Live data from Hacker News

'Cottagecore' and the rise of the modern rural fantasy

bbc.com

131–140 of 274 posts

Re: 'Cottagecore' and the rise of the modern rural fantasy

#131

I love my backyard garden (even though my Brussels Sprout experiment this year proved to be a huge waste of time). I also love the aesthetic that cottagecore is revitalizing. I love drinking at local wineries, buying stuff at my local farmer's market, brewing beer and swapping bottles with homebrew friends, etc... But holy shit am I repulsed by the influencer aspect that is growing with this "movement". Ways of Seein…

Or maybe you're losing your edge to better-looking people with better ideas and more talent who are actually really really nice.

Re: 'Cottagecore' and the rise of the modern rural fantasy

#132
post #102

Earlier quoted context omitted.

One of the worst things we did in the past century is paint the idea of an apartment high rise full of decent sized family apartments overlooking a green shady courtyard as some communist evil, to be actively outlawed. We haven't gotten past that sentiment towards apartment living to this day. Even what we do build in terms of apartments is only really studios or 1 or 2 bedroom units. If you want to have a family, th…

Lots of recent TV paints living in a large apartment building as a completely normal thing to do.

Living as a SINK/DINK? Yeah sure. Look at just about any show about raising children at or above the replacement rate and the vast majority are all in homes. Even the family in shameless had a home. The only counter example I can even think of is smilf.

Re: 'Cottagecore' and the rise of the modern rural fantasy

#133

Its the result of complete burnout of a large portion of society. So many people feel they work too much and dream of just getting away to something simpler. I think its a reflection of so much going wrong currently with society and the way we live in general. But I'm just some guy on the internet; I am probably projecting :) Edit: I often think about buying a cheap old isolated house on a couple acres in Italy, fixi…

> So many people feel they work too much and dream of just getting away to something simpler. I agree that this the popular sentiment, but I think work is a smaller part of it than we like to think. I think people are simply overwhelmed with the always-on, always-connected lifestyles that fill our every waking moment with outrage-bait headlines and more entertainment media than we could possibly ever consume. Anyone…

"I think people are simply overwhelmed with the always-on, always-connected lifestyles that fill our every waking moment with outrage-bait headlines and more entertainment media than we could possibly ever consume" I completely agree with you. I think the worst thing that happened to modern societal culture was the invention of the pay per click model. Everything changed at that moment; politics, consumerism, even they way we form opinions and gather information. All for the worse.

Re: 'Cottagecore' and the rise of the modern rural fantasy

#134

Just another manifestation of people realising their life of metropolitan decadence is wrong, lacks meaning and is damaging to the human spirit.

This reads as if it’s written by someone who has bought into the imagined influencer sanitized idea of rural life which thoroughly ignores the _many_ reasons people move away from rural areas.

I mean, even just the idea that people outside of cities somehow have more “human spirit” is kind of strange and absurd.

Re: 'Cottagecore' and the rise of the modern rural fantasy

#135

Earlier quoted context omitted.

...while ignoring the reasons people headed in that direction in the first place.

To participate in consumerism and capitalism, correct?

Lack of opportunity? Poverty? Disease? Broken homes? War? Sexual/physical/emotional/spiritual abuse? To make new connections? To find a partner? To explore the wider world?

Surely not!

Re: 'Cottagecore' and the rise of the modern rural fantasy

#136
post #53

I dream of quitting my job and living on some land. My wife refuses to "live in the middle of nowhere, where there's nothing to do". I guess I shall continue to work a job I hate in order to live in this expensive area.

Even if you're not planning on getting divorced soon or at all, there's no harm in talking to a divorce lawyer now to figure out how to minimize the damage when things change and you get tired of working a job you hate to live in an expensive area that you don't want to live in.

Things can get better.

Re: 'Cottagecore' and the rise of the modern rural fantasy

#137
post #87

This is, in reality, probably less 'green' than living in a city. Multi-family homes tend to require less energy to heat and cool, because you share walls. You can also walk to many things, bike, or take transit. My bet is that most of the people living in these rural places aren't so into the 'rural lifestyle' that they don't own a couple of cars that they use for ... pretty much everything in life.

Although there is a lot of data to suggest that per capita green house gas (GHG) emissions from urban residents are less than rural counterparts this is not the entire story. Absolute GHG emissions and impact are higher for higher incomes. GHG emissions are a function of wealth not geography. Urban areas have much higher concentraions of wealth. They also outsource much of their GHG creation to rural areas but are st…

It's not clear that the relationship between urbanization and emissions in the third world is that strong when you exclude China.

Also, suburban lifestyles are by far the most carbon intensive. Transportation by car and heating/cooling large houses uses a ton of energy.

Re: 'Cottagecore' and the rise of the modern rural fantasy

#138

I love my backyard garden (even though my Brussels Sprout experiment this year proved to be a huge waste of time). I also love the aesthetic that cottagecore is revitalizing. I love drinking at local wineries, buying stuff at my local farmer's market, brewing beer and swapping bottles with homebrew friends, etc... But holy shit am I repulsed by the influencer aspect that is growing with this "movement". Ways of Seein…

Van lifers feel your pain. The instagram influencer skinny young cute blonde girl with painted toenails and backdoors open to reveal the grand canyon is a far cry from the reality that's 90% pooping in a composting toilet in a walmart parking lot and spending your entire weekend trying to install a water tank to supply a shower.

Re: 'Cottagecore' and the rise of the modern rural fantasy

#139
post #93

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yup, the time-honored tradition of the rich LARPing as the commoner is as alive as ever.

And I am reminded of Common People by Shatner https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=cMXhWf0vE7c

Shatner was covering the song, which was originally by the English band Pulp.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Common_People

Re: 'Cottagecore' and the rise of the modern rural fantasy

#140

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Lots of recent TV paints living in a large apartment building as a completely normal thing to do.

Living as a SINK/DINK? Yeah sure. Look at just about any show about raising children at or above the replacement rate and the vast majority are all in homes. Even the family in shameless had a home. The only counter example I can even think of is smilf.

Apartments are homes.

You're right that families with children living in multifamily dwellings are under-represented on American TV, but that's not because they are rare in real American life. I can think of a few examples of course, like "The Jeffersons", the whole premise of which is how their success led to moving from a house in Queens to an apartment in Manhattan.

Post reply on HN