Live data from Hacker News

Samsung kills the cameras on the Galaxy Z Fold 3 if you unlock the bootloader

xda-developers.com

1–10 of 204 posts

Re: Samsung kills the cameras on the Galaxy Z Fold 3 if you unlock the bootloader

#4
It could be for compliance with Japanese law which forbids taking photos without a shutter sound? This in principle doesn't apply when you're not in Japan, but after unlocking Samsung has no way to tell.

Edit: reading the article about SONY (https://www.xda-developers.com/sony-xperia-android-pie-unloc...), DRM keys seems to be a more likely cause, which drcursor's comment also mentions.

Re: Samsung kills the cameras on the Galaxy Z Fold 3 if you unlock the bootloader

#6
post #4

It could be for compliance with Japanese law which forbids taking photos without a shutter sound? This in principle doesn't apply when you're not in Japan, but after unlocking Samsung has no way to tell. Edit: reading the article about SONY ( https://www.xda-developers.com/sony-xperia-android-pie-unloc... ), DRM keys seems to be a more likely cause, which drcursor's comment also mentions.

If this were the case, then why doesn't every phone have the same restriction? And why would it make its first appearance from a Korean company on a phone for the American market?

Re: Samsung kills the cameras on the Galaxy Z Fold 3 if you unlock the bootloader

#7
post #4

It could be for compliance with Japanese law which forbids taking photos without a shutter sound? This in principle doesn't apply when you're not in Japan, but after unlocking Samsung has no way to tell. Edit: reading the article about SONY ( https://www.xda-developers.com/sony-xperia-android-pie-unloc... ), DRM keys seems to be a more likely cause, which drcursor's comment also mentions.

If this were the case, then why doesn't every phone have the same restriction? And why would it make its first appearance from a Korean company on a phone for the American market?

Different legal opinions and Samsung being more risk-averse I guess?

However reading the article about SONY (https://www.xda-developers.com/sony-xperia-android-pie-unloc...), DRM keys seems to be a more likely cause...

Re: Samsung kills the cameras on the Galaxy Z Fold 3 if you unlock the bootloader

#8
I have one of these on the way and never intended to root it, but this outrages me.

I get that Samsung reserves the right to say "its been rooted and is now longer certified "safe" by us, but BREAKING the functionality of the device that I paid for and own is vandalism.

Re: Samsung kills the cameras on the Galaxy Z Fold 3 if you unlock the bootloader

#9
post #5

Could it be that the camera is directly connected to the security chip responsible for things like biometrics, payment, etc. and that unlocking disable it?

Somehow it does not make me feel better. I have hardware that becomes more restricted the moment I want to actually use it as I see fit.

Re: Samsung kills the cameras on the Galaxy Z Fold 3 if you unlock the bootloader

#10

I have one of these on the way and never intended to root it, but this outrages me. I get that Samsung reserves the right to say "its been rooted and is now longer certified "safe" by us, but BREAKING the functionality of the device that I paid for and own is vandalism.

> Re-locking the bootloader does make the camera work again, which indicates that it’s more of a software-level obstacle

My guess is that their camera supplier has a secret blob that they want to retain encrypted...

Post reply on HN