Live data from Hacker News

Squats can boost brain activity [video]

bbc.com

51–60 of 222 posts

Re: Squats can boost brain activity [video]

#51
post #6

Funny how people become obsessed with specific movements, specific exercise styles, etc. I’ve done it all including becoming obsessed with Mark Rippetoe and the derivatives, cardio like running and mountain biking, swimming 2km a day (80 lengths) etc. The one thing that has absolutely transformed my life is yoga. No more back pain, insane strength I never had, no more injuries from eg lifting a 100 lbs propane tank a…

Interesting- The benefits you mention are primarily physiological. I would argue that if building strength, clarity, and focus is someone's main goal then this could be just as easily achieved by regular routine exercise like a calisthenics or bodyweight program with a healthy diet to boot. At least this way you can realise the benefits much quicker than a year or two. I can't speak to the rewarding 'zen' nature of Y…

Oof. Watch out for anything with 'zen' in it. There's a lot of bull around yoga classes and yoga people. If you just do yoga, breathe and focus on the breath, you are meditating. Simple as that. The rest is just branding and bullshit, to be avoided.

As someone who used to lift and absolutely loved it, I wanted to try to explain the difference between lifting and yoga.

Lifting is awesome and I used to absolutely love it. I also found it somewhat meditative. It was my unwind time. I miss it. What I didn't get from lifting is the diversity that yoga brings in terms of strengthening far more muscles, while also giving you flexibility.

I'm trying to think of a pose I can give you, but I worry that if you just dive in and try it you could injure yourself. The good yoga routines will start you off very slowly with breath, then some light stretching, then sun salutations, and then into the harder poses. It is those harder poses that give you this kind of "diversity of strength" I'm describing.

An example of a pose that isn't that hard to do, but strengthens muscles that lifting rarely works is half moon pose: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ardha_chandrasana

Yoga is usually a flow, and a well designed flow will alternate between exerting muscles and then stretching those same muscles that you were exerting while exerting the ones you were stretching. That way you get strength and flexibility.

I don't have a gym near me anymore (I live on a small island) but I suspect that the combination of yoga and a killer lifting routine could do unbelievable things for your strength, flexibility and overall aesthetics, while helping you lift way heavier while avoiding injury. Just a thought. Best of luck!!

Re: Squats can boost brain activity [video]

#52

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'd actually encourage everyone here to avoid classes. There has been quite a bit of controversy around instructors exploiting students for money or otherwise. The culture is a bit zany. And there's pressure to become an instructor which requires spending more money. But primarily, classes are inconvenient. Do it on your own and you can just roll out of bed and straight onto the mat, and 30 mins later you're done and…

I have mixed feelings about this. I’d agree that most places that offer yoga aren’t all that great — just today I saw a photo of a local (NYC) yoga class and the teacher was teaching the posture (standing bow) all wrong and everyone in the class had seriously messed up alignment. And some of the corporate chains have been known to push people into teacher trainings. But there’s nothing like having a great teacher gui…

Agreed. Great teachers of any subject are so hard to find. I too feel fortunate for the few I've encountered.

Re: Squats can boost brain activity [video]

#53
post #14

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Look for a yoga class with power, core, ashtanga or vinyasa in the name. Avoid hatha.

I'd actually encourage everyone here to avoid classes. There has been quite a bit of controversy around instructors exploiting students for money or otherwise. The culture is a bit zany. And there's pressure to become an instructor which requires spending more money. But primarily, classes are inconvenient. Do it on your own and you can just roll out of bed and straight onto the mat, and 30 mins later you're done and…

How do you know what to without an instructor though?

I was not born with an innate knowledge of how to do yoga :)

Re: Squats can boost brain activity [video]

#54
post #9
post #6

Funny how people become obsessed with specific movements, specific exercise styles, etc. I’ve done it all including becoming obsessed with Mark Rippetoe and the derivatives, cardio like running and mountain biking, swimming 2km a day (80 lengths) etc. The one thing that has absolutely transformed my life is yoga. No more back pain, insane strength I never had, no more injuries from eg lifting a 100 lbs propane tank a…

I want to try Yoga after seeing this. could I just find any youtube instructors and follow along, or is it important to find "the right ones"? How would you approach starting out (must be online, wife won't let me leave the house because of covid)?

Isn’t the point of the comment that this person has just become obsessed with yoga like they’ve seen other people become obsessed with something else? Replace yoga with hop-scotch and would you still be excited to try it?

Re: Squats can boost brain activity [video]

#56
post #6

Funny how people become obsessed with specific movements, specific exercise styles, etc. I’ve done it all including becoming obsessed with Mark Rippetoe and the derivatives, cardio like running and mountain biking, swimming 2km a day (80 lengths) etc. The one thing that has absolutely transformed my life is yoga. No more back pain, insane strength I never had, no more injuries from eg lifting a 100 lbs propane tank a…

   Funny how people become obsessed with specific movements, specific exercise styles, etc. 
In the posted video, the researchers study all kinds of exercises and environments, and the effects on the brain. Squats, because you’re going with and against gravity, had particular benefits on the brain because of the decreased/increased blood flow to the brain during each squat cycle. They were particularly interested in optimizing the physical adaptation from exercise.

Re: Squats can boost brain activity [video]

#57

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Interesting- The benefits you mention are primarily physiological. I would argue that if building strength, clarity, and focus is someone's main goal then this could be just as easily achieved by regular routine exercise like a calisthenics or bodyweight program with a healthy diet to boot. At least this way you can realise the benefits much quicker than a year or two. I can't speak to the rewarding 'zen' nature of Y…

most yoga does plenty of things not accessed by 99.9% of bodyweight and calisthenics

Agree with this. After my first in person vinyasa class I was sore in surprising places.

Re: Squats can boost brain activity [video]

#58
post #9
post #6

Funny how people become obsessed with specific movements, specific exercise styles, etc. I’ve done it all including becoming obsessed with Mark Rippetoe and the derivatives, cardio like running and mountain biking, swimming 2km a day (80 lengths) etc. The one thing that has absolutely transformed my life is yoga. No more back pain, insane strength I never had, no more injuries from eg lifting a 100 lbs propane tank a…

I want to try Yoga after seeing this. could I just find any youtube instructors and follow along, or is it important to find "the right ones"? How would you approach starting out (must be online, wife won't let me leave the house because of covid)?

I liked yoga with Adrienne. Kind of bubbly but I felt like I learned alot and got decently flexible when I kept with it

Re: Squats can boost brain activity [video]

#59
post #6

Funny how people become obsessed with specific movements, specific exercise styles, etc. I’ve done it all including becoming obsessed with Mark Rippetoe and the derivatives, cardio like running and mountain biking, swimming 2km a day (80 lengths) etc. The one thing that has absolutely transformed my life is yoga. No more back pain, insane strength I never had, no more injuries from eg lifting a 100 lbs propane tank a…

You mentioned Rippetoe (Starting Strength). Did you leave it because you found flaws/issues with the program or you simply chose to switch to yoga.

I am about to start lifting again after being away for a couple of years. Back then I was training at a Starting Strength certified gym. I also did a seminar with Mark. For me this was an eye opener. Up until I was introduced to his book I failed at anything having to do with lifting.

I actually did yoga at a studio a couple of decades ago. I think they called it hot yoga or something like that. It was hard work. I definitely enjoyed it.

I am puzzled about the potential combination of Starting Strength style training with a supplement of the right kind of yoga.

Re: Squats can boost brain activity [video]

#60
post #14

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Look for a yoga class with power, core, ashtanga or vinyasa in the name. Avoid hatha.

I'd actually encourage everyone here to avoid classes. There has been quite a bit of controversy around instructors exploiting students for money or otherwise. The culture is a bit zany. And there's pressure to become an instructor which requires spending more money. But primarily, classes are inconvenient. Do it on your own and you can just roll out of bed and straight onto the mat, and 30 mins later you're done and…

Many pilates instructors are recovering yoga zealots.
Post reply on HN