Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: An infinite record playlist of out-of-copyright works

locserendipity.com

61–70 of 87 posts

Re: Show HN: An infinite record playlist of out-of-copyright works

#61

Not infinite, there's only 29816 items in the list ;) But seriously, really awesome! Thanks for this :)

They just have to keep adding new items faster than you can listen to them!

Is that even possible though? Copyright expires after 100+ years these days. We'll probably be dead before we see new works enter the public domain. Assuming the monopolists don't extend it even more.

Re: Show HN: An infinite record playlist of out-of-copyright works

#62
post #58
post #54

You realize how much you're a product of your time, when you hear a piece of music being played[1] and your first thought is that it must be satire. I'm so used to music from that era being satirized (e.g. in the Fallout games) that my mind had a hard to accepting that something like that could be sung unironically. [1] https://ia601004.us.archive.org/2/items/78_im-looking-over-a...

It's been years, and I'm still very suspicious about this one: https://youtube.com/watch?v=WIfcKy-VcXo

Turns out, my spider-sense wasn't off. Here is an interesting comment from YT by "stephen wallin":

As so many query whether the Lyrics were understood in the 1920's I got a friend to check BBC archive and the record was never broadcast on the radio, indicting deep problems, and a note still exists that it was banned for sexual innuendo. So the double entendre was fully noticed as soon as the disk came out. It however sold well!! There was a market for such disks, many dance bands did them, notably Bill Cotton. Harry Roy was noted as having a wicked sense of fun, he loved playing prank versions of songs. You have to appreciate that the English audiences loved such lyrics and jokes, Max Miller made a whole career on such comic material.

Re: Show HN: An infinite record playlist of out-of-copyright works

#63
post #53

Congratulations, very cool. BUT... I can't help but feel this is an... impolite? ... use of archive.org? I see archive.org as being a repository, not a streaming service. I would rather they spent their money on content ingestion and resilient content storage, not on having to scale up their outbound bandwidth capacity. What would polite look like? Download the content off archive.org, then stream it from your own se…

[deleted]

Re: Show HN: An infinite record playlist of out-of-copyright works

#64
post #54

You realize how much you're a product of your time, when you hear a piece of music being played[1] and your first thought is that it must be satire. I'm so used to music from that era being satirized (e.g. in the Fallout games) that my mind had a hard to accepting that something like that could be sung unironically. [1] https://ia601004.us.archive.org/2/items/78_im-looking-over-a...

You just need to listen to more WKHR! (wkhr.org) It’s a radio station in a Cleveland high school with octogenarian djs playing 78s!

Thanks for this! Really enjoying the music and DJs.

Re: Show HN: An infinite record playlist of out-of-copyright works

#65
post #53

Congratulations, very cool. BUT... I can't help but feel this is an... impolite? ... use of archive.org? I see archive.org as being a repository, not a streaming service. I would rather they spent their money on content ingestion and resilient content storage, not on having to scale up their outbound bandwidth capacity. What would polite look like? Download the content off archive.org, then stream it from your own se…

Is it not possible that downloading every such song from IA would have had higher bandwidth usage than all of this service's streaming so far?

Re: Show HN: An infinite record playlist of out-of-copyright works

#66
post #65
post #53

Congratulations, very cool. BUT... I can't help but feel this is an... impolite? ... use of archive.org? I see archive.org as being a repository, not a streaming service. I would rather they spent their money on content ingestion and resilient content storage, not on having to scale up their outbound bandwidth capacity. What would polite look like? Download the content off archive.org, then stream it from your own se…

Is it not possible that downloading every such song from IA would have had higher bandwidth usage than all of this service's streaming so far?

I agree, I don't think this is a impolite usage of Internet Archive's resources. I think they would love it. Though I also agree that putting a donation link to the source is also a good idea.

Re: Show HN: An infinite record playlist of out-of-copyright works

#67
I love this! I previously used Parker Higgens' 78 sampler twitter bot to discover new entries in the collection, but I really like your autoplay/jukebox feature.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26123888

https://twitter.com/78_sampler

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26124267

Re: Show HN: An infinite record playlist of out-of-copyright works

#68
post #65
post #53

Congratulations, very cool. BUT... I can't help but feel this is an... impolite? ... use of archive.org? I see archive.org as being a repository, not a streaming service. I would rather they spent their money on content ingestion and resilient content storage, not on having to scale up their outbound bandwidth capacity. What would polite look like? Download the content off archive.org, then stream it from your own se…

Is it not possible that downloading every such song from IA would have had higher bandwidth usage than all of this service's streaming so far?

Well, you could certainly just download from archive.org for the first-time usage of any particular song and then cache them from there. Like being your own CDN.

Re: Show HN: An infinite record playlist of out-of-copyright works

#69
post #58
post #54

You realize how much you're a product of your time, when you hear a piece of music being played[1] and your first thought is that it must be satire. I'm so used to music from that era being satirized (e.g. in the Fallout games) that my mind had a hard to accepting that something like that could be sung unironically. [1] https://ia601004.us.archive.org/2/items/78_im-looking-over-a...

It's been years, and I'm still very suspicious about this one: https://youtube.com/watch?v=WIfcKy-VcXo

More info here:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/My_Girl%27s_Pussy

Re: Show HN: An infinite record playlist of out-of-copyright works

#70
post #55
post #53

Congratulations, very cool. BUT... I can't help but feel this is an... impolite? ... use of archive.org? I see archive.org as being a repository, not a streaming service. I would rather they spent their money on content ingestion and resilient content storage, not on having to scale up their outbound bandwidth capacity. What would polite look like? Download the content off archive.org, then stream it from your own se…

donations are a fine thing, so is discovery, anything that helps to surface quality will long term perhaps help the archive prove its worth and ensure a positive attitude towards their endeavours.

Great idea! I added a donation link.
Post reply on HN