Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Why don’t you use Linux as your daily driver OS?

news.ycombinator.com

111–120 of 306 posts

Re: Ask HN: Why don’t you use Linux as your daily driver OS?

#111

I'm using Windows 10. In the past year I've tried: Manjaro, Fedora, Linux Mint and some others. Why I'm not switching? Because every time I login there is something that needs a quick update or a quick fix. After I've tried Fedora the last time, I turned on my PC and the resolution of my monitor switched to 800x600 from the 1920x1080. There was no way of setting it back to the correct resolution. "Well, you know, you…

I was attending my client conference when the invited speaker had his windows machine update right in the middle of his powerpoint presentation ! The whole room had to wait about 15 minutes for windows to finish its "important update".

(Of course he probably should have done it before and certainly ignored previous warnings. But it doesn't matter : the whole room of executive was wasting 15 minutes watching the speaker being angry at his machine)

To my knowledge, Linux would not do such a thing.

Re: Ask HN: Why don’t you use Linux as your daily driver OS?

#112

I have a laptop that dual-boots into Linux Mint. I haven't logged into the Linux side for ages. I like the Linux command line, but I get what I need via Git Bash for Windows. Also there's Windows Subsystem for Linux. Windows generally has better compatibility with hardware with less fuss. Especially on laptops. My friend tried to use Linux-only for a while, but he said trying to video conference just sucked. Sure, th…

> My friend tried to use Linux-only for a while, but he said trying to video conference just sucked.

As an FYI, for folks reading this, I spend at least half of every day in video conferences and this is largely a non-issue these days. The vast majority of platforms have web-based clients that work great, and many have native clients that are quite good as well. The biggest issue is probably screensharing on Wayland, which can be fiddly to get working and is subject to client issues, so stick with Xorg if you can.

In terms of hardware, I just end up buying gear designed to work with Linux rather than trying to make Linux work on a random piece of equipment. That means typically Dell or Lenovo, though newcomers like Framework are also prioritizing Linux support.

If you're using just random gear, older is better, as Linux support comes eventually but it often lags.

Edit:

By the way, I have to say, I've appreciated a lot of the comments in this thread. While I don't myself have the deep affection for the mac trackpad, and so can't really comment on that experience, everything else in this comment thread absolutely rings true to me.

And I say that as a person using Linux as a daily driver!

Re: Ask HN: Why don’t you use Linux as your daily driver OS?

#113
post #106

It's primarily because I want things to consistently work as expected. Sure, macOS doesn't always work as expected, but compared to my experiences with various Linux distros, it does. Others have mentioned the trackpad experience, and that's a thing, but not a deal breaker for me since I use the keyboard a lot. Hardware quality is another issue, more important than the trackpad for me. MacBooks are built like tanks c…

Other than the recent M1s don't the previous ones run linux? The mbp's made until 2015 sure do.

No, they run MacOS (or OSX for older versions), a version of Unix. The M1s still run MacOS, just on a different type of processor hardware.

Re: Ask HN: Why don’t you use Linux as your daily driver OS?

#114
I would like to, but just always put off by various small things. I like the UIs available in linux and the free and open software. But often there is a difficulty, a nag, an issue to solve. And things don’t fit together, it’s lack synergy between its components. Hardware support is another difficulty- track pads like others said.

Tbh, I am looking to upgrade my laptop, and was thinking of going pure linux, but all these things are making me reconsider. I don’t want to buy a nice piece of hardware and then struggle to use it because of software compatibility. Yes I know there are Linux only systems with dedicated hardware, but tbh the hardware (system76 etc) isn’t as good as other options (that I can tell), and it locks me to linux. And yes, there are linux/windows laptops like x1 and xps, but I don’t want to buy Lenovo and I’ve had bad experiences with dell. So, I’ll probably end up going Apple and donating to some linux alternative to help forgive my sin of giving in.

Re: Ask HN: Why don’t you use Linux as your daily driver OS?

#115
post #106

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Other than the recent M1s don't the previous ones run linux? The mbp's made until 2015 sure do.

No, they run MacOS (or OSX for older versions), a version of Unix. The M1s still run MacOS, just on a different type of processor hardware.

I figure kreetx is referring to bootcamp'd intel Macs running full Linux.

Re: Ask HN: Why don’t you use Linux as your daily driver OS?

#116

In short: dependency hell. Whatever distro I used it is the same at one point in time: In order to run X-n, you need Y-n-1 but Y-n+1 is installed and needed by Z. Next: sleep mode and or the not recovering from it. Linux is GREAT for tinkering, love it on my single purpose Raspis, love a dedicated VM/Laptop with Kali. But I will never again switch away from my macOS that just works for the job I need to get done.

What distro were you running? It's pretty rare to encounter this on Debian or Ubuntu unless you're running an unstable release and are encountering package breakage...

Re: Ask HN: Why don’t you use Linux as your daily driver OS?

#117

Because I’m not a masochist. I use ubuntu for work, some issues I’ve encountered: * No sleep mode by default * Snap is cancer. When I’m sent a pdf, I cant open it directly because the current app is isolated and cant see that a pdf reader is installed. Same with all other app specific extensions. * Snap, again. Whenever I’m sent a file on Skype, I have to reboot; It overrides my $home directory and I cant open or acc…

That first one puzzles me. What do you mean "no sleep mode by default"? I've been running Linux on laptops for a few years now and this is the first I've heard of this...

Are you perhaps referring to hibernation?

Re: Ask HN: Why don’t you use Linux as your daily driver OS?

#118
I feel comfortable with any of the three major OSs. Currently my daily driver is macOS, though I do most of my dev work on a remote Linux machine.

I wouldn't switch from macOS to Linux because my previous experience is that Linux won't work well or be unstable (with updates) on some hardware—in my case, a laptop. I have been reading that the situation has improve, but honestly I don't want to risk it. In general, even in purely software land, updates haven't always been smooth.

Even if all these issues were resolved, I'd need additional motivation to go through the effort of switching.

Re: Ask HN: Why don’t you use Linux as your daily driver OS?

#120

I would like to, but just always put off by various small things. I like the UIs available in linux and the free and open software. But often there is a difficulty, a nag, an issue to solve. And things don’t fit together, it’s lack synergy between its components. Hardware support is another difficulty- track pads like others said. Tbh, I am looking to upgrade my laptop, and was thinking of going pure linux, but all t…

I learned that you gotta pick a boring Linux distro as your main OS. For me it's Kubuntu LTS. Sure, I've had small glitches like bluetooth headphone issues or flaky double screen support, but once you solve them, you're set for 5 years. At my age, I'll upgrade my main OS maybe 10-15 times at most.

I used to eagerly try the six-month releases, but I can't devote time to beta test anymore. Give me a boring, non-bleeding edge Linux, I can work with that.

Post reply on HN