Live data from Hacker News

Twitter starts to require login to view tweets

reddit.com

61–70 of 643 posts

Re: Twitter starts to require login to view tweets

#61

When Reddit started doing this it effectively broke my redditing habit. I know these things are annoying but for anyone who is trying to use social media less... Twitter, Reddit, and Instagram are almost unusable without their apps. They are basically useless if you dont sign in on the browser on your phone. It's great if you want to get off them.

I don't know my facebook password or save it on any of my devices save for the home pc for this reason.

Re: Twitter starts to require login to view tweets

#62

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's not just the design, it's the fact that it's buggy and frequently unresponsive. If it was well done I might be able to forgive them, but my phone tells me I have messages I can't see on the desktop even after I refresh the page.

It’s more buggy, less responsive, has less features and consumes more resources. Literally its only pro is that it looks pretty.

fewer features

Re: Twitter starts to require login to view tweets

#64
On top of it, it's not just a matter of creating an account because they get blocked within two minutes until you also give them your phone number, despite the registration pretends it's not required (because once you signed up, it's easier to trick people into giving up yet more information than asking for it upfront).

Re: Twitter starts to require login to view tweets

#65
I used to install browser extensions to make twitter and fb usage as un-user friendly as possible, to limit the time wasted reading useless nonsense on social media.

Great that twitter is doing it themselves !

I hope that interesting people, with relevant things to say, will leave those platforms and re-open blogs.

Re: Twitter starts to require login to view tweets

#66

Do they whitelist accounts of public officials? For instance, having the POTUS account behind an auth wall seems like a horrible practice.

It bothered from the other angle when POTUS started pushing Twitter as an important channel to keep up on what was going on because it's hardly ideal for that. My local government has similarly been making Nextdoor a de facto requirement if you want to know what's happening or want to give feedback (especially in an era of frequent town office closures).

I tend to favor minimal government but I think the USPS was an important outcome of the Constitution to fill the need for a universal and "official" communication channel. But their budget has been butchered, I get misdelivered mail all the time and the DMV tells me I'm not the only one in my town who never seems to get their mail, but there's no shortage of wasteful junk mail. If only I was confident we could nail the execution, I would love to see the Internet embraced as basic, universal infrastructure and an official government communication channel that's more reliable and less abused.

But I dream.

Re: Twitter starts to require login to view tweets

#67

When Reddit started doing this it effectively broke my redditing habit. I know these things are annoying but for anyone who is trying to use social media less... Twitter, Reddit, and Instagram are almost unusable without their apps. They are basically useless if you dont sign in on the browser on your phone. It's great if you want to get off them.

I almost hesitate to share these because I too found that Reddit's dark patterns were a large part of what helped me break that habit.

I recently discovered teddit.net which is a frontend for reddit with all dark patterns removed.

There is also an alternative front end for twitter called nitter.net that you can use the same way to avoid the app / login.

Re: Twitter starts to require login to view tweets

#68
post #39

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Login is typically disabled for crawlers.

How do they identify a crawler? Can a user not masquerade as a crawler somehow?

Sometimes they use user agents for this, but those are easily faked, so it's only done by websites that don't have comprehensive auth walls.

A more comprehensive method is based on ip ranges, say whitelisting traffic from Google and Bing. This gives you > 95% of search traffic as Google alone has >90%, and many various smaller search engines like Yahoo or DDG are Bing resellers.

On the other hand, a pure ip based check can be circumvented too. Sometimes you can view how search engines see a website through google translate. But places like LinkedIn have countermeasures for all of these circumventions.

Re: Twitter starts to require login to view tweets

#69

There’s a strange irony in Redditors complaining about this when Reddit has been rolling out the same sporadic login requirements (on mobile web) to view certain Reddit content. I suppose these angry Reddit commenters bashing Twitter aren’t seeing it because they’re logged in to Reddit. Just as with Reddit, there are workarounds to bypass this login requirement if you really want to. The users in that thread have som…

> There’s a strange irony in Redditors complaining about this when Reddit has been rolling out the same sporadic login requirements (on mobile web) to view certain Reddit content. My first thought when I saw the headline was, how long until the front page features this: Reddit starts to require login to view posts (twitter.com) Then I realized this has probably already happened a while ago. Such is the treadmill of s…

The modern internet: four websites each filled with nothing but screenshots from the other three.

Re: Twitter starts to require login to view tweets

#70
post #12

I’ve been able to hide the modal wall via the chrome DOM inspector (right click on parent element in markup view, click “hide element”). Not a great experience but if you really want to see a tweet it works.

Somewhere a Twitter employee is patching this now!

“Thanks for testing our feature without getting paid for it, suckers! Uh, I mean hackers.”
Post reply on HN