Live data from Hacker News

The Search for a Free/Open Source Mobile Operating System

blog.emacsen.net

91–100 of 156 posts

Re: The Search for a Free/Open Source Mobile Operating System

#91

My primary pain point, last time I did the research, was that UBPorts for example, doesn't support full-disk encryption. That might have changed by now, and I'm not sure about the others. But I'd say encryption-at-rest is a basic requirement for a privacy-enhancing OS.

Full disk encryption is insufficient even, iOS and Android have since moved to file-based encryption for increased security.

Re: The Search for a Free/Open Source Mobile Operating System

#92

What about some other projects beyond Android and Linux? Sailfish OS? Tizen? KaiOS? Technically even WebOS was open-sourced and still around as LuneOS, but its last update was Halloween 2019, so it's likely defunct.

Sadly it seems that everything is based on linux beyond Android. Wish there were more choices kernel-wise.

Truly, someone should try out NetBSD here...

Re: The Search for a Free/Open Source Mobile Operating System

#93
post #52

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I can recommend "Open Camera" for the Camera app, its very customizable and reliable.

I have used it in the past and its great, sadly it does not support the multiple cameras of my Motorola.

Current OpenCamera versions support multiple cameras if the OS exposes them.

Re: The Search for a Free/Open Source Mobile Operating System

#94
post #26

Switched to GrapheneOS with the Pixel 5. Email/Calendar integration works fine (K-9 Mail). Signal as instant messenger. Organic Maps as Map application. Replaced Apple Watch with GadgetBridge and a Mi 6 band (cheaper and I have easy access to all data, you need to sync once with their app after you get the key you can delete it ... did the setup on the iphone and copied out the key with a commandline python script fr…

If you selfhost miniflux you can access via the browser, which is a pretty great experience

Re: The Search for a Free/Open Source Mobile Operating System

#95
post #26

Switched to GrapheneOS with the Pixel 5. Email/Calendar integration works fine (K-9 Mail). Signal as instant messenger. Organic Maps as Map application. Replaced Apple Watch with GadgetBridge and a Mi 6 band (cheaper and I have easy access to all data, you need to sync once with their app after you get the key you can delete it ... did the setup on the iphone and copied out the key with a commandline python script fr…

You can use Google's camera application, which is optimized for the Pixels of course. I think it will probably work with the new sandboxed play services implementation, but there is a simpler way: https://github.com/lukaspieper/Gcam-Services-Provider

This is a stub implementation of what gcam needs and it works great. I believe, independent of sandboxed play services, GrapheneOS team plans to implement stub play services like this for all parts, not just those required by gcam.

Re: The Search for a Free/Open Source Mobile Operating System

#96
post #74
post #26

Switched to GrapheneOS with the Pixel 5. Email/Calendar integration works fine (K-9 Mail). Signal as instant messenger. Organic Maps as Map application. Replaced Apple Watch with GadgetBridge and a Mi 6 band (cheaper and I have easy access to all data, you need to sync once with their app after you get the key you can delete it ... did the setup on the iphone and copied out the key with a commandline python script fr…

I started using GrapheneOS today and was able to install the official Google Camera app through Aurora store (the only good camera app for pixels imho). As akc3n suggested in their comment, the installable sandboxed google play services fixes some of the compatibility issues that Graphene has had up till now. Obviously it's a tradeoff I'm making between privacy and a great camera, but I'm not logged into my google ac…

There is a simpler way: https://github.com/lukaspieper/Gcam-Services-Provider

This is a stub implementation of what gcam needs and it works great. I believe, independent of sandboxed play services, GrapheneOS team plans to implement stub play services like this for all parts, not just those required by gcam.

Re: The Search for a Free/Open Source Mobile Operating System

#97
post #26

Switched to GrapheneOS with the Pixel 5. Email/Calendar integration works fine (K-9 Mail). Signal as instant messenger. Organic Maps as Map application. Replaced Apple Watch with GadgetBridge and a Mi 6 band (cheaper and I have easy access to all data, you need to sync once with their app after you get the key you can delete it ... did the setup on the iphone and copied out the key with a commandline python script fr…

My favourite thing about the pixel 5 is the camera. I understand that they do a fair amount of software processing to make it so good. And most other apps don't let me use the wide lens. Is the experience as good on Graphene?

You can use Google's camera application, which is optimized for the Pixels of course. I think it will probably work with the new sandboxed play services implementation, but there is a simpler way: https://github.com/lukaspieper/Gcam-Services-Provider

This is a stub implementation of what gcam needs and it works great. I believe, independent of sandboxed play services, GrapheneOS team plans to implement stub play services like this for all parts, not just those required by gcam.

You can install gcam and just give it no permissions (especially network). It will chug along merrily.

Re: The Search for a Free/Open Source Mobile Operating System

#98
post #32

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Honestly, I don't understand the selling point of CalyxOS over LineageOS. Can you explain the differences? The website just seems to be a little mumble about Privacy without explaining the technological differences. As a daily driver, I'd recommend a setup of an official LineageOS device, combined with a set of Apps to increase the level of privacy: - AppWarden to check for trackers and loggers - RethinkDNS as a VPN…

> because Signal still requires microG or other Google Services for their auto backup, which I don't agree with. I never used Signal with GServices, so I don't know what you mean with auto backup, nevertheless I simply use the backup function and sync the backup folder with my cloud and it works fine for several years now. For me it seems like a hard constrain to use Telegram which is obviously less secure over Signa…

Signal auto-backup works fine without Google services. Just point it to some local folder.

Re: The Search for a Free/Open Source Mobile Operating System

#99
post #26

Switched to GrapheneOS with the Pixel 5. Email/Calendar integration works fine (K-9 Mail). Signal as instant messenger. Organic Maps as Map application. Replaced Apple Watch with GadgetBridge and a Mi 6 band (cheaper and I have easy access to all data, you need to sync once with their app after you get the key you can delete it ... did the setup on the iphone and copied out the key with a commandline python script fr…

I've found Flym https://f-droid.org/en/packages/net.frju.flym/ to be a decent RSS reader.

Re: The Search for a Free/Open Source Mobile Operating System

#100
post #4

Because many important apps (banking and other financial services, major shopping sites, most Authenticators ) don’t provide open source versions, I don’t see how this thing can end up be practical for daily usage. Maybe it can be useful for criminals, underground hackers, but not a normal person.

Banking apps &c. work fine on CalyxOS
Post reply on HN