Live data from Hacker News

Congratulations, Mini, you made the stupidest turn signals ever

jalopnik.com

71–80 of 448 posts

Re: Congratulations, Mini, you made the stupidest turn signals ever

#71
post #11

So the left turn signal is an arrow pointing to the right? And the right turn signal is an arrow pointing to the left? How does that pass, well, anything at all without someone saying “that might not be the best idea”!

How could anyone be confused? They’re on the side the car is turning - like every other turn signal you’ve seen in your entire life.

I had to just laugh at your comment. It’s either brilliant sarcasm or you just might be the guy that designed this.

Re: Congratulations, Mini, you made the stupidest turn signals ever

#72

Earlier quoted context omitted.

How could anyone be confused? They’re on the side the car is turning - like every other turn signal you’ve seen in your entire life.

The article talks about this: "Now, I think the vast majority of drivers will understand what’s going on and treat them as normal blinking turn indicators, but these indicators hurt your brain, at least a little bit" I think you are interpreting "confused" as "I can't tell which way the car is turning", while everyone else is talking about "This UX forces me to use my brain when I shouldn't have to".

I guess I don't know what the author thinks they mean about 'hurt your brain'.

Re: Congratulations, Mini, you made the stupidest turn signals ever

#73
In Psychology there is Stroop Effect. Remember the funny game when asked to name the color of the word it takes longer and is more prone to errors when the color of the ink does not match the name of the color? I guess this design can only happen because no regulator thought that a car manufacturer could be THAT dumb.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stroop_effect

Re: Congratulations, Mini, you made the stupidest turn signals ever

#74

How hard is it to go: oh, the left hand side indicator is blinking. It's possible they might turn left. It's common bloody sense. This is honestly manufactured outrage.

> oh, the left hand side indicator is blinking. It's possible they might turn left.

Not hard at all, which is why this isn't a problem if you have enough time to think all that.

This is a problem in the tiny minority of cases where it's night, it's raining, you're either going too fast or maybe blinded by someone's high beams and all your brain can process in a split second is BLINKING ARROW LEFT.

Re: Congratulations, Mini, you made the stupidest turn signals ever

#75

My humble take: it's actually not meant to be an arrow - although it does indeed look like one - but the part of the embedded Union Jack that lights up.

I mean, that’s not a humble take, that’s what the article is about. That the use of the Union Jack has had the side effect of making the lights into arrows, but on the wrong side (when seen as arrows, which is a natural interpretation). Not that they were intended to be arrows.

Re: Congratulations, Mini, you made the stupidest turn signals ever

#76

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The article talks about this: "Now, I think the vast majority of drivers will understand what’s going on and treat them as normal blinking turn indicators, but these indicators hurt your brain, at least a little bit" I think you are interpreting "confused" as "I can't tell which way the car is turning", while everyone else is talking about "This UX forces me to use my brain when I shouldn't have to".

I guess I don't know what the author thinks they mean about 'hurt your brain'.

Sure, go ahead and play stupid.

Re: Congratulations, Mini, you made the stupidest turn signals ever

#77
post #71

Earlier quoted context omitted.

How could anyone be confused? They’re on the side the car is turning - like every other turn signal you’ve seen in your entire life.

I had to just laugh at your comment. It’s either brilliant sarcasm or you just might be the guy that designed this.

No not joking. They seem to follow the same predictable pattern as every other turn signal I've ever seen. Not sure what the fuss is.

Re: Congratulations, Mini, you made the stupidest turn signals ever

#80
post #43

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What if it’s dark outside. Is that a motorcycle? I can’t tell. I guess that motorcycle is turning left.

If it’s dark, both rear red lights will be on. It could be motorcycles, if they are really close together but that sounds unlikely.

What I failed to articulate (I can’t get my brain to boot this morning) is that a decent amount of motorcycles use arrows as their turn indicators. When I see a blinking arrow at night, I assume it’s a bike.
Post reply on HN