Live data from Hacker News

Facebook Whistleblower Leaks Thousands of Pages of Incriminating Internal Docs

npr.org

61–70 of 734 posts

Re: Facebook Whistleblower Leaks Thousands of Pages of Incriminating Internal Docs

#61
post #58

Now do the same for CNN, Fox News and every other sophisticated media company who have all created Skinner boxes to get more eyeballs. The entire system needs a hard examination.

I suspect the reaction from a lot of companies is going to be to lock down internal documents under a need-to-know security model.

That helps the public good too.

Re: Facebook Whistleblower Leaks Thousands of Pages of Incriminating Internal Docs

#63
post #36

There is something that doesn't sit right with me about the whistleblower. Yes, she is a data scientist which gives her many many extra points. But, she was a PM for 2 years in FAANG. Her actual scope of the what was going on in FB as a huge org, as she's trying to comment on (the "I want to fix FB" quotes from 60 minutes) Everyone I know who works in FAANG, FB specifically, and PMs even more specifically, really hav…

What's your point here? This lady is a PRODUCT manger and heads up the entire product, in this case Civic Integrity, which was directly charged with tamping down hate on the platform related to civic engagement. She is not a PROJECT manager like what you deal with on your engineering team. She is by definition an expert on this segment of Facebook and you're dismissing her wrongly for being a "PM".

She's a Harvard MBA with a degree in Computer Engineering and experience at Google and Pinterest. She's qualified to have a pretty significant role in the company and rightly so earned the job that she has.

EDIT: I looked into the claim that she co-founded Hinge and it's mostly accurate. She worked with Justin McLeod (Hinge CEO) to build "Secret Agent Cupid" which was Hinge before it rebranded with the launch of it's new mobile app.

Re: Facebook Whistleblower Leaks Thousands of Pages of Incriminating Internal Docs

#64
post #50

A ‘whistleblower’ who claims FB isn’t censoring enough? Isn’t manipulating and curating political views enough? Gimme a break... This is like something you’d read in the Gulag Archipelago.

She is not arguing for censorship at all. She's actually arguing that content-based censorship doesn't work because the AI algorithms are so inaccurate.

She is arguing against algorithmic content ranking, and in favor of chronological feeds, as well as other measures that do not attempt to judge the content itself.

Re: Facebook Whistleblower Leaks Thousands of Pages of Incriminating Internal Docs

#65

What are the potential legal ramifications for the whistleblower?

That’s a good question. Leaking internal company documents doesn’t automatically grant someone whistleblower protection. She appears to be trying an angle where she claims that Facebook’s activities have harmed shareholders in an attempt to capture some degree of whistleblower protection, but that’s a huge stretch given that she’s arguing they made choices in the interest of profits without violating any actual laws.…

I seriously doubt shareholders agree with her angle.

> her best chance is to hope that Facebook will simply try to minimize the legal issue to avoid making her into too much of a martyr

I suspect the opposite. They will attempt to make an example of her to dissuade subsequent whistleblowers.

Social media has a short attention span and forgets its "martyrs" within days.

Re: Facebook Whistleblower Leaks Thousands of Pages of Incriminating Internal Docs

#66
once again people are not really understanding this issue. this isn't about security or products, it's about white men and their fascist institutions controlling technology for their own fascist gains

once again, it was never about products, security, or customer satisfaction

Re: Facebook Whistleblower Leaks Thousands of Pages of Incriminating Internal Docs

#68

Now do the same for CNN, Fox News and every other sophisticated media company who have all created Skinner boxes to get more eyeballs. The entire system needs a hard examination.

This is straight-up deflection. It makes sense to start somewhere, so why not the biggest player in town? That would be Facebook, with billions of active users. None of those cable channels are even close to 100s of millions of viewers.

Re: Facebook Whistleblower Leaks Thousands of Pages of Incriminating Internal Docs

#69

Now do the same for CNN, Fox News and every other sophisticated media company who have all created Skinner boxes to get more eyeballs. The entire system needs a hard examination.

The system's imploding.

i disagree

Re: Facebook Whistleblower Leaks Thousands of Pages of Incriminating Internal Docs

#70
post #32

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's not really an "angle", she worked with a whistleblower protection organization and she specifically gave these documents to the SEC, filing 8 complaints with the regulatory organization. All of that communication is protected. I don't know what the legal implications for leaking to the press are, but that's where her exposure is.

Her bigger risk is probably the employment angle. Hard to picture hiring this person except if you're 100% certain your company's behavior aligns with her morals, and you can't find anyone else. Even for people who generally agree with her view on Facebook employing her presents a pretty serious known risk at this point.

I'm guessing she would be eligible for an SEC whistleblower award if her complaints result in fines to Facebook.
Post reply on HN