The American Aristotle
aeon.co
The American Aristotle
1–10 of 36 posts
Re: The American Aristotle
#2Re: The American Aristotle
#3Re: The American Aristotle
#4> The importance and range of Peirce’s contributions to science, mathematics and philosophy can be appreciated partially by recognising that many of the most important advances in philosophy and science over the past 150 years originated with Peirce: the development of mathematical logic (before and arguably better eventually than Gottlob Frege); the development of semiotics (before and arguably better than Ferdinand de Saussure); the philosophical school of pragmatism (before and arguably better than William James); the modern development of phenomenology (independently of and arguably superior to Edmund Husserl); and the invention of universal grammar with the property of recursion (before and arguably better than Noam Chomsky...).
> Beyond these philosophical contributions, Peirce also made fundamental discoveries in science and mathematics. A few of these are: the shape of the Milky Way galaxy; the first precise measurement of the Earth’s gravity and circumference; one of the most accurate and versatile projections of the 3D globe of the Earth onto 2D space; the chemistry of relations and working out the consequences of the discovery of the electron for the periodic table; the axiomisation of the law of the excluded middle, or Peirce’s Law: ((P→Q)→P)→P); existential graphs and the transformation of mathematics into an (quasi-)empirical component of studies on cognition; one of the first studies of the stellar spectra, particularly the spectral properties of argon; the invention of the then most accurate gravimetric pendulum; the first standardisation of the length of the metre by anchoring it to the length of a wavelength of light (which he figured out via his own experiments in multiple stations around Europe and North America).
I wanted to share a classic dialogue put together by Susan Haack, "We Pragmatists..." Peirce and Rorty in Conversation—using only the philosophers' actual words—contrasting Peirce's pragmatism with Rorty's of ~100 years later. It's like night and day, with Peirce = day! It gives a very good sense of how they talked and their wide differences. And it's very funny.
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/312041697_We_Pragma...
Re: The American Aristotle
#5Fallibilism seems to be most of Nassim Talebs bit. There are careers to be made on Pierce's observations.
The idea of getting upstream of objects and asking of what are they the effect seemed to be the main cognitive tool the author recognized Pierce as using and recommending. I have read nothing by him, seems like my kind of person, what body of work does one even start with on someone like that?
Re: The American Aristotle
#6Not only was Peirce a genius logician who discovered the universal and existential quantifiers independent of Frege, he also formalized pragmatism and semiotic.
Edit: Oh and I forgot abductive reasoning[1], which is shockingly unknown given its utility. I first learned of it from an absurdly smart Raytheon physicist many years ago.
Re: The American Aristotle
#7To be able to write like that about that topic is supremely impressive. Fallibilism seems to be most of Nassim Talebs bit. There are careers to be made on Pierce's observations. The idea of getting upstream of objects and asking of what are they the effect seemed to be the main cognitive tool the author recognized Pierce as using and recommending. I have read nothing by him, seems like my kind of person, what body of…
[1]https://courses.media.mit.edu/2004spring/mas966/Peirce%20187...
Re: The American Aristotle
#8The syllogism is too much.
Re: The American Aristotle
#9Also a white supremacist. Not a good looks there Charlie https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charles_Sanders_Peirce#Slavery... The syllogism is too much.
All Men are equal in their political rights. Negroes are Men. Therefore, negroes are equal in political rights to whites.
If you're talking about his use of the word "Negro", I disagree. Negro was a term commonly used, at the time, to refer to people of African origin. I don't associate any negativity with the word in this context.
Re: The American Aristotle
#10This is probably why he isn't very well known.
It's this kind of crap which gives philosophy a bad name.