Live data from Hacker News

Guide to Firefox Containers (2018)

thechiefmeat.com

11–20 of 142 posts

Re: Guide to Firefox Containers (2018)

#11
One issue I have when using containers is that if I have a non-containerised tab and I click a link in it that leads to Twitter, which I have a container for, a new tab opens in the container, but the current tab also switches to a Twitter tab with the click, clobbering my session/history.

Is this a bug or conflict with another setting or add-on?

Re: Guide to Firefox Containers (2018)

#12

One downside that I had hoped containers would fix was multiple accounts on AWS. Because of the way AWS handles the URL's for logging in I get: company1.signin.aws.amazon.com company2.signin.aws.amazon.com company3.signin.aws.amazon.com BUT FF only seems to remember the login/password for 1 of these at a time. I had hoped that putting them all in different containers would fix this but it appears that FF only matches…

I use different profiles for that... basically, I have multiple Firefox shortcuts, each using a different profile. You can also use containers with the profile to segregate things even more.

Re: Guide to Firefox Containers (2018)

#13

One downside that I had hoped containers would fix was multiple accounts on AWS. Because of the way AWS handles the URL's for logging in I get: company1.signin.aws.amazon.com company2.signin.aws.amazon.com company3.signin.aws.amazon.com BUT FF only seems to remember the login/password for 1 of these at a time. I had hoped that putting them all in different containers would fix this but it appears that FF only matches…

Have you considered using a password manager? With 1Password I'm able to save all logins for my AWS accounts and then just select the appropriate one when logging in.

Re: Guide to Firefox Containers (2018)

#14
Don't forget, you can still use multiple profiles. I have multiple shortcuts setup, each starting FF with a different profile. Within a profile, I use containers to further partition things.

edit: for instance, I have a 'banking' profile with containers for each bank, brokerage, etc. The profile is totally separate from my 'general browsing' profile, so nothing can be sniffed. And the containers allow me to partition off each service

Re: Guide to Firefox Containers (2018)

#15
post #8

Containers are great! But since the recent v.91 update screwed the tabs up so much, there's no quick visual way to scan and see which container-type each tab is. Great stuff, well done Mozilla! What's the point in being able to customise a container's appearance, including colour, if they're not described on the tab itself?

You might need to get your vision checked. Each tab in a container gets a colored top border. And it's sizeable.

Re: Guide to Firefox Containers (2018)

#16
The real gem is this extension: Temporary Containers

https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/temporary-con...

Basically every new tab is a new temporary container. Isolation all the time, by default. It's an added exercise for the reader, but you have to go into the settings of the extension and modify some of the mouse behavior. Basically if I want a link I click to share the same container as the parent, I Ctrl + Click. Left-clicking or middle-clicking is always a new temporary container.

Containers are so much more than cookie isolation.

Re: Guide to Firefox Containers (2018)

#17
post #10
post #8

Containers are great! But since the recent v.91 update screwed the tabs up so much, there's no quick visual way to scan and see which container-type each tab is. Great stuff, well done Mozilla! What's the point in being able to customise a container's appearance, including colour, if they're not described on the tab itself?

TreeStyleTabs... next to Containers, it is the only reason I still use FF, if FF drops support for either TreeStyleTabs or Containers there will be zero reason for me to continue using it.

Sideberry is TST with better perfomance, FYI.

Also, right there with ya - treed tabs is the only reason I stick with FF.

Re: Guide to Firefox Containers (2018)

#18
post #14

Don't forget, you can still use multiple profiles. I have multiple shortcuts setup, each starting FF with a different profile. Within a profile, I use containers to further partition things. edit: for instance, I have a 'banking' profile with containers for each bank, brokerage, etc. The profile is totally separate from my 'general browsing' profile, so nothing can be sniffed. And the containers allow me to partition…

What benefit do you get from starting another Firefox instance with a different profile compared to simply using a different container in the same instance?

Re: Guide to Firefox Containers (2018)

#19
post #6

Are containers still necessary? Does the Firefox built in privacy (Strict privacy protection policy) provide same or similar functionality?

I use containers to only use some google services while signed in. For instance I use gmail signed in but I google search in a separate container to not log that data in my account. I may be fooling myself and google can identify it anyway through my IP or something but it feels like I get a little extra anonymity.

duckduckgo is a thing, just sayin

Re: Guide to Firefox Containers (2018)

#20

Are containers still necessary? Does the Firefox built in privacy (Strict privacy protection policy) provide same or similar functionality?

Those are for different things. I use containers to log in to the same website with different accounts without having to switch browsers or open a new window. E.g., since Discord still doesn't support switching accounts in the year of our lord 2021, I have a container set up for the discord account I use for IRL stuff, and my personal account logged into the "vanilla" container. I can keep both discord tabs open side by side and get notifications from both.

Even for websites that allow switching accounts, I prefer to use containers especially if the accounts go across different "domains" of my life. If I must log in to something personal at work or vice versa, I generally use a container for that to keep them separate.

Post reply on HN