Live data from Hacker News

The United States of Comedy: 2035 (2012)

vanityfair.com

21–22 of 22 posts

Re: The United States of Comedy: 2035 (2012)

#21
post #3

I always wondered what stew of genetics and upbringing makes someone extremely funny. Its actually a pretty rare trait for someone to be 'professional quality' funny as evidenced by going to a few open mic nights. I think a lot of people want to be funny and the hustle is admirable, but I wonder if professional comedy is an inherent talent not something you can just read a book about. Still you don't know if you don'…

I'm married to a working comedian and know many. Everybody sucks when they start, and open mics are kind of built for people, even pros, to bomb at as they develop material. The people who seem "effortlessly funny" often work the hardest - although often that practice is developed in childhood.

What percentage of people do you see becoming professionally funny to pay the bills from comedy?

From the open mic's I went to there was a very minscule percentage of them and most had been trying for ages.

Not sure it boils down 'just work hard'.

Re: The United States of Comedy: 2035 (2012)

#22
post #10

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Exactly this. Bill Burr spent many, many years as an opener for other people way less funny than him. Dave Chappelle was in several bit parts and pilots before Half Baked. Richard Pryor was a writer for several years before even starting stand up. George Carlin in his early career is not the Carlin you may have seen, in the ~mid-70s after about a decade he completely changed his look and act. It may take a long time…

Chappelle is an interesting example here. He was doing standup on TV and staring in a Mel Brooks movie before he turned 20. But he also wasn't an overnight success. He supposedly started standup at 14 and spent years honing his craft before most comedians even start their career. Most comics I have heard talk about it say a person needs to do standup for 5-10 years before even naturally funny people actually become g…

Being a funny person is the pre requisite.
Post reply on HN