Live data from Hacker News

Many Americans not aware of being tracked with facial recognition while shopping

techradar.com

81–90 of 369 posts

Re: Many Americans not aware of being tracked with facial recognition while shopping

#81

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Linked to your wifi, paid by you

WiFi calling doesn’t use the device’s VPN settings? Even if it doesn’t, the poster said they also use a router VPN.

The phone number itself is linked to them in someway. Paying for your physical device in cash is meaningless if you’re gonna connect to internet you own and use credit cards, etc to operate it.

Re: Many Americans not aware of being tracked with facial recognition while shopping

#82

Wait till it can ID shoplifting, and people get added to a shared database of blacklisted shoppers. You can steal no problem, but one day you'll be approached and asked to leave upon entering almost anywhere.

When store employees are told not to physically detain any shoplifter, it hardly matters at all if they tell a serial shoplifter to leave the store. The shoplifter will walk around the confronting employee, grab whatever they like off the shelves, and walk out without paying for it. (I've seen this happen numerous times at 7-11, where the facial recognition is being run by store employees using their eyeballs/brains.…

At some point (at least on the east cost) you end up with legit armed private (or public, I can't tell honestly) security at the front.

Re: Many Americans not aware of being tracked with facial recognition while shopping

#83

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Normalize masks? Let them figure my face from that!

They're trying to recognize your face anyway. e.g. see https://pages.nist.gov/frvt/html/frvt_facemask.html It looks like the testing is still done in relation to synthetic masks, but I could see that shifting over time. Absolutely repugnant that the industry is targeting masked individuals, but it's happening none the less.

Mask, hoodie and a cooler and I'm sure they can't do crap. They can try gait but it's a losing proposition anyway.

Re: Many Americans not aware of being tracked with facial recognition while shopping

#84

And: if you have a smartphone in your pocket there will be attempts to couple your smartphone device ID to your mugshots from various angles.

How does that work? How do they get the ID? And is it location accurate enough that it would not get confused with another phone a few feet away?

Wifi and/or bluetooth media addresses, which are unique. I've heard that wifi tracks you to the store, bluetooth to the aisle in the store. A lot of people have all this enabled on their phones, right? Then there's the apps installed on so many phones that are built using facebook sdk's and similar that include a lot of spyware.

I have the impression that stores doing this are working with data aggregator to associate this information with other sources of info, like credit card purchases, facial recognition, phone number and imei, etc.

Re: Many Americans not aware of being tracked with facial recognition while shopping

#85
post #52

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I tried telling random adults on the main street in my University town that Target was using non-disclosed facial recognition, about four years ago, for a while. The rate of response was less than half for people to show concern. I also somewhat-randomly discovered a local "facial aware" security system installer at the coffee shop. Once he noticed I was asking pointed questions about consent, he changed his tone and…

> Weeks later I saw him driving by and rode my bicycle next to him in traffic making a scene while saying nothing that could be construed as a threat. He was a little shaken that time I hope. You tried to subtly threaten and shake up the owner of a local coffee shop, weeks later, as revenge for not entertaining your questions about the features of his security system?

Following somebody on the street is less threatening than filming them for lifelong worldwide tracking and profiling

Re: Many Americans not aware of being tracked with facial recognition while shopping

#86

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Stores used to make customers feel good about shopping there. Adding elements that make your store feel more like a prison don't help here.

I guess the management at those corporations is so bad they do not realize they are driving profits away by spending money to make it feel like a prison. Or management is using tons of experience and data to do what they have to do to stay in business in a 2% profit margin business, inconveniencing customers if they have to in order to prevent losses so they do not have to close the store.

I think it's on a store-by-store basis. My grandfather works at a Wal-Mart in a small town with a large minority population and said they average 10-12K in merchandise stolen each month. The store is open 24 hours, but they still only have 1 security guard working 9-5 because they'd lose more money from lost sales due to minority groups typically having bad experiences with authority figures and avoiding the store.

Re: Many Americans not aware of being tracked with facial recognition while shopping

#87
post #20

Walmart makes this rather obvious. I was walking down a medicine aisle the other day, and I looked up and saw my face on a screen with green lines outlining it.

Last time I was in a Walmart, it felt like they were doing everything they could to communicate they didn't want me to shop at their store. * Gates at the main entrances * Cameras everywhere * "Security" walking through the store in clearly marked uniforms * Self checkouts with UX that clearly communicates a lack of trust.

Apparently they have way too many customers. Business would be so great if it weren't for all the darn customers!

Re: Many Americans not aware of being tracked with facial recognition while shopping

#88

Wait till it can ID shoplifting, and people get added to a shared database of blacklisted shoppers. You can steal no problem, but one day you'll be approached and asked to leave upon entering almost anywhere.

When store employees are told not to physically detain any shoplifter, it hardly matters at all if they tell a serial shoplifter to leave the store. The shoplifter will walk around the confronting employee, grab whatever they like off the shelves, and walk out without paying for it. (I've seen this happen numerous times at 7-11, where the facial recognition is being run by store employees using their eyeballs/brains.…

Humans won’t detain anyone, but probably in the future there will be mechanistic countermeasures — e.g. the doors of the store just not opening for shoplifters (or at all, while shoplifters continue to be present — to prevent shoplifters from sneaking in ahead/behind a non-blacklisted customer.)

Unmanned stores in the Amazon Go mould are already switching from turnstiles to airlock-style entryways; these can easily recognize and deny shoplifters access. (Never mind that these stores also usually have some form of positive identification, e.g. a card tap or hand-print scan being required to enter; so it’d really just be a matter of blacklisting the account associated with your credential.)

There’s no reason that manned stores couldn’t adopt these more-strict entry access systems as well; manned stores just haven’t invested in such technology yet, because they don’t need it in the way unmanned stores do (where an unmanned store without an entry-access system could literally experience 100% “shrinkage”, if someone decided to back a truck up and start loading.)

Alternately, the facial recognition could just trigger a phonecall; which, combined with a simple policy that any car belonging to a shoplifter has no right to park in the lot, would mean that such cars would have a tow called on them the second the shoplifter gets out of their car and walks into view of a camera. This wouldn’t work in most of the world, but in the car-centered US, I could see it being a very effective deterrent.

Re: Many Americans not aware of being tracked with facial recognition while shopping

#90

Wait till it can ID shoplifting, and people get added to a shared database of blacklisted shoppers. You can steal no problem, but one day you'll be approached and asked to leave upon entering almost anywhere.

Even worse, wait until you somehow acidently find yourself on the shoplifter list. Who are they going to believe, the all knowing facial recognition algorithm, or the lying thief it just identified? What company is going to budget the time and manpower to bother checking?
Post reply on HN