Live data from Hacker News

Adults with history of recreational cannabis use have altered speech production

sciencedirect.com

1–10 of 87 posts

Re: Adults with history of recreational cannabis use have altered speech production

#4
The title seems like a stretch since they then go on to say,

"Audio samples were analysed objectively using acoustic analysis for measures of timing, vocal control, and quality. Subtle differences in speech timing, vocal effort, and voice quality may exist between cannabis and control groups, however data remain equivocal."

"After controlling for lifetime alcohol and tobacco use and applying a false discovery rate, only spectral tilt (vocal effort and intensity) differed between groups and appeared to change in line with duration of abstinence from cannabis use"

Basically no acoustical difference, except in perceived effort. You'd get the same intensity out of a group of tired people too, but that oddly doesn't seem to have been compared in the study

Re: Adults with history of recreational cannabis use have altered speech production

#7
Do these folks study speech and know what to control for at all? Seems there are more critical confounding factors a study is likely to observe before psycho-active drug use is a significant factor https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2790192/

Re: Adults with history of recreational cannabis use have altered speech production

#8
post #4

The title seems like a stretch since they then go on to say, "Audio samples were analysed objectively using acoustic analysis for measures of timing, vocal control, and quality. Subtle differences in speech timing, vocal effort, and voice quality may exist between cannabis and control groups, however data remain equivocal." "After controlling for lifetime alcohol and tobacco use and applying a false discovery rate, o…

> Basically no acoustical difference, except in perceived effort.

On the data points measured. It's easy to observe things like "heavy cannabis users tend to have flat affect," but very difficult to translate "flat affect" into something measurable.

Look at the way that Alex Grey or Terence McKenna talk. There is clearly something going on there, regardless of our ability to measure it.

Post reply on HN