Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Why is Reddit so slow and unreliable?

news.ycombinator.com

41–48 of 48 posts

Re: Ask HN: Why is Reddit so slow and unreliable?

#41
post #5

Well their JavaScript "new" site sucks so horribly that it even brings my heavy gaming PC to its knees. Clearly they have no clue what they're doing (probably at management level, even bad devs can do better than this) or they have a ton of legacy code they're trying to write around. But even the old one had its issues. Deep threads with thousands of posts would often crash when you clicked the "read more" to go deep…

There are many frontend issues for sure. But I just don't understand why so many HTTP requests to the site fail. E.g. pages are simply blank about 20% of the time.

Yes it’s horrible and when you look at the network tools there’s a crazy amount of requests flying around too

Re: Ask HN: Why is Reddit so slow and unreliable?

#42

They pay their engineers below and in cases half of market rates, place no organizational value on quality engineering, their CEO/head engineer is a buffoon and they have a history of screwing people with regard to equity compensation. It's not a complicated explanation at all.

Bring back Ellen Pao!

Re: Ask HN: Why is Reddit so slow and unreliable?

#43

They pay their engineers below and in cases half of market rates, place no organizational value on quality engineering, their CEO/head engineer is a buffoon and they have a history of screwing people with regard to equity compensation. It's not a complicated explanation at all.

I don't think this should reasonably be pinned on engineer remuneration. If you were advertising for "top performance tuning experts", it's fair they may not get them. But every criticism regarding root issues with the site (dark patterns pushing the app, AMP pages that don't load any content, loading screens that don't load anything, pages that almost seem deliberately broken) are really not the sort of things you associate with someone who "worked hard on performance but wasn't skilled enough". I would generally expect if they doubled their rates they'd get better ad targeting and investments in a range of places that aren't "faster websites".

Re: Ask HN: Why is Reddit so slow and unreliable?

#45

Reddit should be a quarter page box in a social psychology book about groupthink. It’s a shit website and there are better link aggregators.

Reddit does what it does very well. Any community that gets past a certain size is going to suffer the same problems. A lot of front page subs like /r/funny or whatever are overwhelmed with noise. The specialty communities around a game or hobby or industry are frequently great. Invaluable in some cases.

Re: Ask HN: Why is Reddit so slow and unreliable?

#47
post #45

Reddit should be a quarter page box in a social psychology book about groupthink. It’s a shit website and there are better link aggregators.

Reddit does what it does very well. Any community that gets past a certain size is going to suffer the same problems. A lot of front page subs like /r/funny or whatever are overwhelmed with noise. The specialty communities around a game or hobby or industry are frequently great. Invaluable in some cases.

> The specialty communities around a game or hobby or industry are frequently great.

Are they ? The subreddits for the games I play are 80% posts of people who wrote their question on reddit instead of google.

Re: Ask HN: Why is Reddit so slow and unreliable?

#48
post #35
post #20

Use the API via the mobile app RIF (Reddit Is Fun) for Android and avoid the site's anti-usability-patterns like the plague. * https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.andrewshu....

Doesn’t help me. I don’t have android.

Apollo and Narwahl are popular iOS clients.
Post reply on HN