Live data from Hacker News

Most Canadians believe Facebook harms their mental health

theglobeandmail.com

141–150 of 273 posts

Re: Most Canadians believe Facebook harms their mental health

#141
Most Canadians can stop using it then

This entire topic is very silly. Parents are free to forbid their kids from using it. Adults can make their own decisions.

What it is starting to become is that people want other people to stop using it because they want them to consume the content that they see fit.

Re: Most Canadians believe Facebook harms their mental health

#142
post #55

Social media, ultimately, is information. There is no point in polarizing Facebook as good or bad. It is access to certain types of information and one must learn to discern if it can serve them or not.

Wrong, facebook is a politically involved corporate entity. Additionally they've proven relentlessly over the past decade plus to give zero fucks about improving their scorched earth method of making money.

Re: Most Canadians believe Facebook harms their mental health

#143
post #89

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think twitter is the most toxic. I have been uncomfortable on twitter to find enclaves where people are mentally ill, and have found others to exacerbate their behaviour and thinking.

Twitter, at least, is utterly worthless and entirely voluntary. Nobody uses the platform to announce or coordinate family events or to reach out to loved ones when they need help. I have a mostly inactive facebook account in case family messages me on there and I need to help out - I don't have a twitter account because I don't find brigading to be a worthwhile activity. I'd say with a moderate level of confidence th…

I completely disagree. There are entire fields of academia where effectively the only discussion being held outside of papers is on twitter.

Twitter, by a large magnitude, has been the most professionally useful social network to me as a knowledge worker/researcher.

Re: Most Canadians believe Facebook harms their mental health

#144
Repeat after me:

"I can be happy and thrive without social media."

Here is how you become a billionaire today-

Step 1: Create some thing people want to indulge in, whether or not it is healthy or good for them (as long as it's legal).

Step 2: Convince them that it is good for them.

Step 3: Acquire anyone else who tries to do the same or squash them out aggressively.

Rinse and repeat.

Re: Most Canadians believe Facebook harms their mental health

#145
post #67

I'm getting kind of tired of the narrative that "x is evil/bad/harmful, but I'm too weak (we won't admit addiction) to not use x. Everyone I know uses x. Government needs to regulate x (so I don't have to change my ways)." I deleted my account over a year ago now, because I do view them as evil and do cause overall societal harm. It's not life ending. You'll adjust and then wonder why you didn't do it sooner. I made…

I dunno

On one hand I get it because having a global centralized media source running bleeding edge optimization algorithms against humans is highly unprecedented till recently.

But at the same time I don't like the trend in recent years to completely "minimize individual responsibility"

It makes sense why these narratives are popular too.

It means I don't have to admit my lack of discipline.

Re: Most Canadians believe Facebook harms their mental health

#146
post #82
post #67

I'm getting kind of tired of the narrative that "x is evil/bad/harmful, but I'm too weak (we won't admit addiction) to not use x. Everyone I know uses x. Government needs to regulate x (so I don't have to change my ways)." I deleted my account over a year ago now, because I do view them as evil and do cause overall societal harm. It's not life ending. You'll adjust and then wonder why you didn't do it sooner. I made…

The issue is primarily that some folks have moved all of their online connections onto facebook - they've put all of their eggs in that basket. If you want to keep up with them at all you need to at least have the bearest presence on the platform. This is less about that dude from highschool and more about your cousin.

You want to keep in touch with the cousin who won't bother with you if you leave facebook?

Re: Most Canadians believe Facebook harms their mental health

#148
post #67

I'm getting kind of tired of the narrative that "x is evil/bad/harmful, but I'm too weak (we won't admit addiction) to not use x. Everyone I know uses x. Government needs to regulate x (so I don't have to change my ways)." I deleted my account over a year ago now, because I do view them as evil and do cause overall societal harm. It's not life ending. You'll adjust and then wonder why you didn't do it sooner. I made…

I'd take that further. When I felt lonely sometimes, I'd boot up social media and see what people are up to. Now, without social media, when I feel lonely I'll text friends. Unsurprisingly, it's more healthy. And when I reach out more, they reach out more. And instead of getting a button click invitation, people will text or call with an invitation and we'll actually talk a bit too. Turns out them telling me a thing…

such an under-rated comment!!

Re: Most Canadians believe Facebook harms their mental health

#149
post #67

I'm getting kind of tired of the narrative that "x is evil/bad/harmful, but I'm too weak (we won't admit addiction) to not use x. Everyone I know uses x. Government needs to regulate x (so I don't have to change my ways)." I deleted my account over a year ago now, because I do view them as evil and do cause overall societal harm. It's not life ending. You'll adjust and then wonder why you didn't do it sooner. I made…

"The only people you'll lose touch with were superficial relationships to begin with"

That's extraordinarily presumptuous to assume you understand the contours of a billion strangers human connections.

Post reply on HN