic and private sector product.

Re: MarketBrief (YC S11) Makes Obtuse SEC Documents Human-Friendly

#13
My first thought on seeing their site is that the search box, and email alert box look just like sidebar ads for some reason. I think it's because it looks like an image, and not an html form.

I wouldn't have used the search if I had visited from Google Finance.

Re: MarketBrief (YC S11) Makes Obtuse SEC Documents Human-Friendly

#14

If they are automatically generating all the articles on the site that is quite impressive.

It is impressive but they definitely need some more work. The current top story is about how somebody called "Gendell Jeffrey L Et Al" sold a bunch of stock. The phrase "Gendell Jeffrey L Et Al" clearly refers to multiple people but their website is treating it like the name of a single person.

Re: MarketBrief (YC S11) Makes Obtuse SEC Documents Human-Friendly

#16
post #11

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Their pro package is cheap for an analyst data service.

Doesn't answer the question. Any hedge fund or large trading desk will have prop tools that are probably 100X better as they have unlimited $ to go after more data. Is the hobbyist going to be subscribing... doubtful. Cool idea, but small market imo.

I should have been more clear that finance pros do not all already read SEC filings. Some pay for news services this could replace. Some read the filings manually and would pay a small amount of money to not bother with edgar. They won't get the unlimited-budget firms but they could get a branch manager to replace a $3k/year newsletter with this.

Re: MarketBrief (YC S11) Makes Obtuse SEC Documents Human-Friendly

#17
post #5

So who is the target audience? Finance pros can already read SEC filings. SEO is the only obvious source of traffic and money I can think of.

Lawyers? Retail investors?

Even for finance pros who currently parse the raw filings, I can see how having an auto-generated human-readable summary that pulled out the key points would save enough time to be worth spending money on.

Re: MarketBrief (YC S11) Makes Obtuse SEC Documents Human-Friendly

#20
post #12

An API for the raw data that underlies this system would be extremely useful to academics. Databases like compustat and execucomp are expensive and lack some of the most interesting details in SEC documents. I have worked on trying to extract deep information in footnotes in financial statements (e.g. foreign cash holdings and option exercise tax shields) and found even Turk/Crowdflower couldn't handle the complexity…

I was really excited that they'd figured out a way to cull balance sheet data out of the filings. Doesn't appear so though, "XYZ Corp filed their annual statement today, you can view it here"
Post reply on HN