Live data from Hacker News

Why I hate the Kindle

enlightenmenteconomics.com

11–20 of 66 posts

Re: Why I hate the Kindle

#11
post #2

I have yet to buy any ebooks from amazon, just downloaded most of mine through "3rd parties", and the kindle is a wonderful device for that, thus I can share my books with whoever I like.

Wish it would also sync the non-Amazon books, though. Maybe I am not proficient enough yet, but so far I had to copy ebooks into obscure directories by hand (especially interesting on the Android Kindle reader).

Re: Why I hate the Kindle

#12
Most of the criticism applies to the Kindle specifically, not to ebooks in general. The inability to see what others are reading is a problem, though.

Re: Why I hate the Kindle

#13
This article sounds like it was written by a luddite. The only half-good argument is book sharing, and even that isn't that great.

You can't copy-paste from the kindle? Let me just get my paper book out and copy-paste some text from that here. Oh, wait...

Re: Why I hate the Kindle

#14
re: the issues of sharing and reselling, both of these are going to become far less of an issue. With "mediocre" authors like Amanda Hocking (http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2011/03/01/self-published-auth...) able to make millions by self publishing at a $3 price, we will see more established authors follow this route and eventually weaken he publishers to the point where they must relent on these issues. These are temporary pains cause by an industry being torn up by a technical innovation.

If you look at Amazon's "Domino Project" (http://www.thedominoproject.com/books) you get a sense for what they imagine the future to be. Authors creating books to an audience built via social media rather than expensive retail promotion and being sold for $5ish dollars

As for the other points, I agree with most of the commenters that these sound more like personal issues rather than technical problems.

Re: Why I hate the Kindle

#15
post #12

Most of the criticism applies to the Kindle specifically, not to ebooks in general. The inability to see what others are reading is a problem, though.

Maybe I'm missing something, but how is that a problem? Why do I need to see what other people are reading?

If anything, other's inability to see what I'm reading is a bonus...

Re: Why I hate the Kindle

#17
"I can’t even get e-books I bought on one device onto another device I own, although no doubt one of my domestic IT support staff (sons) could do it for me."

... Okay, so you aren't a techie, and that's why you hate it. You should lead with this next time so that the rest of us can ignore the whole thing.

Re: Why I hate the Kindle

#18
post #3

I am at the Borobudur temple right now : http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Borobudur I brought nothing on my long walk but water and Kindle. Stopped for a couple hours. Reading an amazing book, with the temple in the background. Highlighting the most important bits as I come across them. The stuff I don't want to forget. The Kindle saves all of these to a file called "My Clippings.txt", which I'll later transfer over to m…

I've just bought one myself and have experienced the same kind of joy that you have with it, very much similar to getting my first iPhone. I think your choice on iPad/Kindle will always fall down to e-ink. I get mentally exhausted at looking at backlit screens for too long, picking up the Kindle I get none of that nagging feeling of strain. It's a wonderful device and I wish I'd got it sooner.

There's also a size/flashiness issue. If I'm going on public transit or waiting somewhere that the whole "look, I'm holding a shiny device that's easy to pawn!" thing may be a bad idea, I bring my kindle. Or if it's likely to rain or I just don't feel like dragging around the ipad and a cleaning cloth (what's with those smart cover streaks, anyways?).

Otherwise, I take my ipad. The addition of news reading (the economist and reuters apps are fantastic) is why I usually bring it instead if I can.

Re: Why I hate the Kindle

#19
Some of the reasons he hates it is that it makes it harder for some businesses, that they are obsolete. Nearly every obsoletion that affects people is thought of as bad by someone. There are many more out there that are held back just because the owners are afraid of having to fire a lot of people.

Re: Why I hate the Kindle

#20
post #8

I too have started to hate my kindle, but not for any of the reasons the author lists. Mine are: - Availability. Within the US (and only within the US/Canada) book availability is great, but it isn't perfect..outside the US/Canada it sucks. Amazon once had books 1,2 and 5 of a series I wanted, but not 3 and 4 (I know, i know, this isn't amazon's fault) - Price. Kindle books are often more expensive than their physica…

What is a "KDK?" SDK typo?

You can publish a free book as an idependent author.

I have been annoyed by the occasional higher price of a kindle versus deadtree book. But often? That is a stretch.

Post reply on HN