Live data from Hacker News

Ananki: Software-defined Private Enterprise 5G

ananki.io

11–20 of 22 posts

Re: Ananki: Software-defined Private Enterprise 5G

#11
post #9

Why is no one talking about the privacy implications of 5G (and by no one I mean mainstream adoption efforts)? It feels like all the nutcase 5G conspiracy theories are to distract from the real issue at hand, which is that the legal and societal framework to handle the fact that you need a mobile phone to function in a modern society (keeps getting worse) and that 5G can be used to track your whereabouts with sometim…

The fact that this software is named "Big Brother" is pretty on point.

Re: Ananki: Software-defined Private Enterprise 5G

#12
post #5

I see a lot of buzzwords on this page. Can someone explain what's the actual benefit of this and why it's important?

tl;dr warehouses, factories and other places similar in size to a campus can create their own wireless network based on their 5G stack (vs WiFi, LoRa, 4G) to communicate between nodes, usually things like weather seasors on warehouse rooftops, robot telemetry on factory floors, etc

Re: Ananki: Software-defined Private Enterprise 5G

#13
post #5

I see a lot of buzzwords on this page. Can someone explain what's the actual benefit of this and why it's important?

tl;dr warehouses, factories and other places similar in size to a campus can create their own wireless network based on their 5G stack (vs WiFi, LoRa, 4G) to communicate between nodes, usually things like weather seasors on warehouse rooftops, robot telemetry on factory floors, etc

Thank you! Why can't they just say this. It actually makes a lot of sense and I would be interested, if it wasn't for all these non-sense buzzwords.

Anyway, thank you again for explaining.

Re: Ananki: Software-defined Private Enterprise 5G

#14

Earlier quoted context omitted.

tl;dr warehouses, factories and other places similar in size to a campus can create their own wireless network based on their 5G stack (vs WiFi, LoRa, 4G) to communicate between nodes, usually things like weather seasors on warehouse rooftops, robot telemetry on factory floors, etc

Thank you! Why can't they just say this. It actually makes a lot of sense and I would be interested, if it wasn't for all these non-sense buzzwords. Anyway, thank you again for explaining.

> Why can't they just say this.

I mean, they do. Go back and reread the first and last graphics.

Re: Ananki: Software-defined Private Enterprise 5G

#15

Earlier quoted context omitted.

tl;dr warehouses, factories and other places similar in size to a campus can create their own wireless network based on their 5G stack (vs WiFi, LoRa, 4G) to communicate between nodes, usually things like weather seasors on warehouse rooftops, robot telemetry on factory floors, etc

Thank you! Why can't they just say this. It actually makes a lot of sense and I would be interested, if it wasn't for all these non-sense buzzwords. Anyway, thank you again for explaining.

np, i'm in the space myself and am actively exploring vendors :) tbh there's not much in this space rn that's not a deep integration, so unless you're looking for it, the material can be a bit opaque

Re: Ananki: Software-defined Private Enterprise 5G

#16
post #9

Why is no one talking about the privacy implications of 5G (and by no one I mean mainstream adoption efforts)? It feels like all the nutcase 5G conspiracy theories are to distract from the real issue at hand, which is that the legal and societal framework to handle the fact that you need a mobile phone to function in a modern society (keeps getting worse) and that 5G can be used to track your whereabouts with sometim…

5G is nothing but marketing wank. Carriers aren't deploying some new sci-fi technology, they are just incrementally upgrading their networks to a more recent (and backwards compatible) revision of the LTE standard.

Re: Ananki: Software-defined Private Enterprise 5G

#17
post #5

I see a lot of buzzwords on this page. Can someone explain what's the actual benefit of this and why it's important?

tl;dr warehouses, factories and other places similar in size to a campus can create their own wireless network based on their 5G stack (vs WiFi, LoRa, 4G) to communicate between nodes, usually things like weather seasors on warehouse rooftops, robot telemetry on factory floors, etc

And does this include things like positioning? I remember some buzz around indoor positioning in 5G, but I'm hazy on whether it was built in, or just general speculation.

Re: Ananki: Software-defined Private Enterprise 5G

#18
post #17

Earlier quoted context omitted.

tl;dr warehouses, factories and other places similar in size to a campus can create their own wireless network based on their 5G stack (vs WiFi, LoRa, 4G) to communicate between nodes, usually things like weather seasors on warehouse rooftops, robot telemetry on factory floors, etc

And does this include things like positioning? I remember some buzz around indoor positioning in 5G, but I'm hazy on whether it was built in, or just general speculation.

i dont think any of the vendors claim positioning capability solely on 5G in their published literature, their engineers whisper about interesting demos with stuff "around the corner", but I'd take that with a grain of salt

you'd need at least three nodes apparently :)

Re: Ananki: Software-defined Private Enterprise 5G

#19
post #9

Why is no one talking about the privacy implications of 5G (and by no one I mean mainstream adoption efforts)? It feels like all the nutcase 5G conspiracy theories are to distract from the real issue at hand, which is that the legal and societal framework to handle the fact that you need a mobile phone to function in a modern society (keeps getting worse) and that 5G can be used to track your whereabouts with sometim…

Also pretty much every car in a few years will be connected all time, so someone somewhere will always have the means to monitor its position, visited places, conversations, etc. There's no solution; in just a couple decades we transitioned from local private unconnected CCTV (shops, malls, etc.) to pervasive government surveillance in cities, and we adapted to it; from this to drones with cameras flying and connecte…

I know what you say is possible but that's my point. That's why we have laws. The government and corporations/feudals use to be able to do a lot worse but now we have laws and enforcement of those laws.

Re: Ananki: Software-defined Private Enterprise 5G

#20
post #9

Why is no one talking about the privacy implications of 5G (and by no one I mean mainstream adoption efforts)? It feels like all the nutcase 5G conspiracy theories are to distract from the real issue at hand, which is that the legal and societal framework to handle the fact that you need a mobile phone to function in a modern society (keeps getting worse) and that 5G can be used to track your whereabouts with sometim…

5G is nothing but marketing wank. Carriers aren't deploying some new sci-fi technology, they are just incrementally upgrading their networks to a more recent (and backwards compatible) revision of the LTE standard.

5G is a generation of cellular network tech that allows higeher frequency and more spread out (oversimplifying a bit) cell "towers". Even if you don't use 5G (or any tech at all) it can be used to track your movement with good precision.
Post reply on HN