Live data from Hacker News

Australian gov to use facial recognition and GPS tracking to enforce quarantine

geospatialworld.net

1–10 of 205 posts

Re: Australian gov to use facial recognition and GPS tracking to enforce quarantine

#4
post #3

Citizens need to enforce and assert their rights there before it's too late.

Did you never learn that the definition of a government includes having a monopoly on violence?

Australia would essentially become a failed state with your suggestion, and I don't exactly think the government is just going to let that happen.

Re: Australian gov to use facial recognition and GPS tracking to enforce quarantine

#6
post #4
post #3

Citizens need to enforce and assert their rights there before it's too late.

Did you never learn that the definition of a government includes having a monopoly on violence? Australia would essentially become a failed state with your suggestion, and I don't exactly think the government is just going to let that happen.

If governments all had a permanent monopoly on violence we would all be forever living under the eternal dynasty of God-Emperor Hammurabi CCCXXIVI in the all-kingdom stretching from the Euphrates to all the sun has ever touched.

Sometimes you have to break the rules to make long-term positive changes.

Re: Australian gov to use facial recognition and GPS tracking to enforce quarantine

#7
post #4
post #3

Citizens need to enforce and assert their rights there before it's too late.

Did you never learn that the definition of a government includes having a monopoly on violence? Australia would essentially become a failed state with your suggestion, and I don't exactly think the government is just going to let that happen.

Armed rebellion is not always needed to make changes. However just letting the state do what it wants without push back certainly is not going to change things.

Re: Australian gov to use facial recognition and GPS tracking to enforce quarantine

#8
post #4
post #3

Citizens need to enforce and assert their rights there before it's too late.

Did you never learn that the definition of a government includes having a monopoly on violence? Australia would essentially become a failed state with your suggestion, and I don't exactly think the government is just going to let that happen.

Australia is already a failed state. That happened the second they decided to imprison their populace and started talking about the "New world order." The state has failed its people, and the only thing left is for it to crumble.

Re: Australian gov to use facial recognition and GPS tracking to enforce quarantine

#10
"... following a selective tender process in November"

Remarkably slow process given that we are dealing with a pandemic.

Worth pointing out that "Australian gov to use" should read "South Australian gov to use" (South Australia being a state of Australia).

EDIT: As this thread is attracting attention from people who have views different from my own I'd just like to make it clear that I'm in favour of controlling the actions of people who choose to endanger public health and nothing I said above is meant to suggest otherwise.

Post reply on HN