Live data from Hacker News

Apple rejects developer's horoscope app, says App Store has enough

imore.com

81–90 of 131 posts

Re: Apple rejects developer's horoscope app, says App Store has enough

#81

I have been using the Samsung store for a little while and am shocked by the overwhelming number of low quality apps that are stuffed in there. Long live the walled garden for Apple.

Heow do the walls help Apple's store serve users, would it be worse if they allowed other app stores?

Re: Apple rejects developer's horoscope app, says App Store has enough

#82

I guess the free market has spoken and what is wants is no more free markets. Apple is shooting itself in the foot with this. More choice in products is always better than less.

Apple's entire offering is that more choice is not better.`

Re: Apple rejects developer's horoscope app, says App Store has enough

#84

> Also avoid piling on to a category that is already saturated; the App Store has enough fart, burp, flashlight, fortune telling, dating, drinking games, and Kama Sutra apps, etc. already. I had to double-take to see if this was really a statement from Apple... It was.

Before Apple added the flashlight feature into their OS, flashlight apps were flooding the store. IIRC, this is the exact text they added at that time

Apple hired/acquired the developer of one of the top flashlight apps in in the app store.

Re: Apple rejects developer's horoscope app, says App Store has enough

#85

I have been using the Samsung store for a little while and am shocked by the overwhelming number of low quality apps that are stuffed in there. Long live the walled garden for Apple.

Pardon me, but why were you using Samsung's garbage app store and not the Google Play store? More like long live F-droid as there's no way in hell I'm voluntarily locking myself into Apple's high-quality, nice and shiny walled garden where basically they fully control the device and what I'm allowed to install on it, while renting it out to me for a fee and can scan it for whenever content they want (CP pics today, T…

Not op but guessing because Play Store has some restrictive preconditions for use (eg linking a Google account).

Re: Apple rejects developer's horoscope app, says App Store has enough

#86

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Not to undermine your effort, but isn't this the same outside of Apple? Kickstarter projects get cloned and ask a legitimate Amazon seller how their products got overrun by Chinese clones. That said, I would expect Apple to be a little better for 30% cut.

That's true, on the other hand the fact that copyapps even copy icons and have very close sounding names in the same space would be a trivial thing to guard against.

Machine learning like its 2010! Agree, it would be not too difficult.

Re: Apple rejects developer's horoscope app, says App Store has enough

#87

Earlier quoted context omitted.

We need to be able to use non-Apple app stores for iPhone.

I was really hoping this would be the outcome of Epic v. Apple, but alas it was not. I honestly don't know if I understand any reasoning behind it. I would buy an iPhone tomorrow if I could get a web browser or keyboard that weren't effectively skins of the default/included one.

You aren’t the market. Apple has curated a user base that prefers the exact opposite; I land among them. If it isn’t for you, then avoid it.

That it is a more lucrative market than what Android had built with their more open ended approach is an interesting look at what the general public prefers from their mobile devices.

Personally, I’m not looking for my phone to be a side project, I want it to work without putting in any effort.

Re: Apple rejects developer's horoscope app, says App Store has enough

#88

App Store development has me sort of offended. If I build it I’m not certain users can even try it unless apple (gatekeeper) decides their user base should. It’s certainly a walled garden and perhaps a reason I’ve steered my career away from mobile development.

The odds of rejection should be just another factor in your expected value calculation though.

https://www.investopedia.com/terms/r/risk-of-ruin.asp

Re: Apple rejects developer's horoscope app, says App Store has enough

#89

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I was really hoping this would be the outcome of Epic v. Apple, but alas it was not. I honestly don't know if I understand any reasoning behind it. I would buy an iPhone tomorrow if I could get a web browser or keyboard that weren't effectively skins of the default/included one.

You aren’t the market. Apple has curated a user base that prefers the exact opposite; I land among them. If it isn’t for you, then avoid it. That it is a more lucrative market than what Android had built with their more open ended approach is an interesting look at what the general public prefers from their mobile devices. Personally, I’m not looking for my phone to be a side project, I want it to work without puttin…

I wonder what is the overlap between people who want non-Apple stores in iOS and complain about Epic Store and Origins Store because Steam already exists :)

Re: Apple rejects developer's horoscope app, says App Store has enough

#90

App Store development has me sort of offended. If I build it I’m not certain users can even try it unless apple (gatekeeper) decides their user base should. It’s certainly a walled garden and perhaps a reason I’ve steered my career away from mobile development.

Google app store has (had?) the category "new apps" so people can find and try out fresh developments. It brought me 400 download the first day (which lead to many more). Sorely miss this kind of discoverability on the app store. Also Apples search sucks.
Post reply on HN