Live data from Hacker News

In Chile three border collies are planting seeds (2017)

ibtimes.co.uk

11–20 of 43 posts

Re: In Chile three border collies are planting seeds (2017)

#11
post #7
post #5

I've heard border collies are super smart. Glad they're taking the initiative to do something about the environment that humans have largely ignored.

As if border collies took the decision to do that by themselves.

...I'm confident the suggestion was very dry humor

Re: In Chile three border collies are planting seeds (2017)

#12

This isn't just good for the forests, this is good for the Border Collies! They love to work, and deprived of work they become a little bit insane. I've seen one run faster than cars doing 35mph (or more) and I've seen the same dog just go, go, go, go, go until it couldn't go anymore, and love every second of it. This is just fantastic on a lot of levels.

I got mine when I was 25. I couldn’t imagine doing it now in my 40s with a family in tow. They will wear you out. He owned my back seat and went everywhere. It was just prior to leash laws so he just walked freely but never left me/caused any issues. They’re brilliant but please be ready for the energy levels as it’s a lifestyle.

Re: In Chile three border collies are planting seeds (2017)

#13

I have to disagree with part of the subtitle: "Border collies Summer, Olivia and Das spend their days bounding through charred forests, unaware they're leaving a trail of seeds that could transform the landscape." [emphasis added] Border collies are not simple dogs who can learn tricks. Border collies want task lists . And as border collies often do, these three are accomplishing their task list better than I sometim…

I choose to believe these border collies are fully aware of what they're doing, and I'll die on that irrational hill.

[deleted]

Re: In Chile three border collies are planting seeds (2017)

#15
post #5

I've heard border collies are super smart. Glad they're taking the initiative to do something about the environment that humans have largely ignored.

The article says the people doing the re-planting in the area found a cool way for working-breed dogs to do what they enjoy while helping us help the environment recover. The dogs, unfortunately, did not undertake this task on their own, but I thought that when I read the title- thinking maybe they were catching some in their fur or pooping them out while playing or something. As an aside I love all dogs, but especia…

My dog (Aussie) is more than happy to catch a frisbee (backflipping along the way if need be), but still refuses to bring back a ball. I think simple retrieval can be too boring for such breeds, even with high value treats it's much more exciting for her to dash around the dog park herding the other dogs and leading parades than to just bring a ball back and forth.

I do see some collies who do simple retrieval at the park, but it requires their owners to be strict about the dog not playing with any other dogs and coming back immediately. Not a way I want to raise my pup.

Re: In Chile three border collies are planting seeds (2017)

#16

I have to disagree with part of the subtitle: "Border collies Summer, Olivia and Das spend their days bounding through charred forests, unaware they're leaving a trail of seeds that could transform the landscape." [emphasis added] Border collies are not simple dogs who can learn tricks. Border collies want task lists . And as border collies often do, these three are accomplishing their task list better than I sometim…

Yeah, these border collies are aware they have a job, and probably think wandering through forest and field is the best job ever.

Seriously, as if they couldn’t smell the seeds in their backpacks.

Re: In Chile three border collies are planting seeds (2017)

#17
I’ll be curious to see how this project turns out in the long term. In the US, old growth forests previously had a tree distribution that is very different from young growth and newer managed forests. The pattern used to be less dense, with taller bigger trees whose shade kept the nearest tree was further away. This has benefits in terms of fire resistance, limited spread of pestilence, etc. The healthiest young forests are actually manually thinned to achieve a desirable density where each individual tree can thrive rather than get crowded in. Depending on the environment young growth may also need regular assistance to fight invasive species and weeds until the tree is established, since the ecosystem would be out of natural balance (lacking trees, shrubs, animals, insect populations, etc).

Re: In Chile three border collies are planting seeds (2017)

#19
post #15

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The article says the people doing the re-planting in the area found a cool way for working-breed dogs to do what they enjoy while helping us help the environment recover. The dogs, unfortunately, did not undertake this task on their own, but I thought that when I read the title- thinking maybe they were catching some in their fur or pooping them out while playing or something. As an aside I love all dogs, but especia…

My dog (Aussie) is more than happy to catch a frisbee (backflipping along the way if need be), but still refuses to bring back a ball. I think simple retrieval can be too boring for such breeds, even with high value treats it's much more exciting for her to dash around the dog park herding the other dogs and leading parades than to just bring a ball back and forth. I do see some collies who do simple retrieval at the…

Yea I always went with 'If the dog is into it let's go' and none were really too interested in fetching. I could throw them a ball and most of the time I'd end up fetching it myself.

My last dog loved chasing stuff so a powerful-enough-for-daylight laser pointer was her favorite toy. If she heard the click she got so happy. As a bonus she could run as fast, far, and hard as she wanted, and I could relax a bit!

Re: In Chile three border collies are planting seeds (2017)

#20

This isn't just good for the forests, this is good for the Border Collies! They love to work, and deprived of work they become a little bit insane. I've seen one run faster than cars doing 35mph (or more) and I've seen the same dog just go, go, go, go, go until it couldn't go anymore, and love every second of it. This is just fantastic on a lot of levels.

It always saddens me when people get working dogs like border collies as pets without understanding their needs. Without constant stimulation they get bored and basically lose their minds. It’s really important to know what you are getting into.

I guess the same is true for intelligent birds like parrots or ravens . Most people don’t understand the level of commitment these animals need.

Post reply on HN