Live data from Hacker News

Led by France, 10 EU countries call on Brussels to label nuclear energy as green

euronews.com

41–50 of 143 posts

Re: Led by France, 10 EU countries call on Brussels to label nuclear energy as green

#42
post #6

Given the Germany stupid move to get rid of nuclear (in favor of coal[1], as it turned out), not sure if it will support this decision. And nowadays they are dependent from one country's gas... [1] https://www.wired.com/story/germany-rejected-nuclear-power-a...

The numbers are public record. https://de.statista.com/statistik/daten/studie/156695/umfrag...

There is no huge spike. And since the decision to shut down the nuclear plants, also coal has decreased massively, even more dramatically than nuclear.

Re: Led by France, 10 EU countries call on Brussels to label nuclear energy as green

#43
post #34

This seems to be an unpopular opinion on HN but I just don't trust humans to manage fission power in the long term at scale. First, there are the issues of storage and disposal of enrichment byproducts, specifically depleted Uranium Hexaflouride ("DUJF" or UF6). Second, there's what to do with old fuel rods. Proponents argue this is a solved problem and it can be stored for the long term in geologically stable storag…

Doesn’t thorium address some of these issues?

Re: Led by France, 10 EU countries call on Brussels to label nuclear energy as green

#44
post #34

This seems to be an unpopular opinion on HN but I just don't trust humans to manage fission power in the long term at scale. First, there are the issues of storage and disposal of enrichment byproducts, specifically depleted Uranium Hexaflouride ("DUJF" or UF6). Second, there's what to do with old fuel rods. Proponents argue this is a solved problem and it can be stored for the long term in geologically stable storag…

"Second, there's what to do with old fuel rods. Proponents argue this is a solved problem and it can be stored for the long term in geologically stable storage facilities." With space travel becoming cheaper and cheaper, cant we deposit that on the moon for example?

Re: Led by France, 10 EU countries call on Brussels to label nuclear energy as green

#45

Good. Due do skewed and unreasonable public opinion it is currently almost impossible to start new nuclear power projects. As a result instead of modern, safe (passive cooling, etc) nuclear plants we're running 30-40 year old, unsafe old timers! Thorium pellet reactors, et al, are promising technologies for safe and local power generation. I believe the right answer is a mix of (safe) nuclear, renewables, together wi…

Hasn’t Bill Gates done a lot with nuclear reactor design?

Re: Led by France, 10 EU countries call on Brussels to label nuclear energy as green

#46
post #23

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Let’s see if they still sport these stickers after the coming winter…

You underestimate the masochism of the average German, or at least the type to have such a sticker.

I live in Germany, I have seen a lot…

Re: Led by France, 10 EU countries call on Brussels to label nuclear energy as green

#47
post #27

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Worth adding that in EU this is largely German public opinion. And somehow the tail wags the dog.

Is it so? Constituting a quarter of the gdp, Germany doesn't seem to qualify as "the tail".

Is public opinion weight a matter of GDP? Should it?

Re: Led by France, 10 EU countries call on Brussels to label nuclear energy as green

#48

I read that letter in the newspaper this morning and I had a few questions about the claims being made: - They claim nuclear could create a million of jobs in Europe. What kind of jobs ? Is that job creation or job swapping ? - Switching to nuclear power guarantees energy independence. But where is the uranium we need ? How can we guarantee delivery ? The argument I hear against building new nuclear plants is that it…

Australia is the country wih the world's largest uranium reserves. They seem to be a more agreeable trading partner than Russia.

Re: Led by France, 10 EU countries call on Brussels to label nuclear energy as green

#49

I read that letter in the newspaper this morning and I had a few questions about the claims being made: - They claim nuclear could create a million of jobs in Europe. What kind of jobs ? Is that job creation or job swapping ? - Switching to nuclear power guarantees energy independence. But where is the uranium we need ? How can we guarantee delivery ? The argument I hear against building new nuclear plants is that it…

I think construction timeframes all due to complex political process and lack of proper experience.

With enough political will and accepting more reactors in numbers I believe in 10 years, we could get plants up and running in 5 year timeframe.

Re: Led by France, 10 EU countries call on Brussels to label nuclear energy as green

#50

Good. Due do skewed and unreasonable public opinion it is currently almost impossible to start new nuclear power projects. As a result instead of modern, safe (passive cooling, etc) nuclear plants we're running 30-40 year old, unsafe old timers! Thorium pellet reactors, et al, are promising technologies for safe and local power generation. I believe the right answer is a mix of (safe) nuclear, renewables, together wi…

Hasn’t Bill Gates done a lot with nuclear reactor design?

Yes: https://www.terrapower.com/
Post reply on HN