Live data from Hacker News

File picker meme

wiki.installgentoo.com

51–60 of 130 posts

Re: File picker meme

#51
post #14
post #12

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I’ll take good faith bugs and missing features over the pathological psycho warfare in closed software any day of the week.

I think that the point here is that this is anything but a "good faith bug".

How is that the point? GNOME is an understaffed and underfunded project.

Re: File picker meme

#52
post #2

This "meme" is the core of most useless, destroying DE wars in the Linux community. An example of how such a limited case can fuel beliefs of one desktop being "better" than the other, and the latter being something to continuously joke on. The lack of collaboration between desktops is, in my opinion, at the core of the fragmentation that makes Linux desktops still appear so far from their proprietary counterparts. T…

>Linux desktops

Linux is a kernel.

Re: File picker meme

#56

I hopped off the GNOME train a few months ago, v40 was just too much, too fast, and will likely leave the ecosystem pretty broken for the considerable future. However, I still really like GTK (even prefer it over QT, in many ways) and have full faith that the Linux desktop will push through. What concerns me is the hypocrisy of the modern GNOME team and how little they listen to the actual community using their DE. T…

>What concerns me is the hypocrisy of the modern GNOME team and how little they listen to the actual community using their DE.

Please remember: GNOME is a loosely connected group of volunteers all working on what they want to work on. If one person says they're prioritizing something and another person says they're going to do something else, that's not hypocrisy, that's just a difference of opinion. I know it may be confusing when one person says one thing and another person says something different but this is something you have to get used to in open source, it's not like a company where the CEO tells everyone what to do. Some developers may choose to listen to certain community members and may choose to ignore other community members, sadly that has to happen in any project where the wider community outnumbers the developers. Every interested person can't get their way all the time because resources are limited.

>They claim to respect your freedom, but force you to use Flatpaks and obfuscate their own code to prevent you from getting consistent app theming

This statement doesn't make sense to me. Flathub lists the license of the program and most packages are open source. And I have no idea what you mean by "obfuscate their own code" or "consistent app theming", could you elaborate? The suggested way to get consistent app theming is to stick with the Adwaita theme, if you're installing custom themes then that's guaranteed to be inconsistent.

>Here's hoping they can iron out all of the (many, many) issues before the next major release.

If there are issues that you want to see fixed, the best way to help that would be to contribute.

Re: File picker meme

#57
post #52
post #2

This "meme" is the core of most useless, destroying DE wars in the Linux community. An example of how such a limited case can fuel beliefs of one desktop being "better" than the other, and the latter being something to continuously joke on. The lack of collaboration between desktops is, in my opinion, at the core of the fragmentation that makes Linux desktops still appear so far from their proprietary counterparts. T…

>Linux desktops Linux is a kernel.

... and desktops running operating systems with a Linux kernel are called Linux desktops when it doesn't matter much which distribution is being discussed.

Re: File picker meme

#60
post #10

Earlier quoted context omitted.

On the Gnome bug tracker? Yes.

But why, I don't understand. These conversations need to be had somewhere, why not in a bug tracker where developer said they won't fix it? There already is an argument not to fix it, why can't others support fixing it?

Typically bug trackers are for tracking bugs; not having discussions about the direction of the project. In some open source projects feature requests in general are entirely off topic in the issue tracker (though I'm not sure if that's true for Gnome).
Post reply on HN