Live data from Hacker News

Ireland joins OECD International Tax agreement

gov.ie

1–10 of 384 posts

Re: Ireland joins OECD International Tax agreement

#4
Ireland is about to discover how unattractive it is as a locale for multinational HQs when the playing field is somewhat more level. And I'm in favor of the move as a middle class US taxpayer and a small business owner who pays through the nose, but this is a quite obvious self-own in the long run for them, much for the same reason why introducing a wealth tax was a self-own for France. Big Money is mobile, sophisticated, and quick on its feet.

Re: Ireland joins OECD International Tax agreement

#6
I've always been baffled as to how this is seen as a multi-national issue. The US could always implement unilateral minimum VAT and profit[3] taxes on corporations forcing them to effectively pay whatever proportion the US demands to continue doing business in the world's largest consumer market. Just because you're only paying 3%[1] profit[3] tax in Bermuda doesn't mean you can necessarily skate around the remaining 12% when doing business in the US - the US could just pocket that additional 12% if nobody else wanted it. Implement a policy like that and the competitive tax advantage of havens disappears overnight and all this BS disappears.

We[2] have tax loopholes because we want to continue to have tax loopholes.

1. BS example I'm unfamiliar with the actual numbers.

2. Where "We" is lawmakers or maybe society as a whole as weighted by political power.

3. Edited: s/revenue/profit/

Re: Ireland joins OECD International Tax agreement

#7
post #4

Ireland is about to discover how unattractive it is as a locale for multinational HQs when the playing field is somewhat more level. And I'm in favor of the move as a middle class US taxpayer and a small business owner who pays through the nose, but this is a quite obvious self-own in the long run for them, much for the same reason why introducing a wealth tax was a self-own for France. Big Money is mobile, sophistic…

Sure - but it's the process of making the world a better place. The more these tax havens get shut down the fewer (and riskier) places that corporations have to shelter their revenue.

Re: Ireland joins OECD International Tax agreement

#8
post #4

Ireland is about to discover how unattractive it is as a locale for multinational HQs when the playing field is somewhat more level. And I'm in favor of the move as a middle class US taxpayer and a small business owner who pays through the nose, but this is a quite obvious self-own in the long run for them, much for the same reason why introducing a wealth tax was a self-own for France. Big Money is mobile, sophistic…

And big money can stop moving if countries stop giving them tax breaks.

Re: Ireland joins OECD International Tax agreement

#9
post #6

I've always been baffled as to how this is seen as a multi-national issue. The US could always implement unilateral minimum VAT and profit[3] taxes on corporations forcing them to effectively pay whatever proportion the US demands to continue doing business in the world's largest consumer market. Just because you're only paying 3%[1] profit[3] tax in Bermuda doesn't mean you can necessarily skate around the remaining…

Governments want to tax profits rather than revenues. A tax on revenues would kill a lot of high growth businesses.

Re: Ireland joins OECD International Tax agreement

#10
post #3

> Global minimum effective corporation tax rate of 15% for multinationals with revenues in excess of €750 million > No change to the 12.5% rate for businesses with revenues below €750 million

Hopefully 15% is for ( Total - 750 )

Total and $750M aren't even the same unit. The former is profit, while the latter is revenue.
Post reply on HN