Live data from Hacker News

California outlawed all-white-male boardrooms – reshaping corporate America

latimes.com

191–200 of 208 posts

Re: California outlawed all-white-male boardrooms – reshaping corporate America

#191

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This comment ten years ago would be agreed to by almost everyone in the United States. Not anymore; it is now fashionable to be racist against Whites. No more!

This comment has never been agreed upon by almost everyone in the US. The difference now is that we want to take action to try to even the playing field against the majority of those who didn't agree with the statement then or now.

Nonsense

Re: California outlawed all-white-male boardrooms – reshaping corporate America

#192

Earlier quoted context omitted.

So that's your counter? Nothing against the actual merit of the statement? White people don't naturally assume they have their positions on merit? How many whites actually think, "Maybe I shouldn't have this position because of the advantage I've been given being white"? Seriously. How often do white males seriously ponder this?

Are they in that position because they are white, or are they in that position because they were born in privileged families? My country has had predominantly white, male Prime Ministers. What's even more remarkable is that every single one of them over the past 20 years went to highly exclusive private schools. The sort of private school that costs more than a good portion of adults earn, i.e $40k per annum. When yo…

larry went to a public high school, as did sergey. neither family was wealthy.

Re: California outlawed all-white-male boardrooms – reshaping corporate America

#193

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Honestly there is not right angle to race. Saying "black people cant be at the board of companies" is just as wrong as saying "some black people have to belong to it". That being said, when only white people are at the board of companies without that being a calculated strategy, there is also a problem. If only white people come out on top where - allegedly - the smartest people belong, wouldn’t it be the place of th…

The problem is that the only real solution is a lot more extreme. I think once women are pregnant they go into managed care and babies are immediately taken at birth into academies (with no knowledge of parents) until adulthood. But that will never happen. Unfortunately short of that we’re likely to never have real equality.

Wow. That escalated quickly!

I hope you’ll never be in any position of power to realize this “solution”.

Re: California outlawed all-white-male boardrooms – reshaping corporate America

#194
20 years ago, my IT friends and I were all enviously looking at California as a model to replicate. TC and Michael Arrington made us understand daily the opportunities we were missing.

Today, I honestly feel sad to see the decrepitude of this once beautiful lady we were in love with. She does not inspire me anymore. Sad.

Re: California outlawed all-white-male boardrooms – reshaping corporate America

#195

What is not a white male? Will this be a self declared sort of thing?

> What is not a white male? Will this be a self declared sort of thing?

Except for Native Americans, where active tribal affiliation is sometimes required, racial/ethnic identity in the US is generally purely self-identification, despite having legal significance for various purpose (e.g., government contracting and minority-owned business incentives/requirements.)

Re: California outlawed all-white-male boardrooms – reshaping corporate America

#197

Genuinely curious how women would feel if they were given a job not based purely on merit and credentials, but their gender. Isn’t that a slap in the face? Like, “yea there were other much more qualified candidates, but we just have to fill this quota.” That’s what would be nagging me in the back of my mind if I was a women.

It completely undermines credibility. If there is a person in authority who may have been put there under affirmative action policies, the people under that authority will always wonder whether or not the person was put in that position because of their competence or because of the policy.

Re: California outlawed all-white-male boardrooms – reshaping corporate America

#198

Earlier quoted context omitted.

what you are saying is that women and people of color are not capable of competing on merit? they have to be installed by decree? i am insulted.

It's not that they're incapable of competing on merit; it's that the established institutions are unwilling to recognize based on merit, and a coercive outside force is required to counterbalance the entrenched racism & sexism until we're at a point where society can function on a truly meritocratic basis on its own.

[deleted]

Re: California outlawed all-white-male boardrooms – reshaping corporate America

#199
post #88

Let’s say a 10 person board is populated with 9 white male board members. They need to appoint the 10th board member. It can’t be a white male? So, for this specific role, they must make a hiring decision based upon the individual’s membership in a class, such as sex, race or color. That seems to violate Title VII of the Civil Rights Act.

I mean, the law is unconstitutional. Racial quotas are not legal. And this will get struck down by courts. Democrats literally just don't care.

India should be held up as a classic example. Racial reservation once initiated is difficult to eradicate and there is no assurance that such a program benefits the under-privileged. If at all it creates further class divide.

Re: California outlawed all-white-male boardrooms – reshaping corporate America

#200
post #192

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Are they in that position because they are white, or are they in that position because they were born in privileged families? My country has had predominantly white, male Prime Ministers. What's even more remarkable is that every single one of them over the past 20 years went to highly exclusive private schools. The sort of private school that costs more than a good portion of adults earn, i.e $40k per annum. When yo…

larry went to a public high school, as did sergey. neither family was wealthy.

Does the US have public Monterossi schools? Here in Australia they're all private and expensive.
Post reply on HN