Live data from Hacker News

Is going to the office a broken way of working?

newyorker.com

451–460 of 468 posts

Re: Is going to the office a broken way of working?

#451

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> No, you just don’t want to get vaccinated. Everything else is window dressing around that. And I have no rational reason to, except artificial reasons created by most of governments. > The virus will mutate and continue to do so. Eventually your immunity will weaken - will you get the vaccine then? My immune system seems doing great job defending me from all the mutations which already took place. So I don't want t…

> I trust my immune system more than I trust whatever the vaccine does Uhh…this is what a vaccine does. It shows your immune system what a disease looks like, lets it do it’s thing to discover a solution…so that it has a hashmap to a solution ready to go rather than than needing to iterate over the entire database and apply iterative mutations to the best solutions in order to find a successful match. What in the wor…

> It shows your immune system what a disease looks like

But it knows! Why should I now train it on a picture if there are live viruses of all the mutations all over around which I have already encountered countless times and keep encountering every day?

I would certainly vaccinate if I were going to an infected place from a place where there is no such virus. Or if the disease was widespread somewhere else and coming to my place while there already was a vaccine.

But I have been living emerged deep in the infection intensively for over 2 years already! I have never even decreased (even increased actually, meeting many new people every day, and nobody wears masks in business) my social interactions, just tested regularly and wore a mask in public transport. I even drank from the same cup with an sick and positive girl once, then self-isolated for some days, tested regularly (incl. in-lab PCR) - all negative, no sickness. And even lab tests objectively show I have been maintaining high level of antibodies for already a year (which suggests they are renewing given regular contact). How can we possibly suspect my immune system still has not enough clue and an instruction can be better than what it already knows?

> apply iterative mutations to the best solutions in order to find a successful match.

But I apparently applied very successful matches to every mutation!

> What in the world do you think a vaccine is? Vaccine-based immunity is natural immunity.

To something specific, more precisely - a specific model (not even a real object) isn't it?

Re: Is going to the office a broken way of working?

#452

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> No, you just don’t want to get vaccinated. Everything else is window dressing around that. And I have no rational reason to, except artificial reasons created by most of governments. > The virus will mutate and continue to do so. Eventually your immunity will weaken - will you get the vaccine then? My immune system seems doing great job defending me from all the mutations which already took place. So I don't want t…

> Plus the natural instinct to resist whenever pushed. And there it is..you are still an adolescent who never fully matured emotionally. Glad we could get to the root of it.

This saved me from loosing money and possibly from getting into trouble so many times already.

Re: Is going to the office a broken way of working?

#453

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> I trust my immune system more than I trust whatever the vaccine does Uhh…this is what a vaccine does. It shows your immune system what a disease looks like, lets it do it’s thing to discover a solution…so that it has a hashmap to a solution ready to go rather than than needing to iterate over the entire database and apply iterative mutations to the best solutions in order to find a successful match. What in the wor…

> It shows your immune system what a disease looks like But it knows! Why should I now train it on a picture if there are live viruses of all the mutations all over around which I have already encountered countless times and keep encountering every day? I would certainly vaccinate if I were going to an infected place from a place where there is no such virus. Or if the disease was widespread somewhere else and coming…

> But it knows! Why should I now train it on a picture if there are live viruses of all the mutations all over around which I have already encountered countless times and keep encountering every day?

Ok so when are you going to get a booster shot or your first COVID shot? Or are you planning on getting the disease again and letting it run its course?

Any why would you treat this vaccine any different than the flu vaccine or w/e? It makes absolutely no sense. If you don't understand the science, how are you making informed decisions?

> nobody wears masks in business

False? Who cares? I'm in business and wear a mask all the time when meeting with clients if we even meet on-site.

> which suggests they are renewing given regular contact

Which also suggests you are getting the virus again and giving it to people you interact with who may now be getting COVID-19 for the first time. You're literally perpetuating the disease! But hey screw everybody else right? Those who might not be able to get the vaccine, like, oh idk, my nephew? Or maybe kids who BTW aren't immune from getting sick.

Your mentality around this is selfish and bizarre.

> How can we possibly suspect my immune system still has not enough clue and an instruction can be better than what it already knows?

The person you are replying to was discussing your complete misunderstanding of how vaccines work. Not commenting on naturally acquired immunity, which BTW doesn't mean you're 100% immune because that's now how things work.

Re: Is going to the office a broken way of working?

#454

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Well, yes. If not "everyone," certainly lots and lots of folks are just staying home whenever possible. Because we are in the middle of a global pandemic. I think this has much more to do with "we are in a global pandemic" than "you can't meet people doing remote work." Certainly, there were a number of larger groups that I used to hang out with consistently pre-pandemic, but now have totally abandoned. I'm not inter…

I think it is, on average, incorrect to say that people are staying home for fear of the pandemic which is what I think you are suggesting. I think the average hn reader probably skews much more cautious about coronavirus, much better able to remain indoors, and much more, for want of a better phrase, socially responsible than the average person. And even among hn readers plenty will not be staying at home much. That…

In my case, most of my outside socializing was through gaming meetings, and:

- the local Gaming Society closed for 2 years (meeting for the first time after 2 years in November),

- the local game stores stopped doing in-person events for 2 years (still no news on Magic: the Gathering in-person pre-releases, not authorized for Latin America despite my country being basically covid-free),

- I started playing D&D (with coworkers, so the OP has a point), had one in-person session and then we moved to Roll20 (slowly coming back to in-person).

I do think people were socializing outside more before the pandemic.

Re: Is going to the office a broken way of working?

#455

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> It shows your immune system what a disease looks like But it knows! Why should I now train it on a picture if there are live viruses of all the mutations all over around which I have already encountered countless times and keep encountering every day? I would certainly vaccinate if I were going to an infected place from a place where there is no such virus. Or if the disease was widespread somewhere else and coming…

> But it knows! Why should I now train it on a picture if there are live viruses of all the mutations all over around which I have already encountered countless times and keep encountering every day? Ok so when are you going to get a booster shot or your first COVID shot? Or are you planning on getting the disease again and letting it run its course? Any why would you treat this vaccine any different than the flu vac…

> Ok so when are you going to get a booster shot or your first COVID shot?

I consider every interaction with the virus a booster shot. So I guess every day.

> False? Who cares? I'm in business and wear a mask

Perhaps the right question would be where. I personally insist on masks every time I feel even slightly imperfect (which mostly is because I didn't sleep enough) even if the other people feel too confident. In fact I believe masks make the most sense out of all the measures deployed and allowing people use public transport and supermarkets without masks once most of them are vaccinated is going to be a huge mistake.

> Which also suggests you are getting the virus again

How is this getting it with natural immunity proven by a lab antibody test worse than getting it being vaccinated?

> But hey screw everybody else right?

Nobody experienced any symptoms after contacting me. Everybody I talked to still feels fine. I test. I wear FFP2. I use hand sanitizers. I avoid meeting anyone without a necessity (as I always did). And by the way I have also heard a rumor (though I don't rely on it as I never cared to check) getting an infection from a light/asymptomatic-symptomatic person means higher chances to overcome it without light symptoms too.

> Your mentality around this is selfish and bizarre.

No, I just the question above. I do everything I see logical reason in but I don't understand how is a vaccine better than immunity I have already developed naturally. Why is it supposed to protect the people around me better than the antibodies I already have?

> The person you are replying to was discussing your complete misunderstanding of how vaccines work. Not commenting on naturally acquired immunity, which BTW doesn't mean you're 100% immune because that's now how things work.

Ok. Would you be so kind to tell me how is a vaccine supposed to be better than contacting all the mutations of the actual live virus besides the fact the latter gives you less chances to survive unharmed and enjoy the immunity?

Re: Is going to the office a broken way of working?

#456

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> But it knows! Why should I now train it on a picture if there are live viruses of all the mutations all over around which I have already encountered countless times and keep encountering every day? Ok so when are you going to get a booster shot or your first COVID shot? Or are you planning on getting the disease again and letting it run its course? Any why would you treat this vaccine any different than the flu vac…

> Ok so when are you going to get a booster shot or your first COVID shot? I consider every interaction with the virus a booster shot. So I guess every day. > False? Who cares? I'm in business and wear a mask Perhaps the right question would be where. I personally insist on masks every time I feel even slightly imperfect (which mostly is because I didn't sleep enough) even if the other people feel too confident. In f…

Right. Anything to avoid getting a vaccine. Any excuse imaginable. Got it.

> Nobody experienced any symptoms after contacting me.

Sure except you know people can transmit diseases without showing signs of symptoms. It's called being asymptomatic.

> Ok. Would you be so kind to tell me how is a vaccine supposed to be better than contacting all the mutations of the actual live virus besides the fact the latter gives you less chances to survive unharmed and enjoy the immunity?

You're familiar with the concept of a straw man right?

Nobody is arguing this point. What we are arguing is your misunderstanding of "whatever is in a vaccine" from your original post.

Here's what you said:

> I trust my immune system more than I trust whatever the vaccine does

It's clear from the start that you don't even know what a vaccine does. The vaccine does the exact same thing as obtaining the virus "naturally". It's a living virus, put into you, to train your immune system. It's the same thing. Trying to separate that out into a "natural" immunity versus an "artificial" immunity is not only incorrect scientifically but pretty comparable to believing the earth is flat or something.

Here's another thing you said:

> I never ever resisted any vaccine before and was always willing to get vaccinated against everything.

So again, why is COVID-19 different? Explain the exact scientific and logical reasoning for resisting this vaccine and not others.

> Why is it supposed to protect the people around me better than the antibodies I already have?

So your plan is to just get COVID-19 + variants every year instead of getting a vaccine? Why? Why get yourself sick when a vaccine will do the exact same job? Doesn't seem very logical to me. Do you not get flu shots either? Do you realize that even if you didn't get extremely sick from your first interaction with COVID that it doesn't mean the next time you get a variant you won't be in a coffin? I don't understand at all the point of taking an unnecessary risk here.

Re: Is going to the office a broken way of working?

#457

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Lol, you'd be surprised to learn I'm not surprised in my expectation that these things will come back. Referring to their death literally because the bars are closed for the last year and a half, despite the hit to innovation and progression that causes. And I'll go to them once they're back, see "career progression reasons." The light ire my last comment contains is directed at the people that view these as lightwei…

Feel free to downvote me again and laugh but as someone who's office is back in the city. Thing ARE already back to normal, you just have no idea yet as a remote drone. I'll stop trying to help you and stop giving you cheat codes at this point. In 5 years we'll know who was correct.

I live in a large tech city you’d know, a venture-backed place on lists you’d recognize, and at a career point where I’ve played these cheat-codes already. I stayed in the city for the same reasons you’d advocate for. The offices are 1/4 full, financial districts around it are a ghost town, and companies are shedding real estate. I can’t down vote comments that are direct replies to me. Yeesh.

Re: Is going to the office a broken way of working?

#458

Earlier quoted context omitted.

But the act of tapping someone in the shoulder and break their concentration already does all the harm IMO. Once you've done that, headphones on or off is redundant. In my experience, 99% of these disturbances could be avoided with a bit more effort on the side of the person interrupting. So what generally happens is that the person concentrating loses his focus - very likely getting out of the zone - and helps them…

What? I'll wait for coffee or lunch. There are natural places throughout a work day to ask someone a question without interrupting their work time. I specifically noted this too. I'm not advocating for instant response, I'm saying that there are no natural breaks in a remote environment for us to have casual conversations.

Yeah, fair point. But what's stopping you from simply asking for some face-to-face time and scheduling it?

Sometimes the best solution is to have a discussion and it's a lot easier to do compared to writing. On those cases I just ask "can we have a meeting to discuss X?" and we schedule something.

This gets you the help you the same results, without any interruption.

Sure they could just pretend to not see your message and ignore it leaving you in a tough spot, but that's a problem with the person, not remote work IMO.

Generally speaking, even if you're focused, you'll stop to have lunch, grab a snack, etc. And you then answer questions, setup a time to meet, etc.

Re: Is going to the office a broken way of working?

#459

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Ok so when are you going to get a booster shot or your first COVID shot? I consider every interaction with the virus a booster shot. So I guess every day. > False? Who cares? I'm in business and wear a mask Perhaps the right question would be where. I personally insist on masks every time I feel even slightly imperfect (which mostly is because I didn't sleep enough) even if the other people feel too confident. In f…

Right. Anything to avoid getting a vaccine. Any excuse imaginable. Got it. > Nobody experienced any symptoms after contacting me. Sure except you know people can transmit diseases without showing signs of symptoms. It's called being asymptomatic. > Ok. Would you be so kind to tell me how is a vaccine supposed to be better than contacting all the mutations of the actual live virus besides the fact the latter gives you…

> Right. Anything to avoid getting a vaccine. Any excuse imaginable. Got it.

No. Just only get vaccinated if I understand why I should (I mean why I should, not why everybody should). Avoid everything if I don't understand why it is going to help me or anyone around me in my particular case. "Let's just apply the measure to everyone to get a better total result" approach doesn't convince me, I'm a strong proponent of individual approach in everything.

> The vaccine does the exact same thing as obtaining the virus "naturally". It's a living virus, put into you, to train your immune system. It's the same thing.

It's not THE virus. And not even a virus, it's an mRNA which tells the cells to produce something modeled by something they caught in a lab somewhere far away more than a year ago. I actually prefer the real viruses in the circulation given I've been lucky enough to resist any harm they could do. I know "natural" and "artificial" immunity work the same way, but the former is against the real viruses and the latter is against a model.

>> I never ever resisted any vaccine before and was always willing to get vaccinated against everything.

> So again, why is COVID-19 different? Explain the exact scientific and logical reasoning for resisting this vaccine and not others.

Okay, not everything, only the diseases I'm not already immune to. I have chickenpox antibodies (because I had chickenpox when I was a child) so I don't feel like vaccinating against it. I have covid antibodies (because I had light covid obviously, how else could I get them? but the government doesn't believe I had it despite the antibody test, they only accept positive PCR tests taken during the sickness, to me this seems absurd) so I don't feel like vaccinating against covid. The moment when I probably caught it the vaccines were just invented and not available in my country. But I wouldn't hurry even if they were because not tested enough. I really want a vaccine against Lime's disease but am not going to hurry with it as soon as it gets approved, I'll wait some years anyway. Perhaps my logic is imperfect but can you really see no logic in this?

> So your plan is to just get COVID-19 + variants every year instead of getting a vaccine?

So again you believe a vaccine developed against some of the first variants is better than whatever immunity I already have (after surviving waves of all the known strains and having antibodies on a level higher than people I know got after serious sicknesses and vaccines)? I still don't understand why.

> Why get yourself sick when a vaccine will do the exact same job?

I don't get sick. Just slightly sick once long ago and still reliably high level of the antibodies.

> Do you not get flu shots either?

Flu isn't around me all year round. I never tried but I probably wouldn't find particularly high level of flu antibodies if I tested in summer. I don't think I would get the shot if I actually tested and found a reasonable amount of the antibodies. Or maybe I would because flu is more sophisticated AFAIK - there are more diverse varieties. Covid is always around and I think contacting it regularly works like booster shots.

> it doesn't mean the next time ... you won't be in a coffin

Nothing does.

> I don't understand at all the point of taking an unnecessary risk here.

I agree my understanding of the immune system and the vaccines is futile but again I'm not sure tuning it against an old strain can decrease my risk as compared to leaving it as it is after it has successfully tuned it against all the live strains in circulation.

Re: Is going to the office a broken way of working?

#460
post #157

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I see your point, but I think it goes the other way. Churches et al are microcosms of a geographic community, resulting in greater localized diversity of thought. And these groups can either lead or hold back a community along the lines of race- and class-exclusion. The church I grew up with was the very first institution in my life that had an openly homosexual person in a position of power (the rector, in charge of…

My childhood Southern Baptist church (irregularly attented, around holidays visiting family) had a female pastor. Eventually, the Southern Baptist Convention got around to noticing, and told them that wasn't allowed. They could either fire the pastor, or they'd lose SBC funding. ... to which the church replied that they were founded in 1804, liked their pastor just fine, and that the SBC could go have a talk with the…

I am not a church goer myself but I love how your church handled it. Kudos!
Post reply on HN