Live data from Hacker News

Software for Math Research

amathr.org

11–20 of 31 posts

Re: Software for Math Research

#13

Recently (re-)discovered Mathematica, and found spanning a much larger set of domains than I expected (also, very approachable).

The first time I used Mathematica (20 years ago) it blew my mind. To be fair it was the first time I used a CAS and so the very idea of a computer crushing me at several calculus tasks was incredible.

From the open source alternatives the better supported I think is (wx)Maxima, which for the simple tasks I usually require (i.e some Taylor series, check cumbersome trigometric equations, ...) it's more than enough although it's true it lacks by a long margin the polish of Mathematica. Recently I'm considering buying an educational version of Mathematica just for the convenience. It sucks it's a closed source program but it's rare, although not impossible, for open source alternatives to have the same good documentation and ease of use. I guess that the attention to these details is not something people usually do unless being paid.

Now, tangentially related, this is extremely cool (and previously posted in HN I think): https://ai.facebook.com/blog/using-neural-networks-to-solve-...

Re: Software for Math Research

#15
The list is missing Manim for visualization. I tried it out because I was curious how 3b1b creates his videos and was blown away by the simplicity of the tool. For simple visualization and teaching aid, Manim is a great tool.

Re: Software for Math Research

#16

Recently (re-)discovered Mathematica, and found spanning a much larger set of domains than I expected (also, very approachable).

The first time I used Mathematica (20 years ago) it blew my mind. To be fair it was the first time I used a CAS and so the very idea of a computer crushing me at several calculus tasks was incredible. From the open source alternatives the better supported I think is (wx)Maxima, which for the simple tasks I usually require (i.e some Taylor series, check cumbersome trigometric equations, ...) it's more than enough alth…

I've never liked Mathematica, it gets notation all wrong, Sin[x] where it should be sin(x), Maple got this right.

Re: Software for Math Research

#17
post #16

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The first time I used Mathematica (20 years ago) it blew my mind. To be fair it was the first time I used a CAS and so the very idea of a computer crushing me at several calculus tasks was incredible. From the open source alternatives the better supported I think is (wx)Maxima, which for the simple tasks I usually require (i.e some Taylor series, check cumbersome trigometric equations, ...) it's more than enough alth…

I've never liked Mathematica, it gets notation all wrong, Sin[x] where it should be sin(x), Maple got this right.

That's probably because they wanted to use juxtaposition for multiplication. Otherwise, “f(x)” could mean either f applied to x or f times x in parentheses.

Re: Software for Math Research

#19
I think you are all missing the context here. The "Association for Mathematical Research" is a new organization created by various people who got in trouble on woke math twitter. Nobody had heard of it until yesterday. (Their crimes are mostly opposing diversity statements in job applications, or favoring gifted programs.) It looks like a schism with the AMS (which more-or-less publicly takes the opposite view on these things), though they deny it. The impetus for the new group is clearly political. They got a few big names on there, but everybody on the board is already known for holding retrograde political views and I think they all signed one of the dueling petitions about this in the AMS Notices a year or two ago.

This is just a filler page to make it look like they have some content. It's not a serious list of mathematical software. There are good ones of those done elsewhere.

Re: Software for Math Research

#20

I think you are all missing the context here. The "Association for Mathematical Research" is a new organization created by various people who got in trouble on woke math twitter. Nobody had heard of it until yesterday. (Their crimes are mostly opposing diversity statements in job applications, or favoring gifted programs.) It looks like a schism with the AMS (which more-or-less publicly takes the opposite view on the…

The amount of leftist political content in the AMS notices is pretty annoying. I wish them well in this endeavor.
Post reply on HN