Live data from Hacker News

What domain name to use for your home network

ctrl.blog

21–30 of 174 posts

Re: What domain name to use for your home network

#21

> Do not use undelegated domain names like .lan, .home, .homenet, .network, nor should you make up your own domain name. ...why? My DNS server, my rules, no? Why should I feel obligated to follow ICANN? Obviously, I'll need to make changes if someone ever registers the domain with ICANN (and I want to access the ICANN version), but other than that...

For what it's worth, this does work. For now.

The main issue is if it gets sold later, or assigned by RFC. As an example, more than one company I've worked for used .dev as a TLD for their dev environments, with local DNS to override it. Once google bought .dev, this meant that:

- we couldn't access anything Google put on .dev

- suddenly, all of our test sites had HTTPS forced, because .dev was HSTS preloaded by Google

The point here is that an unexpected change that you might not be aware is coming can break your setup in ways that are awkward to resolve - eg HSTS preloading means that you can no longer access non HTTPS endpoints unless you do it by IP and that leads to a frustrating afternoon - and it's inevitably always when you don't want it.

Like it or not, ICANN operates the DNS space. There's a proper way to get your own piece of this space, and you can run home or business networks under your own piece and you have a guarantee that no one will break you - because it's yours.

(edited for formatting)

Re: What domain name to use for your home network

#23

IMO the best approach is to register somedomain.com and use its subdomains. It’s guaranteed not to interfere with anything, you can get LE certificate, you can make it available from the Internet if necessary.

somedomain.com is not guaranteed not to interfere!

example.com is guaranteed not to interfere (and example.org)

http://www.iana.org/domains/reserved

Re: What domain name to use for your home network

#25
I just set static IPs for important things and put them in my domain. There's also MDNS although most of the MDNS responders are pretty fat for what they do. I tried hacking some basic MDNS stuff into busybox a few years ago but never cleaned it up and sent a patch.

Re: What domain name to use for your home network

#27
post #5

> Do not use undelegated domain names like .lan, .home, .homenet, .network, nor should you make up your own domain name. ...why? My DNS server, my rules, no? Why should I feel obligated to follow ICANN? Obviously, I'll need to make changes if someone ever registers the domain with ICANN (and I want to access the ICANN version), but other than that...

The issue here being: what happens when you have your proxy configured as "proxy.lan" but you make a typo when entering it in local DNS or in your browser settings? That DNS request for "proxy.lan" will now go all the way out to the root servers for every page load, multiple times. Not so important for you with your 200 tabs open, but quite important to the people maintaining the root servers who see a significant pe…

What if you make a typo on .home.arpa? e.g., .home.arps? How is that any different?

Re: What domain name to use for your home network

#28
post #23

IMO the best approach is to register somedomain.com and use its subdomains. It’s guaranteed not to interfere with anything, you can get LE certificate, you can make it available from the Internet if necessary.

somedomain.com is not guaranteed not to interfere! example.com is guaranteed not to interfere (and example.org) http://www.iana.org/domains/reserved

I believe you took their post too literally; they mean to go register some domain you would like to have (such as ilovemycoolhouse.com or bearinabigblue.house) and use it, because the only way it will ever interfere with something is if you cause it to.

Re: What domain name to use for your home network

#29
post #23

IMO the best approach is to register somedomain.com and use its subdomains. It’s guaranteed not to interfere with anything, you can get LE certificate, you can make it available from the Internet if necessary.

somedomain.com is not guaranteed not to interfere! example.com is guaranteed not to interfere (and example.org) http://www.iana.org/domains/reserved

in case it isn't obvious, OP is saying to use YOUR domain, not the domain 'somedomain.com'

Re: What domain name to use for your home network

#30
post #23

IMO the best approach is to register somedomain.com and use its subdomains. It’s guaranteed not to interfere with anything, you can get LE certificate, you can make it available from the Internet if necessary.

somedomain.com is not guaranteed not to interfere! example.com is guaranteed not to interfere (and example.org) http://www.iana.org/domains/reserved

[deleted]
Post reply on HN