Live data from Hacker News

Ruqqus, an open source Reddit clone, is shutting down their main instance

ruqqus.com

31–40 of 115 posts

Re: Ruqqus, an open source Reddit clone, is shutting down their main instance

#31
post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

While these "moderated speech" Reddit alternatives end up taking a far-left tone, what's funny is how all discussions they host have to be approached from that angle. So you can't just talk about your favorite article. You have to first make a nod to how it features a white supremacist conspiracy to push anti-Jewish sentiments. Only then can you go on to discuss the actual submission.

Perhaps in certain subreddits that's true, but on Reddit, it's easy to find both far right and far left echo chambers. And it's easy to find centrist communities. It's also easy to find communities where people don't talk about politics at all, and just discuss their favorite TV show or 3D printing filament without bringing anything else up. That's not the case on these other "free-speech" reddit clones - they're exc…

It's a mistake to think echo chambers are a phenomenon which only take place on the political extremes. Reddit itself is an echo chamber of tepid liberal orthodoxy and American exceptionalism, moderated by a former member of the Atlantic Council. A fish doesn't recognize the water it swims in.

Redditors might call a place like Hexbear an echo chamber for instance, but it wasn't the members of Hexbear who chose to isolate themselves. Reddit made that decision by banning them.

Re: Ruqqus, an open source Reddit clone, is shutting down their main instance

#32
post #27
post #21

Earlier quoted context omitted.

- r/conspriacy - r/politicalcompassmemes (basically all the popular 'meme' subreddits are far-right breeding ground) - any of the "fight porn"/"justice served" have incredibly right-leaning commentariat These are all things that regular hit r/all

/r/conspiracy is NOT far right, FAR FAR FAR from it it is 1990 Democrat, which today sadly is "right" given that "left" has taken an extreme left turn...

r/conspiracy is a sad story. I loved the subreddit from years ago, where crazy and even stupid conspiracies were discussed. Nowadays it's all related to "antivax" crap.

Re: Ruqqus, an open source Reddit clone, is shutting down their main instance

#34
post #19
post #14

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> it's easy to find both far right and far left echo chambers Could you point to 3 "far right echo chamber" active-ish (more than 50,000 subscribers) non-banned subreddits? For "far-left" I'd say: r/politics r/LateStageCapitalism and r/socialism EDIT: I knew this post was going to get heat. I consider myself a "leftist" (and by US standards I would be maybe consider a communist) but my point was that there is active…

r/the_doland (banned) r/CringeAnarchy (banned) r/Greatawakening (banned) The myriad of r/incel communities and their clones that Reddit plays whack-a-mole with

r/antifa and r/chapotraphouse were also large communities that were banned.

Reddit policy definitely appears to be based on behavior, not ideology.

Re: Ruqqus, an open source Reddit clone, is shutting down their main instance

#35
post #30

Earlier quoted context omitted.

My post was exactly what GP was doing here. He couldn't talk about the article posted without bringing in some neo nazi fantasy he had. I simply changed the words he spouted and it fit perfectly with what he is doing. Reddit bans anything "far right" (whatever that means) that gets popular. Extremist used to mean terrorist, now it's used for people you don't align with politically. No one on [Patriots . win] is an ex…

The good thing about "no one on $site is an extremist" is that there's a pretty clear way to disprove it: find one specimen. https://patriots.win/p/13zg9agFHB/instead-of-eliminating-hun... promotes some myth about "the government wanting to eliminate 1e6 to 1e9 american workers" and proposes to "eliminate politicians" instead. Comments by the OP in that thread clarify the direction this is supposed to take, respondin…

your definition of an extremist is certainly lax isn't it?

I'd designate someone an extremist if they were plotting to do something, not some edgy comment that you'd find anywhere.

There's hundreds of comments on reddit wishing death, that doesn't make those people "extremists".

Re: Ruqqus, an open source Reddit clone, is shutting down their main instance

#36
post #21
post #14

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> it's easy to find both far right and far left echo chambers Could you point to 3 "far right echo chamber" active-ish (more than 50,000 subscribers) non-banned subreddits? For "far-left" I'd say: r/politics r/LateStageCapitalism and r/socialism EDIT: I knew this post was going to get heat. I consider myself a "leftist" (and by US standards I would be maybe consider a communist) but my point was that there is active…

- r/conspriacy - r/politicalcompassmemes (basically all the popular 'meme' subreddits are far-right breeding ground) - any of the "fight porn"/"justice served" have incredibly right-leaning commentariat These are all things that regular hit r/all

>> justice served

Moderators for popular subreddit r/JusticeServed on Reddit — one of the most visited websites on the internet with an estimated 12 billion page views per month — said Monday that due to new site policies they are no longer allowed to permit posts, comments, or any other content that shows a person of color as the aggressor

Re: Ruqqus, an open source Reddit clone, is shutting down their main instance

#37
post #17

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The comment that got flagged for trying to reverse this missed its point, but I thought it had one. My reply-too-late: While that is a little hyperbolic, there's definitely a "kid gloves" approach you have to take in a lot of online discussions. E.g. there was an article on burnout that popped up on HN[0] recently where the author made sure to apologize for being a "privileged white chick" early on. You can't just ta…

> you have to virtue signal about issues Acknowledging your privilege is not categorically virtue signalling. One can think there's not value is acknowledging privilege (or that it might not exist), but let's not pretend it's impossible (or unlikely) that another does.

Are you saying that it’s not categorically virtue signaling because someone can find value in that? Doesn’t sound logical to me. If the detail doesn’t contribute to the discussion but is meant to appease a specific group - that’s definitely closer to virtue signaling than to a genuine expression.

Re: Ruqqus, an open source Reddit clone, is shutting down their main instance

#38

I tried using the site and used it for a while, for what little non political and non flame war content it had. It got boring. I don't particularly like some of the UX decisions and features, but overall it is a pretty well built piece of software. I don't believe ruqqus federates, so "instance" would be the wrong word. It's a standalone server.

The use of the term "instance" to describe a deployed instance of software predates federated software like mastodon.

Re: Ruqqus, an open source Reddit clone, is shutting down their main instance

#39
post #34
post #19

Earlier quoted context omitted.

r/the_doland (banned) r/CringeAnarchy (banned) r/Greatawakening (banned) The myriad of r/incel communities and their clones that Reddit plays whack-a-mole with

r/antifa and r/chapotraphouse were also large communities that were banned. Reddit policy definitely appears to be based on behavior, not ideology.

yeah real great "behavior" they got over there

https://www.reddit.com/r/HermanCainAward/

Re: Ruqqus, an open source Reddit clone, is shutting down their main instance

#40
post #21

Earlier quoted context omitted.

- r/conspriacy - r/politicalcompassmemes (basically all the popular 'meme' subreddits are far-right breeding ground) - any of the "fight porn"/"justice served" have incredibly right-leaning commentariat These are all things that regular hit r/all

>> justice served Moderators for popular subreddit r/JusticeServed on Reddit — one of the most visited websites on the internet with an estimated 12 billion page views per month — said Monday that due to new site policies they are no longer allowed to permit posts, comments, or any other content that shows a person of color as the aggressor

Do you have a link to where they said that?
Post reply on HN